Navigation Links
Anti-smoking ads with strong arguments, not flashy editing, trigger part of brain involving behavior change

PHILADELPHIA Researchers from the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania have shown that an area of the brain that initiates behavioral changes had greater activation in smokers who watched anti-smoking ads with strong arguments versus those with weaker ones, and irrespective of flashy elements, like bright and rapidly changing scenes, loud sounds and unexpected scenario twists. Those smokers also had significantly less nicotine metabolites in their urine when tested a month after viewing those ads, the team reports in a new study published online April 23 in the Journal of Neuroscience.

This is the first time research has shown an association between cognition and brain activity in response to content and format in televised ads and behavior.

In a study of 71 non-treatment-seeking smokers recruited from the Philadelphia area, the team, led by Daniel D. Langleben, M.D., a psychiatrist in the Center for Studies of Addiction at Penn Medicine, identified key brain regions engaged in the processing of persuasive communications using fMRI, or functional magnetic resonance imaging. They found that a part of the brain involved in future behavioral changesknown as the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dMPFC)had greater activation when smokers watched an anti-smoking ad with a strong argument versus a weak one.

One month after subjects watched the ads, the researchers sampled smokers' urine cotinine levels (metabolite of nicotine) and found that those who watched the strong ads had significantly less cotinine in their urine compared to their baseline versus those who watched weaker ads.

Even ads riddled with attention-grabbing tactics, the research suggests, are not effective at reducing tobacco intake unless their arguments are strong. However, ads with flashy editing and strong arguments, for example, produced better recognition.

"We investigated the two major dimensions of any piece of media, content and format, which are both important here," said Dr. Langleben, who is also an associate professor in the department of Psychiatry. "If you give someone an unconvincing ad, it doesn't matter what format you do on top of that. You can make it sensational. But in terms of effectiveness, content is more important. You're better off adding in more sophisticated editing and other special effects only if it is persuasive."

The paper may enable improved methods of design and evaluation of public health advertising, according to the authors, including first author An-Li Wang, PhD, of the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania. And it could ultimately influence how producers shape the way ads are constructed, and how ad production budgets are allocated, considering special effects are expensive endeavors versus hiring screenwriters.

A 2009 study by Dr. Langleben and colleagues that looked solely at format found people were more likely to remember low-key, anti-smoking messages versus attention-grabbing messages. This was the first research to show that low-key versus attention-grabbing ads stimulated different patterns of activity, particularly in the frontal cortex and temporal cortex. But it did not address content strength or behavioral changes.

This new study is the first longitudinal investigation of the cognitive, behavioral, and neurophysical response to the content and format of televised anti-smoking ads, according to the authors.

"This sets the stage for science-based evaluation and design of persuasive public health advertising," said Dr. Langleben. "An ad is only as strong as its central argument, which matters more than its audiovisual presentation. Future work should consider supplementing focus groups with more technology-heavy assessments, such as brain responses to these ads, in advance of even putting the ad together in its entirety."


Contact: Steve Graff
University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine

Related medicine news :

1. Small neural focus groups predict anti-smoking ad success
2. Anti-Smoking Ads Have Increased Quit Attempts: CDC
3. Anti-Smoking Progress Stalls Among U.S. Adults: Report
4. Genes May Influence Effectiveness of Anti-Smoking Policies
5. Symptomatic behaviour in childhood strongly predicts psychiatric treatment as a young adult
6. Military Marriages Stay Strong in Face of Challenges: Study
7. Does dinner make a strong family, or does a strong family make dinner?
8. Gastroenterology, CGH maintain strong 2011 impact factors
9. Strong communication between brain and muscle requires both having the protein LRP4
10. A stronger doctor-patient relationship for the costliest patients
11. First identification of a strong oral carcinogen in smokeless tobacco
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... While powdered supplements and drinks can reduce food ... inventor from Chesterfield, Va., has found an easy to keep track of the scoop. ... measure powdered contents in a canister or other container handy and readily accessible. As ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Volpara ... breast density assessment and enterprise analytics solutions, here at the 101st Annual ... Hall booth #2377). Volpara’s quantitative breast imaging tools enable personalized measurements of ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... DC (PRWEB) , ... November ... ... Inc. (AIS) is pleased to announce the speakers for “Value-Based Payer-Provider Partnerships: ... lessons learned from three innovative value-based care arrangements: Essentia Health and UCare, ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... , ... November 30, 2015 , ... ... alliance around Novus’ TIGR® Matrix Surgical Mesh technology for soft tissue repair in ... TIGR® Matrix is a long-term resorbable surgical mesh intended to support and reinforce ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... GKhair & Tibolli team members and artists ... Show held on November 8th and 9th at the Puerto Rico Convention Center, San ... renowned beauticians and top of the line fashion journalists. The San Juan Beauty Show ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... Months Ended 30 September 2015 2014RestatedChange%Turnover 545,575 , 518,852 , ... 384,242 , 9.8 Hospital Management Service Income ... (18.3) Medical Insurance Administration Service Income , 2,780 ... and Accessories Sales , 89,645 , 94,580 ... 2,822 , 2,917 , (3.3) Gross ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... , Nov. 30, 2015  PTS Diagnostics, the U.S.-based ... ® analyzers, A1CNow ® systems, and PTS ... family of patents that will propel the company into ... and Europe . The technology is ... as those on smartphones and tablets, and uses test ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... -- Cumberland Pharmaceuticals (CPIX), today announced that A.J. Kazimi , ... 3, 2015. TIME: 3:15p.m. ET LINK: ... --> DATE: Thursday, December 3, ... --> --> This will be ... ask the company questions in real-time - both in the ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: