Navigation Links
Advocacy for planned home birth not in patients' best interest
Date:11/13/2012

Philadelphia, PA, November 13, 2012 Advocates of planned home birth have emphasized its benefits for patient safety, patient satisfaction, cost effectiveness, and respect for women's rights. A clinical opinion paper published in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology critically evaluates each of these claims in its effort to identify professionally appropriate responses of obstetricians and other concerned physicians to planned home birth.

Throughout the United States and Europe, planned home birth has seen increased activity in recent years. Professional associations and the European Court have publicly supported it, and insurance companies have paid for it.

"These recent statements by professional associations and by the European Court should not be allowed to stand unchallenged," says lead author Frank A. Chervenak, MD, the Given Foundation Professor and chairman of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Weill Cornell Medical College, and obstetrician and gynecologist-in-chief and director of maternal-fetal medicine at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center. "Positions taken about planned home birth, in our view, are not compatible with professional responsibility for patients.We call on obstetricians, other concerned physicians, midwives, and other obstetric providers, and their professional associations not to support planned home birth when there are safe and compassionate hospital-based alternatives and to advocate for a safe home-birth-like experience in the hospital."

For its evaluation of patient safety, the authors examined evidence of obstetric outcomes and found that planned home birth does not meet current standards for patient safety. Unexpected complications that develop in labor during planned home births can lead to emergency transports and delayed delivery of emergency care. The perinatal mortality rate was reported to be more than 8 times higher when transport from home to an obstetric unit was required.

While the primary motivation for planned home birth is increased patient satisfaction, the authors found this motivation undermined by a high rate of necessary emergency transport, as well as reported inability of the patient to cope with pain, anxiety about losing the baby during transport, and dissatisfaction with caregivers. By creating home-birth-like environments with appropriate staffing in a hospital setting, physicians can improve and ensure patient satisfaction.

In analyzing cost effectiveness, Dr. Chervenak and co-authors refer to a comprehensive Dutch study that calculates a threefold increase of costs that include patient transport and midwife and obstetrician services. Cost analysis must also include professional liability, transport system maintenance, hospital admission, lifetime costs of supporting neurologically disabled children, and more.

Finally, the team examined the relationship between planned home birth and women's rights. It argues that medical professionals should not allow unconstrained rights of pregnant women to control the birth location. To do so would be unethical.

Analytical results of these four claims enabled the authors to provide practical answers to obstetricians' questions regarding their professional responsibility for planned home birth, including addressing the root cause of planned home birth recrudescence, responding to a patient who asks about or requests planned home birth, receiving a patient on emergency transport from planned home birth, and whether to participate in or refer to planned home birth clinical trials.

Professional associations of obstetricians also have a responsibility to promote patient safety, reconsider their statements on planned home birth, and align them with professional responsibility.

"Advocacy of planned home birth is a compelling example of what happens when ideology replaces professionally disciplined clinical judgment and policy," Dr. Chervenak concludes. "We urge obstetricians, other concerned physicians, midwives and other obstetric providers, and their professional associations to eschew rights-based reductionism in the ethics of planned home birth and replace rights-based reductionism with an ethics based professional responsibility."


'/>"/>

Contact: Francesca Costanzo
ajogmedia@elsevier.com
215-239-3249
Elsevier Health Sciences
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Advocacy toolkit launched to halt the runaway train of cancer in Africa
2. The consequences of late preterm birth
3. Pregnant Women With Bipolar Disorder May Have Higher Risk of Premature Birth
4. Combating a crisis: Global burden of preterm birth can be reduced if critical actions are taken
5. Birth is no reason to go to hospital
6. Simple test to predict if pregnant women will give birth prematurely
7. Vanderbilt study looks at benefits of progestogens to prevent early childbirth
8. Guys, take note: Male birth control pill may be ready soon, says Texas A&M professor
9. Multiple Abortions May Raise Risk of Preemie Birth Later
10. What babies eat after birth likely determines lifetime risk of obesity, rat study suggests
11. Cervical Disease Treatment Not Linked to Premature Birth Risk
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... The Data Council, the leading ... was acquired by Advantage Solutions. The Data Council’s IX-ONE platform is the ... industry’s leading suppliers, brokers, distributors and retailers. The Data Council will become a ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... QualDerm Partners , a ... today announced Cumberland Skin Surgery and Dermatology has joined the company ... in both Hermitage and Lebanon, Tennessee, provides comprehensive general dermatology and skin cancer ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... LabRoots , the leading provider of ... world, is excited to announce Andrew Ly as the winner of the LabRoots Summer ... costs. , Ly, who is in his third year at the University of ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... Fusion Flix Inc., a Telly Award ... four countries and millions of viewers in a partnership with the Amazon Video Direct ... and fully available on Blu Ray disc in 2018. Proceeds will be going to ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... Houston, TX (PRWEB) , ... August 16, 2017 ... ... transforming digital health, announces their latest new client win in the healthcare market, ... and web-based solution to support healthcare staff and members. , AHF cares for ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/2/2017)... Aug. 2, 2017  Life Flight Network and PeaceHealth Oregon ... improves patient care and operational efficiency for patients at hospitals ... , Cottage Grove , and ... PeaceHealth and Life Flight Network work collaboratively to move patients ... or when a time sensitive emergency exists. ...
(Date:7/31/2017)... , July 31, 2017 Three Tru-D SmartUVC robots ... South Korea . Tru-D, short for "Total Room Ultraviolet Disinfection," ... rooms after an environmental services (ES) professional cleans the area with traditional ... Tru-D ... "Although the BAACH has ...
(Date:7/27/2017)... Biomet Holdings, Inc. (NYSE and SIX: ZBH) today reported financial ... Company reported second quarter net sales of $1.954 billion, ... and an increase of 2.1% on a constant currency ... the LDR Holding Corporation acquisition, second quarter 2017 revenues ... 0.3% on a constant currency basis. ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: