Navigation Links
A missed shot: The failure of HPV vaccination state requirements

In an article appearing in the current issue of Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics, experts from the University of Pennsylvania Center for Bioethics and Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics review the controversy surrounding the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine debate, and its effects on ethical and public health issues.

The arrival of Gardasil was a major achievement for cervical cancer prevention efforts worldwide, says Jason Schwartz, MBE, Researcher, Penns Center for Bioethics and Department of History & Sociology of Science, and lead author. Much of the initial enthusiasm for the vaccine was lost amid the controversy surrounding state proposals that would require teenage girls to be vaccinated in order to attend school. The events of the past year reveal important lessons regarding ways to introduce new vaccines successfully and in an ethically responsible manner."

In the months leading up to the June 2006 approval of Gardasil, there was unprecedented media coverage and support from even socially-conservative groups. However, this support for the vaccine began to slow in September 2006 following the introduction of a bill in the Michigan state legislature that would require the vaccination of girls attending public schools. Additional states also were quick to propose similar legislation. In response to the legislation, numerous groups expressed their opposition by arguing that it was either too soon to consider an HPV requirement, or that the sexual transmission of the virus did not warrant requiring the vaccine in schools.

The opposition grew when the governor of Texas issued an executive order requiring HPV vaccination for all girls entering the sixth grade. Critics of state HPV requirements called attention to how these policies violated obligations to respect parental autonomy. However, many critics often overlooked opt-out provisions, implying that the proposals made vaccination compulsory.

The authors note that, Quite apart from whether it was prudent public health policy to implement state requirements for HPV vaccination so soon after the vaccines licensure, these attacks on the state initiatives may have exacted a very real ethical price in terms of the publics understanding of the justifications for state vaccination requirements generally, as well as the publics understanding of the merits of the HPV vaccine itself. Additionally, they suggest that issues of price gouging, corporate profits, and political motives, may have also added to the opposition.

In order to move forward with cervical cancer prevention efforts, the authors suggest that attention be focused on assessing the long-term safety of the vaccine, while implementing effective patient and provider educational programs about HPV and the HPV vaccine, as this is the model that other successful vaccination programs have followed. "With a second HPV vaccine expected to be approved in early 2008, it is vital to understand the strategies that are most likely to lead to the long-term success of this remarkable weapon against cervical cancer," says Schwartz.

The authors also discuss the importance of designing and implementing HPV vaccination programs in developing countries. "Cervical cancer is a worldwide concern, but its impact is particularly severe in the developing world, says Schwartz. It would be tragic if the negative attention created by the debate over HPV vaccine mandates in the U.S. hamper efforts to make the vaccine available to those internationally who could benefit most from it."

Additional article authors are Arthur Caplan, PhD, Director, Center for Bioethics, Penn; Ruth Faden, PhD, MPH, the Philip Franklin Wagley Professor of Biomedical Ethics and Executive Director of The Phoebe R. Berman Bioethics Institute, Johns Hopkins University; and Jeremy Sugarman, MD, MPH, MA, the Harvey M. Meyerhoff Chair of Bioethics and Medicine at the Phoebe R. Berman Bioethics Institute, Johns Hopkins University


Contact: Kate Olderman Tavella
University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine

Related medicine news :

1. Bihar Government Dismissed Doctors For Negligence
2. NHS Trust Wants Abortion Mothers Case To Be Dismissed
3. Missed Vaccination Caused Largest Measles Outbreak in U.S in 2005
4. Meningitis Case Dismissed as Viral Infection Proves Fatal for Child
5. Colorectal Cancer Getting Missed Out in Office Setting
6. Is Diabetes the Leading Cause of Kidney Failure in India
7. New FDA Approved Drug NATRECOR For Heart Failure Patients
8. Depression and heart failure
9. Reversing heart failure
10. How to diagnose heart failure?
11. Early test to detect kidney failure
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/12/2015)... ... 2015 , ... The American Society of Clinical Hypnosis (ASCH) ... and clinical training in a health care discipline. , Many practitioners claim ... losing weight, managing pain, or stopping smoking, etc. Frequently, extravagant statements and guarantees ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... ... October 12, 2015 , ... AcousticSheep LLC, creators of ... in honor of Breast Cancer Awareness Month. During the month of October, ... a SleepPhones® Classic product to a breast cancer patient at the Cleveland Clinic. ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... ... October 12, 2015 , ... To help ... its charitable donation to the National Breast Cancer Foundation. The National Breast Cancer ... breast cancer through early detection, education, and support services. , The annual campaign ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... ... October 12, 2015 , ... NFL football fans who are interested in having an opportunity to ... CLICK HERE to donate to Smile for a Lifetime (S4L) Foundation and gift ... all-inclusive trip to the 2016 NFL Super Bowl! , Donors contributing $20.00 or more between ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... , ... October 12, 2015 , ... The translation for ... seamless migration of complete ARIS installations into the Microsoft world. The ARIS models ... As Microsoft Visio® is very familiar for both IT and Office users it is ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/12/2015)... October 12, 2015 ... Pipeline Review, H2 2015 market research report provides ... pipelines by identifying new targets and MOAs to ... . --> . ... spread across 62 pages, analyzing 6 companies, 8 ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... , Oct. 12, 2015 Device usage ... need to help integrate these devices into existing clinical ... ergonomic healthcare mounting and mobility solutions, has launched the ... cart yet, for a wide array of laptops and ... SV10 was developed exclusively for Microsoft Surface and is ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... 2015  Today, Divurgent is honored to announce Paul ... former CIO, Paul brings 15 years of hands-on experience as ... with today,s CIOs, he is one. The challenges that face ... faced, and his new role with Divurgent allows him to ... an organization. ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: