Navigation Links
Are doing harm and allowing harm equivalent? Ask fMRI
Date:12/2/2011

PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] People typically say they are invoking an ethical principle when they judge acts that cause harm more harshly than willful inaction that allows that same harm to occur. That difference is even codified in criminal law. A new study based on brain scans, however, shows that people make that moral distinction automatically. Researchers found that it requires conscious reasoning to decide that active and passive behaviors that are equally harmful are equally wrong.

For example (see below), an overly competitive figure skater in one case loosens the skate blade of a rival, or in another case, notices that the blade is loose and fails to warn anyone. In both cases, the rival skater loses the competition and is seriously injured. Whether it is by acting, or willfully failing to act, the overly competitive skater did the same harm.

"What it looks like is when you see somebody actively harm another person that triggers a strong automatic response," said Brown University psychologist Fiery Cushman. "You don't have to think very deliberatively about it. You just perceive it as morally wrong. When a person allows harm that they could easily prevent, that actually requires more carefully controlled deliberative thinking [to view as wrong]."

In a study published in advance online in the journal Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, Cushman and his co-authors presented 35 volunteers with 24 moral dilemmas and lapses like the one involving the figure skaters. For specific lengths of time the volunteers would read an introduction to the incident, a description of the character's moral choices, and a description of how the character behaved. Then they'd rate the moral wrongness of the behavior on a scale from 1 to 5. All the while, Cushman and his co-authors, who were at Harvard University at the time, tracked the blood flow in the volunteers' brains with functional magnetic resonance imaging scans.'/>"/>

Contact: David Orenstein
david_orenstein@brown.edu
401-863-1862
Brown University
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Study: Working moms multitask more and have worse time doing so than dads
2. Heart failure: Doing what your doctor says works
3. Few people are doing it, so why should I? Motivating men to seek cancer screening
4. Health Groups Ask Supreme Court to Authorize Financial Penalties on Tobacco Companies for Decades of Wrongdoing
5. Mountain Home 'Doing the Right Thing Really is the Best Business Approach'
6. Allowing part-time surgeons may help address workforce shortage
7. Allowing Organ Donation by People With HIV Could Save Lives, Experts Say
8. Brain Stimulation Might Help Stroke Patients With Swallowing Problems
9. Mouse nose nerve cells mature after birth, allowing bonding, recognition with mother
10. Factors linked to speech/swallowing problems after treatment for head and neck cancers
11. Speech, Swallowing Usually OK After Head & Neck Cancer Therapy
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/20/2014)... discovered that the immune system is defective in people suffering ... sufferers have ongoing issues with pain. , The research ... also help to explain why some painkillers may not offer ... up to 10% of the community. There are different ... pain, which often has the greatest impact on sufferers, quality ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... 20, 2014 Hundreds of Mirena IUD ... women who were allegedly injured due to spontaneous migration ... Jersey’s Bergen County Superior Court, Bernstein Liebhard LLP reports. ... 15, 2014, the Court has established procedures regarding the ... that are part of the proceeding’s initial disposition pool. ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... -- Loss of brain cells that act as a ... trouble falling and staying asleep, a new study suggests. ... severe and often results in nighttime confusion and wandering, ... from the Rush Memory and Aging Project, which includes ... are being followed until death, at which point their ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... Doheny HealthDay Reporter WEDNESDAY, ... mastectomy has long been an option, but a new study ... "The most common reasons women didn,t undergo reconstruction was ... more surgery or they were focused on their cancer treatment," ... at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, in New York City. ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... deadliest infectious diseases in the world, killing one to ... tuberculosis have long debated its origins. New research shows ... seals and sea lions that brought the disease to ... before Europeans landed on the continent. , The paper, ... New World Human Tuberculosis," was published in Nature ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Pain treatments less effective for those with irritable bowel 2Health News:Mirena Lawsuit News: Case Management Order Issued in New Jersey Mirena Litigation, Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reports 2Health News:Mirena Lawsuit News: Case Management Order Issued in New Jersey Mirena Litigation, Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reports 3Health News:Mirena Lawsuit News: Case Management Order Issued in New Jersey Mirena Litigation, Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reports 4Health News:Seniors' Sleep Woes May Be Linked to Loss of Brain Cells 2Health News:Many Women Who Have Mastectomy Don't Get Breast Reconstruction: Study 2Health News:Many Women Who Have Mastectomy Don't Get Breast Reconstruction: Study 3Health News:New research shows seals and sea lions likely spread tuberculosis to humans 2Health News:New research shows seals and sea lions likely spread tuberculosis to humans 3
... major science prize, Pauline Ashley Prize 2007 was awarded to a ... in the human brain that could help to single out somebody's ... together and also responsible for training the brain to hear better ... to identify or hear another person's voice in a noisy room ...
... backlogs of patients for important surgeries has alerted ... the issue. According to the complaint, operations ... been put on the back burner, with patients ... of evidence to support these complaints has spurred ...
... is about to embark upon a health revolution that ... for paraplegics to walk again.// ,This is ... seven medical advances which they consider will transform lives. ... are at the forefront of the coming breakthroughs. ...
... Structural abnormalities were found in a particular brain ... to a study conducted// at the Laboratory for ... Studies. ,Williams syndrome is a rare ... therefore spend hours listening to or making music. ...
... the National Breast Feeding week included an All-Ireland Conference ... pose a major hurdle to ensuring more number of ... of the lowest breast feeding rates. ,Internationally acclaimed ... Toronto, said, “In the case of infant feeding, if ...
... curcumin — a chemical found in curry and turmeric ... //of amyloid beta, which form the plaques found in ... of the Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease, the early laboratory ... Alzheimer’s disease by enhancing the natural function of the ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Tune Your Brain to Hear Another in a Noisy Ambience 2Health News:Tune Your Brain to Hear Another in a Noisy Ambience 3Health News:Tune Your Brain to Hear Another in a Noisy Ambience 4Health News:Age of Medical Miracles has come upon us 2Health News:Chemical in Curry May Help Immune System Clear Plaques Found in Alzheimer's 2
(Date:8/20/2014)... 2014  The National Association of Drug Diversion ... by the real-time, pseudoephedrine (PSE) blocking system in ... Exchange (NPLEx), automatically blocks unlawful PSE sales and ... and make arrests. Data released by NPLEx shows ... blocked the sale of more than 32,105 boxes of ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... , Aug. 20, 2014  The National Association ... latest results achieved by the real-time, pseudoephedrine (PSE) ... National Precursor Log Exchange (NPLEx), automatically blocks unlawful ... down methamphetamine offenders and make arrests. Data released ... Missouri blocked the sale of more ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... NEW YORK , Aug. 20, ... a new market research report is ... The Market for Hospital-Acquired Infection Control ... http://www.reportlinker.com/p01618925/The-Market-for-Hospital-Acquired-Infection-Control-Sterilization-Disinfection-Testing-and-Treatment.html ... and healthcare-associated infections (HAIs), demand has ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Indiana's Stop-Sale System Achieves Significant Results In Battle Against Meth 2Missouri's Stop-Sale System Achieves Significant Results In Battle Against Meth 2The Market for Hospital-Acquired Infection Control (Sterilization, Disinfection, Testing and Treatment) 2The Market for Hospital-Acquired Infection Control (Sterilization, Disinfection, Testing and Treatment) 3The Market for Hospital-Acquired Infection Control (Sterilization, Disinfection, Testing and Treatment) 4The Market for Hospital-Acquired Infection Control (Sterilization, Disinfection, Testing and Treatment) 5The Market for Hospital-Acquired Infection Control (Sterilization, Disinfection, Testing and Treatment) 6
... Regado Biosciences, Inc., a privately held company pioneering ... announced today the primary results of the RADAR Phase ... anticoagulation system REG1, at the i2 Summit during the ... & Expo in New Orleans, LA.  REG1 is a ...
... her husband, Andrew, filed suit today against DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc. ... by the failures of Vickie,s two DePuy ASR XL Acetabular ... of John David Hart in Fort Worth, Texas, is the ... in the United States District Court for the Western District ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Regado Biosciences, Inc. Presents Results of the RADAR Phase 2b Clinical Trial of its REG1 Anticoagulation System 2Regado Biosciences, Inc. Presents Results of the RADAR Phase 2b Clinical Trial of its REG1 Anticoagulation System 3Regado Biosciences, Inc. Presents Results of the RADAR Phase 2b Clinical Trial of its REG1 Anticoagulation System 4Regado Biosciences, Inc. Presents Results of the RADAR Phase 2b Clinical Trial of its REG1 Anticoagulation System 5Bilateral DePuy Hip Implant Failures Lead to Lawsuit 2
... The first step to treatment is accurate ... an innovative and quick, patient-friendly tool designed ... urinary incontinence while minimizing patient discomfort. Designed ... features a new type of urethral pressure ...
...
...
...
Medicine Products: