Navigation Links
Comparison of PCR Kleen Spin Columns to Traditional Methods for Purification of PCR Products Prior to Sequencing, Rev A

Jolanta Kolodziejek, MSc, and Professor Norbert Nowotny, PhD, Clinical Virology Group, Institute of Virology, University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna , Veterinaerplatz 1, A 1210 Vienna, Austria


Introduction
The purity of the DNA template employed in sequencing PCR (cycle sequencing) is the most critical factor in nucleotide sequencing. The presence of contaminants such as enzymes (nucleases, polymerases), salts, primers, primer- dimers , nucleotides (dNTPs or ddNTPs), ethanol, and others decre ases the quality of the sequencing scans significantly. Primer- or RNA-contaminated samples exhibit a high background and lead to misinterpretation of sequencing data. Contamination with nucleases, salts, nucleotides, and ethanol decreases read length and signal intensity and sometimes results in unre a dable sequence data.

We tested Bio-Rads PCR Kleen spin columns for purification of PCR products prior to sequencing PCR in two different experiments, and compared the resulting nucleotide sequences obtained from these samples with the sequences obtained after purification by traditional methods.


Methods
Experiment 1. Comparison of Effectiveness of Purification Method Prior to Sequencing PCR
A 510 bp RT-PCR product (100 l) was prepared using Borna disease virus as template, and three of four equal-volume aliquots of the PCR product were purified by different methods prior to sequencing. The fourth aliquot was left as an unpurified control.

The first aliquot of the PCR product was purified using PCR Kleen spin columns according to the instructions. The DNA f rom the other two aliquots was recovered from agarose slices using commercial gel extraction kits from two other suppliers (suppliers A and B).

Following purification, PCR aliquots were analyzed on a 1.2% TAE agarose gel and compared with the unpurified PCR p roduct (aliquot 4). The DNA concentration of all three purified PCR products was evaluated spectrophotometrically and compa red with the concentration of the unpurified PCR p roduct. The DNA concentrations were : unpurified product , 0.978 g/l; product purified by PCR Kleen spin column, 0.064 g / l; by supplier A gel extraction kit, 0.016 g/l; by supplier B gel extraction kit, 0.014 g/l.

Following sequencing PCR, the resulting nucleotide sequences were analyzed on an ABI PRISM 310 automated sequencer and compared .

Experiment 2. Sequencing Quality of Longer PCR P roduct After Sequencing PCR and Dye Te rminator Removal
In order to evaluate the effectiveness of PCR Kleen spin columns on the quality of longer nucleotide sequences, thre e aliquots of a 750 bp PCR product derived from Borna disease v i rus were purified using PCR Kleen spin columns. After sequencing PCR, the recovered products were purified for sequencing by three diff e rent methods: We tested one classical purification method (p recipitation in the presence of C2H5O H and 0.5 mM MgCl2) in parallel with two modern commercially available dye removal kits from two other suppliers.


Results
Experiment 1
The best yield of DNA was achieved after purification of the PCR product with the PCR Kleen spin column (see figure).

In contrast, both PCR products obtained by gel extraction, using either the protocol of supplier A or B, were only weakly detected by agarose gel analyses. These results correlated with the amount of DNA in each sample: the PCR product purified with the PCR Kleen column yielded 4 times more of the specific DNA compared to the other samples. Also, the use of PCR Kleen spin columns for purification gave rise to excellent sequencing results (the entire sequence of 510 bp was nicely readable), whereas only 200300 bases were readable in the sequences derived from the other two samples.

Experiment 2
Independently of the purification method used after sequencing PCR (classical or one of the dye removal kits), we achieved the best sequencing results when the PCR products had been purified by PCR Kleen spin columns prior to sequencing PCR: 700 bases were readable, which is the maximum achievable with the ABI PRISM 310 automated sequencer.

Discussion
The results of direct nucleotide sequencing depend on the quality and purity of the PCR products; there fore, the DNA purification step prior to sequencing plays the most importantrole. The purification method used for the sequencing PCR product is of secondary importance .

The use of PCR Kleen spin columns led to excellent sequencing results. Other advantages of this method are:
A simple and rapid procedure (4 min for PCR Kleen column vs. 3 hr for gel purification)

The purified PCR product is immediately available for sequencing PCR

No exposure to ethidium bromide or UV light

It is possible to obtain sequencing results for a PCR product within 1 day

Only one specific PCR product should be present after amplification; in cases where agarose gel electrophoresis exhibits multiple bands, purification methods based on excision of the desired specific band from the gel may be advantageous.

To summarize, we have used PCR Kleen spin columns for purification of many diff e rent PCR products, and have found this method very reliable and superior to other techniques.


The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) process is covered by patents owned by Hoffman-LaRoche. Use of the PCR process requires a license.

ABI PRISM is a trademark of Applied Biosystems.

Info rmation in this tech note was current as of the date of writing (2002) and not necessarily the date this version (rev A, 2003) was published.


back to top
'"/>

Source:


Page: All 1 2 3 4

Related biology technology :

1. PCR Performance Comparisons Between pfuturbo and Taq DNA Polymerases
2. Performance Comparisons of Commercial RT-PCR Systems
3. A Comparison Study of Lipid Tranfection Reagents in A549, NIH 3T3 and COS-7 Cell Lines
4. Comparison of Growth Techniques and Media for the Purpose of Plasmid Isolation from E. coli Using the Eppendorf Perfectprep Plasmid Mini Kit
5. TripleMaster PCR System: Direct Comparison with Competitors
6. Quantitative Measurement of Cell Proliferation Using the BrdU ELISA: A Comparison Between Colorimetric and Chemiluminescent Detection
7. Comparison of different protein quantitation methods
8. Comparison of Different Methods of mRNA Quantitation
9. Bio-Plex Cytokine Immunoassays and ELISA: Comparison of Two Methodologies in Testing Samples From Asthmatic and Healthy Children, Rev A
10. Performance Comparison of the Experion Automated Electrophoresis System and a Competing Automated System for Protein Analysis, Rev A
11. Separation and Comparison of Proteins From Virulent and Nonvirulent Strains of the Fish Pathogen Flavobacterium psychrophilum, Using a 2-D Electrophoretic Approach
Post Your Comments:
(Date:9/18/2014)... 18, 2014 Research and Markets ... Diagnostics (Polymerase Chain Reaction, In-situ hybridization, Immunohistochemistry) Market - ... offering. The global companion diagnostics market ... from 2014 to 2019. Factors such as rising need ... companion diagnostics by the pharmaceutical industry, support from regulatory ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... Leatherwood Plastics has selected Vycom’s ... stay competitive in the semiconductor, clean room and ... impact product quality and productivity, according to Dwight ... in 1980 in Lewisville, TX, Leatherwood Plastics ... left the business. Much of Leatherwood’s equipment building ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... -- U.S. biotech company Kultevat has strengthened its ... developed by the Donald Danforth Plant Science Center ... applications in production of natural rubber in Taraxicum ... under the direction of Roger Beachy , Ph.D., ... the Danforth Plant Science Center, and is used to ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... , Sept. 18, 2014  MEI Pharma, Inc. (Nasdaq: ... development of novel therapies for cancer, announced today that ... will present at BioCentury,s NewsMakers in the Biotech Industry ... Eastern time from the Millennium Broadway Hotel & Conference Center ... of the presentation can be accessed at www.meipharma.com . ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Global Companion Diagnostics (Polymerase Chain Reaction, In-situ hybridization, Immunohistochemistry) Market - Trends & Forecasts to 2019 2Global Companion Diagnostics (Polymerase Chain Reaction, In-situ hybridization, Immunohistochemistry) Market - Trends & Forecasts to 2019 3Leatherwood Plastics Selects Vycom’s Flametec PVC-C Material to Stay Competitive in Semiconductor and Lab Equipment Industries 2Kultevat obtains license of gene switch technology 2MEI Pharma To Present At BioCentury's NewsMakers Conference 2MEI Pharma To Present At BioCentury's NewsMakers Conference 3
... class of enzymes routinely used to synthesizing some of nature's ... a new way to expand on nature's chemical creativity to ... (Sept. 1) in the journal Science , a team ... at the University of Wisconsin-Madison , describes the discovery ...
... life sciences company with 120 Madison employees is bolstering ... of proteins in today's drug development market. , ,The ... Corp. 's recent acquisition of Sentigen Holding Corp., which ... Madison. , , The scientific opportunity , ,The ...
... summer, but for workers the lazy, hazy, crazy vacation days ... So now that we are all rested and relaxed, what ... , ,Well, actually neither workers or the workplace seem to ... conflict and strife between management and workers, real tensions exist ...
Cached Biology Technology:UW finds new path to anti-cancer agents 2UW finds new path to anti-cancer agents 3Invitrogen boosts drug development capability 2Workplace flexibility: Give and take or tug of war? 2Workplace flexibility: Give and take or tug of war? 3Workplace flexibility: Give and take or tug of war? 4Workplace flexibility: Give and take or tug of war? 5
(Date:9/18/2014)... Va.Sept. 18, 2014Many Americans across racial and ethnic ... greatest impact on their day-to-day life, more so ... hearing and speech (57% of African-Americans, 49% of ... Hispanics). When asked which disease or ailment is ... ranked first among African-Americans followed by AIDS/HIV. ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... characters, so you might expect that most would have ... some dogs are distinctly more pessimistic than others, research ... research is exciting because it measures positive and negative ... researchers and dog owners an insight into the outlook ... Starling, from the Faculty of Veterinary Science. Her PhD ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... from several disciplines will be celebrated tonight at the ... in improving the health of premature infants and in ... The researchers, whose work was supported by the National ... former Atomic Energy Commission, will be honored at a ... A bipartisan group of Members of Congress will be ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Americans rate losing eyesight as having greatest impact on their lives 2Americans rate losing eyesight as having greatest impact on their lives 3Dogs can be pessimists too 2Dogs can be pessimists too 33rd annual Golden Goose award ceremony honors 8 researchers; Unusual work had big results 2
... Nov. 18, 2010 The 2010 Golf Atlanta charity golf ... aimed at finding better treatments and eventually a cure for ... 15, 2010, to the Crabapple Golf Club in Alpharetta, Ga., ... Genomics Research Institute (TGen), a non-profit biomedical research facility in ...
... For Immediate Release While scientists depend on ... long and frequently frustrating process. For one Scripps Research ... Ja, an assistant professor in the Department of Metabolism ... January, was recently awarded an unsolicited grant of $60,000 ...
... November 18, 2010 The Paul G. Allen Family ... and cellular engineering research. The Allen Distinguished Investigator Awards ... Washington, California, Massachusetts and New York. The grants ... years. "A year ago, I started ...
Cached Biology News:Golf Atlanta charity tournament raises $105,000 for TGen research 2New Scripps Florida scientist awarded pair of unconventional grants 2First Allen Distinguished Investigators named 2First Allen Distinguished Investigators named 3
... 2000 instrument can be used as a ... Data Manager Software provides the means to ... the instrument. These data can then be ... such as Microsoft Excel or Lotus 123, ...
... Gasket slide kit (1x 22K gasket/slide) G2534-60003 ... or Gasket slide kit (2x 11K ... slides offered in either 11K or 22K microarray feature ... gaskets are carefully fabricated and batch tested to ensure ...
... is a new product number, ... product number. If showing no ... the old Sigma-Aldrich number (Z71,346-5) ... assistance. ID clarifier: box holds ...
... description: self locking design in ice/water ... new product number, created to easily ... no availability yet, please order under ... contact customer service for assistance. ID ...
Biology Products: