Navigation Links
Assessing the quality of phase I clinical trial abstracts
Date:10/21/2008

Geneva, Switzerland: Researchers have developed a method of assessing the quality of phase I clinical trial abstracts submitted to two different oncology conferences: EORTC-NCI-AACR (ENA) [1] and American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO). The results, presented on Thursday (23 October) at the 20th ENA Symposium on Molecular Targets and Cancer Therapeutics in Geneva, show there is room for improvement and the researchers suggest authors of conference abstracts should adopt guidelines for reporting phase I clinical trials.

Dr Jeremy Ho, an internal medicine resident under the supervision of associate professor Dr Lillian Siu at the Princess Margaret Hospital (Toronto, Canada), had worked with colleagues to develop a quality score for abstracts based on an electronic survey of experts. They had used it to measure the quality of 1,683 phase I abstracts published in the ASCO Annual Proceedings from 1997 to 2006, and then they used the same method to measure the quality of 304 abstracts presented at the ENA symposia from 2003-2007.

When they compared abstracts on phase I trials from the period where there was an overlap between the two conferences (2003-2006), they found that the mean average quality score for the 229 ENA abstracts was 69.6% compared to 64.5% for the 713 ASCO abstracts.

Dr Ho said: "ASCO is a much bigger meeting than ENA, with different objectives, scope and audience. Our study is not meant to be a direct comparison to criticise the quality of abstracts submitted to either meeting. The data enable us to gain insight on areas where improvements in the quality of phase I trial abstract reporting can be made, regardless of the meeting.

"The slightly higher quality score for the ENA abstracts is probably due to a higher figure for the maximum number of characters allowed per abstract (2,500 for ENA and 2,000 for ASCO), an allowance for updating previously presented data, and the more specialised anti-cancer drug development focus of the ENA symposia. There remains room for improvement in both conferences for improving abstract quality and we believe this may be achieved by adopting guidelines for reporting on phase 1 clinical trials."

Dr Ho and his colleagues have drawn up a list of what they believe should be included in any guidelines on reporting phase I trials. The following are items that are absolutely essential:

  • Description of dose-limiting toxicity encountered on study
  • Conclusion explicitly states maximum tolerated doses (MTD) or residual disease (RD) or reason for early trial closure
  • Description of grade three toxicity and above that may be related to study drug
  • Description of drug delivery schedule or formulation
  • Number of patients on study
  • Title identifying study as dose finding or phase I
  • Pharmacokinetic analysis, if applicable

The following items should also be reported:

  • Explicit definition of primary end point or objective
  • Rationale for study
  • Pharmacodynamic results, if applicable
  • Current status of study
  • Information related to treatment cycles
  • Efficacy outcome of patients
  • Number of patients at each dose level
  • Tumour types of responders, if applicable

Dr Ho said: "We are not aware of any such guidelines in existence. We are hoping that our suggestions for guidelines can be validated further and then put into clinical use, for instance, as recommendations and reference guide to clinical researchers to help them with abstract writing, and maybe also as guidelines for conferences to evaluate abstracts being submitted."

Abstracts at both conferences improved in quality the more recently they were presented, possibly indicating that authors were becoming more aware of what information needed to be included.

Dr Ho said he and his colleagues concentrated on phase I clinical trials for a number of reasons. "Phase I trials are unique in that they evaluate new drugs or drug combinations, and provide necessary foundations for the development of safe and more effective anti-cancer therapies. These trials are often initially presented in abstract format at major cancer conferences. Results of phase I trials published in abstract format frequently influence further research endeavours in higher-phase trials before full peer-reviewed publication occurs.

"We hope that this study will help to raise awareness about the importance of improving abstract quality in oncology conferences and in the cancer literature."


'/>"/>

Contact: Emma Mason
wordmason@mac.com
41-227-612-105
ECCO-the European CanCer Organisation
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Diabetes Spectrum Reports a Study Assessing the i-port(R) Injection Port for Administration of Insulin
2. Financing Retiree Health Care: Assessing GASB 45 Estimates of Liabilities
3. Measurements Poor for Assessing Clinical Trials With Children
4. Extremely low dose CT coronary angiography shows promise in assessing cardiac function
5. MedPAC Again Fails to Evaluate Overall Economic Conditions in Assessing SNF Funding Requirements
6. Nurses Report Quality Health Benefits Key to Choosing an Employer
7. National Pharmacy Technician Day Celebrated with Focus on Quality -- Pharmacy Technician Certification Board (PTCB) Touts Importance of Certified Technicians
8. Death rate 70 percent lower at top-rated hospitals: HealthGrades annual hospital quality study
9. National Coalition for Quality Colorectal Cancer Screening and Care Conveys Concerns over CT Colonography
10. Health Care Management Thought Leaders Converge for Summit on Cost, Quality and Consumer Focus
11. 2008 Idaho Potato Harvest Forecast: Plentiful, High-Quality Spuds
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:3/24/2017)... ... ... “The Adventures of Joey, The Dog Who Barks at Puddles”: a boisterous story about ... as God intended. “The Adventures of Joey, The Dog Who Barks at Puddles” is ... for writing, especially about truth and human behavior. , Published by Christian Faith Publishing, ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... , ... March 23, 2017 , ... A recent report ... entry into teacher preparation programs. The NCTQ report suggests, based on a review of ... would significantly improve teacher quality in the U.S. It argues that this higher bar ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... ... March 23, 2017 , ... ... to their communities, 16 more public health departments have been awarded national accreditation ... another 4.5 million people into the expanding network of communities across the nation ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... ... March 23, 2017 , ... PAINWeekEnd (PWE) Oklahoma City, on ... Avenue, will be an educational and exciting program providing busy clinicians and allied ... chronic pain. , Oklahoma is in a healthcare crisis. The state ranks 46th ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... ... 23, 2017 , ... The MBI “Hall of Fame” recognizes the contributions of those whose careers ... impact on the careers of all others involved. , On Monday, March 21st, ... MBI’s Hall of Fame. The induction took place during the World of Modular – ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:3/24/2017)... Wash. , March 23, 2017  Mirabilis ... of advanced medical technology for non-invasive surgery, announced ... Mirabilis System for treatment of uterine fibroids throughout ... it had received approval from the US Food ... of the Mirabilis System in the United States.  ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... Research and Markets has announced the addition of the ... 2025" report to their offering. ... The Global Cryostat Market is poised to ... to reach approximately $3.5 billion by 2025. This industry ... segments on global as well as regional levels presented in the ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... March 23, 2017  Transportation Insight, a multi-modal lead ... supply chain management firm with expertise serving clients in ... Rick Zaffarano was named a 2017 ... Chain by the only publication exclusively dedicated to covering ... chain. "Rick has brought to Transportation Insight ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: