Navigation Links
Hickam's dictum


Hickam's dictum is a counterargument to the use of Occam's razor in the medical profession.[1] The principle is commonly stated: "Patients can have as many diseases as they damn well please". The principle is attributed to John Hickam, MD.[2]

When discussing Occam's razor in contemporary medicine, doctors and philosophers of medicine speak of diagnostic parsimony. Diagnostic parsimony advocates that when diagnosing a given injury, ailment, illness, or disease a doctor should strive to look for the fewest possible causes that will account for all the symptoms. However, this principle has very important limits in medical practice. The actual process that occurs when diagnosing a patient is a continuous flow of hypothesis and testing of that hypothesis, then modifying the hypothesis, and so on. In the context of this method, the principle of Hickam's dictum asserts that at no stage should a particular diagnosis be excluded solely because it doesn't appear to fit the principle of Occam's razor. The principle of Occam's razor, or parsimony, does not demand that the diagnostician necessarily opt for the simplest explanation, but instead guides the medical practitioner to seek explanations, without unnecessary additional assumptions, which are capable of accounting for all relevant evidence.

A key reason for using Hickam's dictum as a limiting principle to that of Occam's razor is, it is often statistically more likely that a patient has several common diseases, rather than having a single rarer disease which explains the myriad of their symptoms. Another key reason is that, independently of statistical likelihood, some patients do in fact turn out to have multiple diseases. In such cases multiple categories of diagnosis may indeed have independent causes rather than a single source, i.e. may be due to separate events or combinations of events to which the patient may have been subjected or exposed. Thus Hickam's dictum provides physicians with a counterbalancing principle to the unfettered use of Occam's razor in diagnosis.

An example of the utility of Hickam's dictum is Saint's Triad of hiatus hernia, gallbladder disease and diverticulosis. C. F. M. Saint was a South African surgeon. His triad has no known pathophysiologcal relationship nullifying the usefulness of Occam's razor.[3] Hickam's dictum is similar in principle to Willian of Chatham's anti razor.

Notes

  1. ^ See, e.g., "Hickam's Dictum versus Occam's Razor: A Case for Occam." W. Bradley Fields, MD, University of Michigan Health System, Ann Arbor, MI (2005) ([1] )
  2. ^ Hickam was a faculty member at Duke University in the 1950's, and was later chairman of medicine at Indiana University.([2] )
  3. ^ Hilliard A. A., Weinberger S. E., Tierney L. M. Jr., Midthun D. E., and Saint S. (2004): Occam's Razor versus Saint's Triad., N Engl J Med 350:599-603

'"/>


(Date:7/11/2014)... 11, 2014 Shoulder instability is a ... return to play has not been regularly determined following ... Society for Sports Medicine’s ( AOSSM ) Annual Meeting ... approximately 90 percent no matter what the stabilization procedure ... rate of return to play following shoulder stabilization surgery. ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... occur more than 200,000 times a year, but the ... may determine how long you stay in the game, ... Meeting of the American Orthopaedic Society of Sports Medicine ... in a young athletic population, allografts (tissue harvested from ... harvested from the patient)," said Craig R. Bottoni, MD, ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... (PRWEB) July 11, 2014 Woodland Hills ... founder of the Anacapa Dental Art Institute in Woodland Hills ... Biocare World Symposium in Marina Del Rey, Calif. , ... master class on the permanent teeth in one day dental ... teeth in one day was developed 15 years ago, Dr. ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... (PRWEB) July 11, 2014 The World Cup ... according to recent reports , many star soccer players left ... in the media to American football when it comes to ... risk is always there. While none of the soccer superstars ... possibility remains. Beverly Hills spine surgeon Dr. Gravori reveals some ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... 2014 On Tuesday, July 9, Eric ... VA office joined CBS affiliate WUSA’s Andrea Roane ... the audience about the number of ways Shady Grove ... motherhood possible for women after they undergo cancer ... patients in the developing field known as oncofertility which ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Stabilizing Shoulder Surgery Helps NFL Players Return to the Game 2Health News:ACL reconstructions may last longer with autografts 2Health News:Woodland Hills Dental Expert Speaking at Nobel Biocare World Symposium in One Week 2Health News:Woodland Hills Dental Expert Speaking at Nobel Biocare World Symposium in One Week 3Health News:Woodland Hills Dental Expert Speaking at Nobel Biocare World Symposium in One Week 4Health News:Woodland Hills Dental Expert Speaking at Nobel Biocare World Symposium in One Week 5Health News:As World Cup Comes to an End, Injuries are Star of the Show 2Health News:As World Cup Comes to an End, Injuries are Star of the Show 3Health News:Baby After Cancer Is a Reality as Shady Grove Fertility Provides Successful Treatment for Cancer Survivors 2Health News:Baby After Cancer Is a Reality as Shady Grove Fertility Provides Successful Treatment for Cancer Survivors 3Health News:Baby After Cancer Is a Reality as Shady Grove Fertility Provides Successful Treatment for Cancer Survivors 4
... The University of Houston (UH) will soon open its doors ... a new joint venture between the UH Graduate College of ... Cancer Center Division of Cancer Prevention and Population Sciences. CHEER ... the newly opened center at UH GCSW. CHEER ...
... blood vitamin D levels, there,s uncertainty about where the ... threshold amount has become controversial as several scientific societies ... University of Washington researchers conducted an observational study. They ... circulating in the blood to lower the risk of ...
... , TUESDAY, May 1 (HealthDay News) -- Children with ... hospitalized than children without arthritis, a new study says. ... higher infection risk among kids with arthritis, other arthritis ... inhibitors -- were not. Researchers analyzed Medicaid ...
... can have as much effect on the teens, substance ... "Among friendship groups with ,good parents, there,s a ... aware of your whereabouts, and your friends, parents are ... you are less likely to use substances," said Michael ...
... announced today the inaugural class of its Presidential ... early career researchers with financial support to attend ... exclusive networking and mentoring opportunities with AcademyHealth leadership ... "The presidential scholarships are an opportunity for ...
... 1, 2012 Scientists at Joslin Diabetes Center have identified ... rapamycin) protein kinase, a critical regulator of cell growth which ... finding not only illuminates the physiology of aging but could ... conditions, such as cancer, type 2 diabetes, and neurodegeneration. ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:University of Houston Graduate College of Social Work announces partnership with MD Anderson 2Health News:Researchers determine vitamin D blood level for reducing major medical risks in older adults 2Health News:Arthritis in Children Linked to Infections 2Health News:It takes a village to keep teens substance free 2Health News:First recipients of AcademyHealth's Presidential Scholarship announced 2Health News:Joslin scientists identify important mechanism that affects the aging process 2Health News:Joslin scientists identify important mechanism that affects the aging process 3
Other medicine definitionOther Tags