Navigation Links
Patient trade-off


The trade-off dilemma in prostate cancer treatment refers to the choice between different treatments for localized prostate cancer (a tumor that is contained within the prostate). The choice is a trade-off between the expected beneficial and harmful effects in terms of patient survival and quality of life.

Symptoms specifically related to prostate cancer treatment, include urinary and bowel symptoms and waning sexual function which is the most prevalent source of severe distress in prostate cancer patients. [1] The prevalence of these symptoms and the extent to which they distress the men vary between treatment forms and patients. Also, the relationship between distress owing to these symptoms and overall well-being varies considerably between patients. [2] In the case of clinically localized prostate cancer one option is to abstain from curative treatment to avoid side effects. However, symptoms from the cancer and the fear of living with an untreated tumor may overweigh the fear of negative side-effects.

When doing trade-off’s of this nature it is of central importance for the patient and the physician to have access to empirical information on established treatment benefits and side effects.

One example of a complicated trade-off is the willingness to trade off an intact sexual function for the possibility of a prolonged life expectancy by abstaining from curative treatment. A Swedish study found that the willingness to do this kind of trade-off varied considerably among the men included in the study. [1] While six out of ten were willing to consider a trade-off between life expectancy and intact sexual function, given the present knowledge of treatment benefits for clinically localized prostate cancer, four out of ten stated that they would under all circumstances choose treatment irrespective of the risk for waning sexual function. In general the phenomenon of conceptual trade-off is poorly understood. The trade-off between the decreased risk of survival and the increased probability of intact quality of life is one such problem. Access to valid empirical information is crucial for such decision making. However the individual’s feeling towards the subject in question is also a factor based on emotional values and theological positions rather than knowledge. An individual that does not care about a certain documented side effect of treatment, even if there is no documented treatment benefit, may decide to choose the treatment so long as the theoretical possibility exists that there may be some positive treatment effects, although this has not been empirically established. The relatively complex dynamics of this kind of compromise are an interesting subject that needs to be studied in more detail.

A substantial proportion of patients (and physicians for that matter) experience stress owing to trade-off between different treatment options and treatment side-effects. Given this stressful situation in addition to the stress of being diagnosed with cancer it is of great concern that eight out of ten prostate cancer patients have no one to confide in except their spouse and one out of five live in total emotional isolation. [3] This indicates that psycho social support widely available at cancer clinics may not get through to men.

How localized prostate cancer should be treated may never be answered. We can only continue collecting valid information about the basis for the trade-off between different treatment forms and learn to communicate the data to the patient in a fruitful way.

References

1. Helgason ÁR, Adolfsson J, Dickman P, Fredrikson M, Arver S, Steineck G. Waning sexual function - the most important disease-specific distress for patients with prostate cancer. Br. J. Cancer. 1996: 73: 1417-1421.
2. Helgason ÁR, Adolfsson J, Dickman P, Fredrikson M, Steineck G. Distress due to unwanted side-effects of prostate cancer treatment is related to impaired well-being (quality of life). Prostate Cancer and Prostatic Diseases. 1998: 1:128-133.
3. Helgason ÁR, Dickman PW, Adolfsson J, Steineck G. Emotional isolation : Prevalence and the effect on well-being among 50-80 year old prostate cancer patients. Scandinavian Journal of Urology and Nephrology 2001 :35;97-101.

'"/>


(Date:9/2/2014)... a Viewpoint published today in the Journal of ... researchers call for the implementation of taxes and subsidies ... researchers from the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and ... Hospital write that policies taxing nearly all packaged foods ... meaningful dietary changes and substantially reduce health care costs. ...
(Date:9/2/2014)... 2014 TCG, a leading government technology strategy ... one of the fastest-growing companies in America for the seventh ... was previously recognized in 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008, ... grown 86% from 2010 to 2013, ranking the company at ... in America - up 635 spots from 2013! More information ...
(Date:9/2/2014)... The use of Xarelto (known generically ... at a rapid pace, even as Xarelto lawsuits ... the U.S., Bernstein Liebhard LLP reports. According to a ... a year of its 2011 launch, patients were just ... blood thinner that has been in use for several ...
(Date:9/2/2014)... Complications are rare among breast cancer patients who ... However, the researchers did find that a ... risk for certain complications than a single mastectomy. ... cancer patients who had a single (64 percent) ... were followed for 30 days after surgery. ...
(Date:9/2/2014)... In a large population-based study of randomly selected ... impairment (MCI) occurred twice more often in individuals ... strong association was only observed in middle-aged participants ... the association vanished. This study is published in ... The concept of MCI describes an intermediate state ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Taxes and subsidies could encourage healthier diet and lower healthcare costs 2Health News:TCG One of the Fastest-Growing Companies in America – for the Eighth Time! 2Health News:Xarelto Lawsuit News: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Comments on Growing Use of Xarelto in Spite of Mounting Product Liability Litigation 2Health News:Xarelto Lawsuit News: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Comments on Growing Use of Xarelto in Spite of Mounting Product Liability Litigation 3Health News:Xarelto Lawsuit News: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Comments on Growing Use of Xarelto in Spite of Mounting Product Liability Litigation 4Health News:Complication Rates Low With Mastectomy, Breast Reconstruction: Study 2Health News:Diabetes mellitus and mild cognitive impairment: Higher risk in middle age? 2
... study may help put to rest fears that pregnancy ... receiving antiretroviral therapy. The study, published in the October ... now available online, revealed that pregnancy may, in fact, ... advent of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), many women ...
... Segal Health Plan Cost,Trend Survey forecasts continued declines in ... medical trends. And, although a growing,number of health plans ... still significantly above general inflation. Key findings,include: ... for point-of-service (POS) medical ...
... District,Court for the District of Massachusetts has granted ... a class of people and entities that,purchased certain ... Health Benefits Fund v. First DataBank, Inc., No.,1:05-CV-11148-PBS ... Medi-Span, No.,07-cv-10988-PBS, concerning how the published price of ...
... of parents feel they play a significant role in ... at the University of Michigan C.S. Mott Childrens Hospital. ... issue of the Journal of Pediatrics, 86 percent of ... their hospitalized childs medical care. Researchers also found that ...
... Medicine (BUSM), Boston University School of Public Health ... Institute (NHLBI), have completed analyses of a genome-wide ... participants from the landmark Framingham Heart Study (FHS). ... potentially affect the risk for cardiovascular disease and ...
... researchers say , , WEDNESDAY, Sept. 19 (HealthDay News) ... knew little or nothing about peripheral arterial disease (PAD), ... legs that boosts heart risk. , "I don,t think ... PAD," said Dr. Timothy Murphy, a professor of diagnostic ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Pregnancy may slow -- not accelerate -- progression to AIDS 2Health News:Pregnancy may slow -- not accelerate -- progression to AIDS 3Health News:Segal Survey Predicts Declines in Trends for Fifth Consecutive Year 2Health News:Class Settlement Could Result in Considerable Savings for Certain Consumers of Prescription Pharmaceuticals 2Health News:Class Settlement Could Result in Considerable Savings for Certain Consumers of Prescription Pharmaceuticals 3Health News:Parents' participation in medical decisions linked to self-efficacy 2Health News:Researchers provide genetic associations from a genome-wide scan for cardiovascular disease traits 2Health News:Researchers provide genetic associations from a genome-wide scan for cardiovascular disease traits 3Health News:Few Americans Know of Leg Artery Danger 2Health News:Few Americans Know of Leg Artery Danger 3
Other medicine definitionOther Tags