Navigation Links
Balancing scientific freedom and national security
Date:1/19/2012

WASHINGTON, DC -- The U.S. government's request that the journals Science and Nature withhold scientific information related to the genetically modified H5N1 virus because of biosecurity concerns does not violate the First Amendment, say two Georgetown University professors. They caution, however, that a fair, transparent process undertaken by research organizations is preferable to governmental constraints on disseminating scientific information.

Writing in Science, John D. Kraemer, JD, MPH, assistant professor of health systems administration at Georgetown University School of Nursing & Health Studies, and Lawrence O. Gostin, the Linda D. and Timothy J. O'Neill Professor of Global Health Law and faculty director of the O'Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law at Georgetown University Law Center, explore the balance of scientific freedom and national security in their opinion piece published online today entitled, "The Limits of Government Regulation of Science."

In 2011, two research teams genetically modified the H5N1 avian influenza virus. Their work, funded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH), demonstrates the ability to alter a virus in such a way that it could possibly spread rapidly among humans killing more than half who contract it (the research was conducted in an animal model believed to represent human behavior of the virus). The research prompted the National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity (NSABB), which advises the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), to recommend that Science and Nature redact key information prior to publication. Both NSABB and HHS expressed concerns that published details about the papers' methodology and results could become a blueprint for bioterrorism.

"The NSABB process seems to have worked well in this instance," says Kraemer. "It raised legitimate security concerns while avoiding censorship of the scientific press. But there remains a need to strengthen precautions around this type of research before it occurs."

To date, Science and Nature have not yet announced their intentions regarding the government's request.

In their commentary, Kraemer and Gostin write "HHS' request reveals a troubled relationship between security and science." However, the authors point out, "Given the absence of legal force or undue inducements or penalties, the government's request to withhold information does not violate the First Amendment."

Kraemer and Gostin say the First Amendment, "affords considerable protection to political artistic and scientific expression, triggering 'strict scrutiny' by the Supreme Court." They point out that had the government compelled either the researchers or the journals to withhold publication, that act would have violated the First Amendment.

In their opinion piece, the authors explore various court cases that challenge and support the government's rights to go further with such an issue. They say the federal government has the power to prevent dissemination of sensitive life science research, but warn, " there are good reasons to exercise that power sparingly."

Looking beyond the current dilemma, Kraemer and Gostin ask: "Can the review process for high-risk biologic research be improved further?"

The origins of the National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity can be traced to the National Research Council's Fink Report issued in 2004. The Fink Report endorsed, among other things, expanded self-governance by researchers toward issues of biosecurity, as well as the formation of a national advisory board to help guide both the government and research community in addressing issues involving dual-use research.

However, Kraemer and Gostin point out that vital recommendations in the Fink Report have not yet been implemented, including the need to employ an institutional review process for biological "experiments of concern" patterned on the Institutional Biosafety Committees (IBC) required for recombinant DNA research.

Kraemer and Gostin make the following recommendations to improve the review process:

HHS, in partnership with institutions, will have to ensure that the IBC model works effectively: (1) institutions must develop the requisite expertise to review dual use research; (2) HHS must specify the categories of research requiring institutional reviewminimally including the 7 types of high-risk experiments; and (3) HHS must set clear and consistent standards for institutional review. If IBCs are formally designated to conduct the institutional review function, HHS will have to clarify whether NSABB will guide and oversee the process.

Kraemer and Gostin suggest that such a process can ensure a, "sound balance between scientific freedom and national security. A fair, transparent process undertaken by research institutions, with a balanced approach to scientific benefits and public safety, together with HHS guidance and oversight of high-risk research, is preferable to government constraints on scientific information by force of law."
'/>"/>

Contact: Karen Mallet
km463@georgetown.edu
Georgetown University Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Balancing the womb
2. Parenting after the death of a child a difficult balancing act: York U study
3. 'The Balancing Act' & Chicken of the Sea Search for America's 'Supercook'
4. O2 Media's Hit Morning Show ‘The Balancing Act' Welcomes Dr. Bob Arnot to the Program
5. O2 Media's Hit Morning Show ‘The Balancing Act' Welcomes HSA Bank to the Program
6. O2 Media's Hit Morning TV Show ‘The Balancing Act' Welcomes Absolute Miracle Cream to the Program
7. ‘The Balancing Act' and Chicken of the Sea Search for America's ‘Supercook'
8. O2 Media's Hit Morning Show ‘The Balancing Act' Welcomes Dexter Russell, Inc. to the Program
9. O2 Media's Hit Morning Show ‘The Balancing Act' Welcomes Resident Chef Jeremy Hanlon to the Program
10. O2 Media's Hit Morning Show ‘The Balancing Act' Welcomes the Arthritis Foundation to the Program
11. O2 Media's Hit Morning TV Show ‘The Balancing Act' Welcomes Atkins Nutritionals to the Program
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... January 23, 2017 , ... The Masters of Science in ... leaders with decades of experience who remain current practitioners in the field. With ... there is a renewed demand for versatile, data-driven leadership.The American University’s MS in ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... , ... January 23, 2017 , ... ... on Crystallization in Process Chemistry by Applying Simple PAT Tools . , ... compounds to isolate and purify the desired product. Chemists now spend more ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... 23, 2017 , ... Old School Labs™, makers of the wildly popular all-natural ... Breon Ansley to its growing team of brand ambassadors. The Olympia top finisher and ... less than a year was able to turn professional, participating in the 2013 NPC ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... January 23, 2017 , ... “Crossing the Bar”: a moving and eloquent ... life. “Crossing the Bar” is the creation of published author, Charlotte Hotte, a North ... who credits the inspiration of the book to her sister, Denise, wishes to acknowledge ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... 23, 2017 , ... Valentine’s Day is a time when many people celebrate romance and love ... may be looking for the ideal present, Atlanta-based Perimeter Plastic Surgery is offering ... free. Or, spend $200 and get $50 free. , “A lot of people just ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/23/2017)... Research and Markets has announced the addition of the ... their offering. ... The interventional radiology products market is expected to reach USD 8.02 ... CAGR of 4.8%. This market is segmented based on type, procedure, ... of this market are rising incidence of chronic diseases, rising geriatric ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... , Jan. 23, 2017 LifeVac, the ... a blocked airway and prevented choking deaths, welcomes ... advocate to the LifeVac team as Official Spokesperson. ... join the LifeVac team," said Arthur Lih , ... to represent LifeVac and his mission to raise awareness ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... TORONTO , Jan. 23, 2017 ... both 510(k) clearance from the U.S. Food and ... from Health Canada enabling the North American commercial ... (MIGS™) system for spine surgery, the 7D Surgical ... employs cutting-edge 3D optical technologies and machine vision ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: