Navigation Links
Baucus Co-Op Plan Would Gut State Laws; Consumer Watchdog Report Calls for 'Prior Approval' Rate Regulation in Health Reform, Not Deregulation of State Consumer Protection Laws

WASHINGTON, Sept. 8 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The consumer group that pioneered the most successful insurance premium regulation law in the nation, which has saved California drivers $62 billion on auto insurance rates since 1988, released a report today outlining the deep flaws in the proposed Senate Finance Committee health reforms. The report calls on Congress to adopt "prior approval" health insurance rate regulation and block insurance industry efforts to gut state consumer protection laws.

A "framework plan" released today by the so-called "Group of Six" Senators negotiating a health reform bill headed by Senator Max Baucus (D-MT) would open the door to gutting state laws. The plan would result in a "race to the bottom" in health care regulation by allowing insurance companies that participate in "health care compacts" to choose the weakest state law to govern all their policies, regardless of which state the policies are sold in. Currently, insurance companies must abide by the state laws of any state where they sell insurance. The Baucus plan resembles an industry proposal carried by Mike Enzi (R-WY) in 2006 discussed below.

Consumer Watchdog said that health insurance reform must include strengthened oversight of insurance companies and an assurance that consumers will be protected from price gouging, junk insurance and other unfair practices.

Download Consumer Watchdog's report, "Regulation, Not Deregulation: The Prescription for Lowering Health Costs Without Cutting Coverage (With or Without a Public Option)," at

The components of California's landmark property and casualty insurance regulation law, Proposition 103, include:

** A prior approval system for rates requiring insurers to seek permission from government regulators and justify rate increases. Since 1988, California's Proposition 103 has saved drivers $62 billion.

** An intervenor system that allows the public to challenge unnecessary premium hikes. Since 2003, Consumer Watchdog has saved $1.7 billion by challenging unnecessary premium increase and insufficient decrease requests using the public intervention process.

** An elected commissioner accountable to the public directly for premium hikes. To ensure that the reforms would be properly enforced, Proposition 103 made the insurance commissioner an elected position accountable directly to the voters, not to a politician who typically uses an appointment to reward the insurance industry for political support.

"Congress must require every state to adopt a similar prior approval system for health insurance rates. Any reform must require insurers to justify rate increases and allow the public to intervene," said Jerry Flanagan of Consumer Watchdog.

A 2008 Consumer Federation of America report detailing the savings of Proposition 103 can be downloaded at: A related press release is available at:

Deregulation: Hidden Co-Op Loophole?

Republican Senator Mike Enzi (R-WY), ranking Republican member of the Senate health committee, has spoken favorably about a proposal by Senator Kent Conrad (D-N.D.) to establish health insurance cooperatives ("co-ops"), to replace the "public option" in a national health reform plan. Enzi likened the co-ops to his 2006 proposal for "association health plans," embodied in his bill S. 1955, which would have exempted health policies from oversight by state laws and courts. The measure failed in the U.S. Senate.

The major problems of the Enzi approach to health insurance co-ops include:

** Loss of state benefit mandates would allow exclusion of preventive treatments and exams, prevent early diagnosis of disease and evade Patient Bill of Rights laws passed in nearly every state. Denying access to such basic preventive care makes treatment more costly to the policyholder and ultimately to taxpayers, who pick up the bill when individuals cannot pay outrageous out-of-pocket costs.

** State laws providing consumers the right to appeal a coverage denial to an independent panel of physicians, a right to a second opinion, and assistance from state regulators when coverage is denied would all be lost under the Enzi approach.

** Individual patients who currently have the ability to hold insurers financially accountable for injuries caused by the denial or delay of necessary care would lose those rights if they joined the Enzi co-op.

Legal Accountability: The Missing Link

The Consumer Watchdog report also discusses the need to increase the legal accountability of health insurance companies, a concept supported by Congressional Democrats in 2001 and championed by Senator Edward Kennedy. A 2001 bill authored by Kennedy passed the Senate but died in the House.

Currently, for patients who receive health coverage through a private employer, HMOs and health insurers face no financial consequences for mishandling claims. Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), lawsuits are removed to federal court where victims can only recover the cost of the procedure or service denied in the first place -- no damages or penalties are allowed. As a result, HMOs and insurers are largely free to deny access to care without fear of reprisal or financial consequences.

On June 19, 2001, Senator Kennedy gave his opening speech to Congress on S. 1052, which would have allowed patients to hold health insurers financially accountable when they cause harm. Kennedy told his Senate colleagues:

"Patients should have the right to hold their HMO accountable in court when its negligence causes the injury or death of a patient. No other industry in America enjoys immunity from accountability for its actions, and the insurance industry does not deserve it either. Few, if any, provisions will do more to guarantee that your HMO does the right thing than the knowledge that it can be sued if it does the wrong thing."

However, none of the health reform bills provide legal accountability of health insurers.

Consumer Watchdog is a nonpartisan consumer advocacy organization with offices in Washington, D.C. and Santa Monica, CA. Find us on the web at

SOURCE Consumer Watchdog
Copyright©2009 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Senators Baucus and Grassley Statement Regarding Physician Hospitals Despicable
2. National Medical Association Applauds President Obamas and Senator Baucuss Efforts to Work With PhRMA to Bring Down Health Care Costs and Advance Meaningful Reforms
3. Senators Baucus and Tester Vote to Protect Americas Kids From Tobacco
4. Coalition Commends Senators Baucus, Grassley for Including Prevention, Wellness of Chronic Disease in Recent Paper on Coverage Policy Options
5. Rarely Used Closed Doors Slammed Again in U.S. Senate Health Care Reform; Sen. Max Baucus Must Publicly Answer 10 Questions About Mandatory Purchase of Health Insurance
6. Sen. Max Baucus: Answer 10 Questions About Mandatory Purchase of Health Insurance Including Why the Public Was Excluded From Todays Committee Meeting
7. President Obama, Sens. Kennedy & Baucus: Dont Buy Insurer Compromise for Bush-era Plan to Gut State Consumer Protection Laws
8. National Long Term Care Leaders Praise Overall Baucus Health Reform Effort, Express Specific Concerns Moving Forward
9. Statement From Larry Minnix, President & CEO, American Association of Homes and Services for the Aging on the Release of Sen. Baucuss Health Care Reform Proposal
10. US Oncology Applauds Senator Baucuss Healthcare Reform Call to Action for 2009, Supports Collaborative Measures to Enhance Cancer Patients Access to Care While Improving Quality and Access
11. Poll Shows Baucus Individual Mandate To Buy Health Insurance Unpopular
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/10/2015)... York, NY (PRWEB) , ... October 10, 2015 , ... ... some alarming numbers on the growth of cybercrime costs for US companies. The New ... on Tuesday, October 6th. With averages showing increases hovering around 20% among the companies ...
(Date:10/10/2015)... , ... October 10, 2015 , ... Isabel Healthcare will ... , On the heels of the release of the Institute of Medicine’s latest report ... their integration with Cerner solutions that assist healthcare providers and consumers to potentially reduce ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... The American Osteopathic ... for Graduate Medical Education J. Michael Finley, DO, as the recipient of the ... for his impact on graduate medical education opportunities for osteopathic residents, and his ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... 2015 , ... A new health tool that helps identify if a sore ... ) – just in time for the cold and flu season, which the ... many in the U.S., the real start of cold/flu season is the start of ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... Dentist in Huntington ... orthodontic system that uses clear, plastic aligners. This alternative to braces has become ... which allow patients to complete treatment in privacy. Additionally, Invisalign aligners are removable, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
... serious problem that can often be fatal. Methadone has ... addicts. However, the major concern in treating heroin addicts ... is one reason methadone therapy is usually only given ... that an alternative drug therapy combined with psychosocial treatment ...
... researchers are currently testing the safety of hypothermia ... injury. Hypothermia treatment has been shown to be ... but its effectiveness in treating children with traumatic ... decreases inflammation, excitotoxicity (excessive neurotransmitters released with injury ...
... of skin cancer and it has been shown through previous ... sunlight, whose UV rays cause damage to DNA that triggers ... are more prone than others to melanoma. Researchers have now ... people with melanoma that those with fair skin// have lowered ...
... Affective Disorder(SAD) is not all that well understood, but ... sunlight in the winter months. Winter depression involves suffering ... days get longer and nights get shorter. Other SAD ... sleeping for longer than usual. Researchers have now found ...
... hospital in Kolkatta, India recently received a patient, a two-month-old ... suffering from a rare disease caused due to a deficiency ... of 10 million children. Doctors said that the baby was ... On detection the baby, a boy child, was found to ...
... time to its ultraviolet rays, has always been said to be ... shown that even moderate sun exposure can result in moles that ... to sun has been shown as the main risk factor for ... rarest type of skin cancer, is much weaker. It has however, ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:10/8/2015)... Oct. 8, 2015  Clariant, a world leader in specialty ... facility in Belen, New Mexico , has ... including desiccant canisters and packets and other ... plant is the second Clariant site – the first in ... the ISO 15378:2011 standards, following only the Clariant manufacturing facility ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... , Oct. 8, 2015  Nektar Therapeutics (Nasdaq: ... pain and oncology portfolio during an Investor and Analyst ... p.m. Eastern Time in New York City ... of the NKTR-214 Phase 1/2 clinical program and biomarker ... cytokine designed to preferentially stimulate the production of CD8-positive ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... a clinical stage drug development company focused on advancing ... today the commencement of the US arm of an ... acebilustat, in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF). The study ... the United States and European Union, ... 2016. This landmark clinical trial testing once-daily oral acebilustat ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
... Texas, Dec. 2, 2010 Ascension Orthopedics, Inc., ... another implantation of the TITAN™ Modular Total Shoulder. ... at Bucks County Specialty Hospital in Bensalem, Pennsylvania. ... postoperative x-rays showed a very anatomic replacement.  The ...
... 2, 2010 Medical devices, biotechnology and IT products ... will present to United States investors and the business ... business and investment opportunities. (Logo: ... successful Chilean Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) was selected ...
Cached Medicine Technology:
The IRN method used on the Dimension clinical chemistry system is an in vitro diagnostic test intended for the quantitative determination of iron in serum....
For the quantitative in vitro determination of Aspartate Aminotransferase (AST) in serum and plasma....
Enzymatic Clearance assay for the in vitro quantitative determination of HDL-cholesterol in human serum and plasma....
Immunoturbidimetric assay for the quantitative in vitro determination of Lipoprotein (a) in human serum or plasma...
Medicine Products: