Navigation Links
America will never be gay and lesbian friendly, says researcher

The relationship between church, state and the international crisis facing welfare finance is the root cause of why some countries are friendlier to same-sex couples than others, says a University of Manchester researcher.

Professor Angie Wilson's findings, based on an analysis of ten countries, are published in her new book this month, ahead of the US Supreme Court's judgement on gay marriage this week.

According to Professor Wilson, the court's nine justices are unlikely to proclaim a national right to same-sex marriage, differing widely from the attitudes of policy makers in Western Europe.

In her book, 'Why Europe is Lesbian and Gay friendly and why America never will be', published by Suny Press, she argues there is a gap in how we understand the advancement of gay rights across different countries.

Well organised gay and lesbian movements, political action, changes in social attitudes and human rights legislation, have all contributed to policy changes in gay friendly Europe, she says.

But more fundamental is the 'Political economy of care': the intersection of state, market, religious and family relations.

She will be giving a prestigious TED talk on the topic, online next month.

She said: "My research asks how is it that so many European countries have policies that protect citizens from discrimination based on sexual orientation and recognize same-sex couples, when many American states do not?

"The historical involvement of Christian churches, particularly in post-World War II welfare settlements, and the resulting political economy of care in each country, is unique. However, one common factor is the interpretation of 'the family'.

"In many US States especially in the South- religiosity is high, and Christian churches, rather than the state, are primary providers of social welfare, health and other services.

"This represents a huge financial investment in the traditional family and the church as the two key providers of services.

"If socially conservative religions lose their investment in service provision, they lose the political power to define morality and much of their political influence."

She added: "As European countries are facing austerity, redefining the traditional family to encompass and gay and lesbian people makes financial sense for states: families are far cheaper than the state at providing welfare.

"For those countries where religiosity is lower, this is going to be easier. In America, where religiosity is high and there is little federal support for welfare, it is going to be harder."

Professor Wilson's work can help explain policy development in countries such as:

  • Russia. Recently passed law banning gay 'propaganda' is indicative of unfriendly policies to gay and lesbian people. This must be seen in the context of growing religiosity, investment in welfare from the Christian right and lack of dependable state welfare.

  • France. Recently allowed its first gay marriage. Despite the love of the traditional family, France's increasing secularism and established welfare system has created this policy opportunity.

  • Britain. Same-sex marriage law and an impressive contemporary history of policy expansion. Brown and Blair both redefined the family, as Cameron is continuing this trend. At least part of the reasoning behind this was the need for a larger population to be defined as 'family' and therefore responsible financially for care thus saving the state money.

  • Spain. Legalises same sex marriages even though it is Catholic country. Explained by more women in work, migration into the cities which weakened Spain's dependence on the extended family to meet welfare needs. This created a momentous policy opportunity for well organized activists.

  • Italy. Less friendly to gay and lesbian people, explained by historic investment of the Catholic Church in direct care provision.

  • America. High religiosity and little national welfare reinforces the power of the Christian Right in many 'red states'. Churches are key providers of welfare for individual states and thus have great power to define the family according to their morality. Those individual states with significant investment in welfare are the exact ones with laws more inclusive of gay and lesbian couples.


Contact: Mike Addelman
University of Manchester

Related medicine news :

1. Dialogic Wins American Technology Award for Telecommunications
2. Sharon Kleyne Hour Power of Water® Radio Show Expands VoiceAmerica Coverage for Wider Audience
3. Transvaginal Mesh Lawsuits Continue, as Bernstein Liebhard LLP Comments on Reported Settlement of American Medical System Vaginal Mesh Lawsuits
4. American Medical Association Defines Obesity as a Disease Affecting 90 Million Americans
5. Medical Breakthrough from Mercy Research & Development Can Protect Wounded Warriors' Sight and Help Everyday Americans
6. American Brain Tumor Association’s 2013 Patient & Family Conference Aims to Engage and Empower
7. Stress from 9/11 linked to nationwide resurgence in smoking among Americans who had quit
8. Immigrant Entrepreneurs Demonstrate Growing Contribution To U.S. Economy, Says American Made 2.0
9. Nearly 7 in 10 Americans are on prescription drugs, Mayo Clinic study finds
10. American Brain Tumor Association Conference Advances Holistic Approach to Living with a Brain Tumor
11. Boston Scientific and American Medical Systems Named in Transvaginal Mesh Lawsuit Filed by Parker Waichman LLP on Behalf of Arizona Woman
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/10/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... October 10, 2015 , ... ... Brecher & Miller is pleased to be recognized by The National Law Journal ... list acknowledges the 50 law firms across the United States who obtained the ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... For many, October is a month whose focus ... effort to find a cure. At Beverly Hills Physicians in Southern California, it is ... their Bra Collection Campaign, Beverly Hills Physicians is encouraging patients and non-patients alike to ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... , ... October 09, 2015 , ... ... best audiologists in The Tennessean's eighth annual Toast of Music City, a reader’s ... Local Nashville residents nominated and cast votes for their favorite businesses in over ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... The Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America (AAFA) ... and Prevention (CDC) to improve the knowledge and skills of underserved adults with asthma. ... project by the CDC and allows AAFA to continue vital efforts to educate people ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... MMJ PhytoTech ... with Ed Begley Jr., airing 1st QT 2016 via the Discovery Channel. Dates ... MMJ Phytotech Limited (MMJ) – a global leader in the field of commercializing ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
... a health ratings company, the top 5 % of U.S ... lower the risk of death to patients by almost 27%, ... of complications. //,Health Grades, as part of their checks for ... United States. ,Death and complication rates for major surgeries ...
... is spending large amount of money on the Medicare sector ... act quickly otherwise the // problem will be blown out ... as high as 16% of gross domestic product and growing ... costs are to be borne by the individuals, businesses, the ...
... have advised expectant mothers to reduce the intake of anti-depressant ... with withdrawal symptoms. // The newborn babies of such ... and tremors within 48 hours after birth. ... women who had taken higher doses of the medicines. The ...
... approved the drug TEMODAL in combination with Radiotherapy ... // The drug TEMODAL that contains Temozolomide is ... treating two forms of brain cancer Glioblastoma multiforme ... the drug TEMODAL was tested on newly diagnosed ...
... for the worst possible results does not serve any ... in the end is the same for both categories ... University and Jonathon Brown of the University of Washington, ... their findings in the latest issue of the journal ...
... UK based doctors have called upon Muslim leaders, particularly in ... community. // This has been reported by the British Medical ... called for in anti-tobacco campaigns. ,The researchers ... countries with the highest proportion of Muslims. Smoking rates in ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:10/9/2015)... 2015  Insulet Corporation (NASDAQ: PODD ), the ... its OmniPod ® Insulin Management System, today announced ... quarter of 2015 on November 5, 2015 after the ... release, management will host a conference call that day ... . A replay will be available two hours after ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... MOUNT BRYDGES, Ontario , Oct. 9, ... of ergonomic radiology furniture, monitor mounting solutions ... Texas Children,s Hospital,s Department of Pediatric Radiology ... "ballroom concept."  RedRick Technologies provided ergonomic design ... facilitating productivity, clinical collaboration and teaching. ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... PUNE, India , October 9, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... with analysis of major players. --> ... major players. --> announces addition ... current status and 2020 forecasts for global markets ... India along with analysis of ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
... Claret Medical, Inc. announced today that its Montage ... first complete system of filtration to protect both carotid ... or brachial access, providing complete neuro protection during intravascular ... unique design of the Montage System provides for not ...
... 2011 Althera Medical Ltd. announced today that it ... treatment of cancer tumors with alpha radiation at Israel,s ... of Radiation Oncology at the Sourasky Medical Center and ... of the Head and Neck Tumor Service at Rabin,s ...
Cached Medicine Technology:
The world's first automatic computation program analyzes massive amount of measurement data and computes "the most comfortable value" for the patient....
... The Ultramatic Rx Master is ... years of reliable service and ... that measurably improve procedures. It ... need and want most, including ...
Maddox Rod, short handle (12cm)...
Snellen 10' Eye Test Chart....
Medicine Products: