Abstract
The efficiency of the Rapid DNA Ligation Kit from
Roche Molecular Biochemicals was compared with
standard and optimized conventional ligation procedures.
The reactions generated circular recombinant
bacteriophage DNA in a three-fragment assembly
DNA ligation. Sequential blunt-end and cohesive-end
ligation, including a temperature shift from 26C to
14C, led to a more than 10-fold increase in the number
of transformants obtained. Applying a modified
protocol, the kit was found to provide a reliable, fast,
and remarkably efficient procedure for this complex
application.
Introduction
To construct a phage displaying integrin-binding
ligands, we needed a reliable and efficient ligation
procedure, by which three DNA fragments could be
assembled simultaneously, yielding circular DNA.
Such a ligation is known to require high concentrations
of the reacting DNA molecules [1], especially if
blunt-ended DNA is involved [2] and is therefore
usually circumvented by subcloning. Because of the
absence of appropriate restriction sites in the DNA
fragments, subcloning into another suitable vector
and subsequent ligation of the two fragments in this
construct was impossible in our case. A standard
ligation protocol led only to poor transformation
results, whereas parallel ligations using either an
optimized conventional procedure or the Rapid DNA
Ligation Kit from Roche Molecular Biochemicals
resulted in efficient and correct formation of the
desired cloning vector.
Materials And Methods
The bacteriophage fd-tet which confers tetracycline
resistance upon infected cells was donated by Dr.
John McCafferty (Cambridge Antibody Technology).
Two DNA fragments (here designated as fragments A
and B) had to be joined at a common unique Alu I site
and ligated with a fd-tet DNA backbone at Apa LI and
Bam HI restriction sites (Figure 1). Both insert fragments
were obtained by cleavage of cloned DNA with
the endonucleases Apa LI, Bam HI, and Alu I. The
Apa LI/Alu I fragment of insert A and the Alu I/Bam HI
fragment of insert B were purified after separation on
an agarose gel. One microgram of DNA in a total
volume of 10 l was used in the conventional ligation
reactions, with a molar ratio of phage DNA to insert A
and insert B of 1:5:5. Standard ligations of the two insert
fragments together with appropriately cleaved
fd-tet DNA were performed for 24 h at 14 C. Our optimized
procedure was comprised of two temperature
steps: first, the blunt-end ligation of the insert fragments
A and B for 18 h at 26C; second, the cohesiveended
vector DNA was added, and the ligation continued
for an additional 6 h at 14C [3]. The protocol
for the Rapid DNA Ligation Kit was modified in accordance
with our optimized conventional procedure.
The blunt-end ligation mixture (290 ng DNA in a total
volume of 20 l) was ligated for 30 min at 26C. Next,
710 ng vector DNA was added in a volume of 1 l with
further incubation for 10 min at room temperature.
The ligation mixtures were then cooled to 0C without
heat-inactivation of the ligase, and one third of each
reaction was used to transform DH5a competent
cells, which were plated on 140 mm Petri dishes containing
30 mg tetracycline/ml LB medium. After a 20 h
incubation period, colonies were counted, and doublestranded
phage DNA of a representative number
purified with the High PureTM Plasmid Isolation Kit.
The DNA was screened by restriction analysis with the
endonuclease Sca I, followed by sequencing of all
restriction-positive clones using the primer
5'-TGAATTTTCTGTATGAGG-3', the T7 Sequenase 2.0
kit, and 33PdATP from Amersham, according to the
manufacturers instructions.
Results and Discussion
Although a T4 DNA ligase-overexpressing E. coli
strain that allows cloning of linear DNA molecules
was reported recently [4], efficient transformation of
E. coli normally requires circular DNA. However, the
formation of a circular structure in a three-fragment
assembly ligation is a relatively rare event. At high DNA
concentrations, which are crucial for a three-component
assembly ligation [1], predominantly intermolecular
ligation events leading to linear products
occur, while DNA circularization is favored at low
concentrations of the DNA fragments [5]. Our case
was further complicated by the need to ligate two
blunt-ended DNA fragments. Blunt-end ligation is
known to be one to two orders of magnitude less
efficient than cohesive-end ligation [6]. We chose to
optimize the conventional procedure by sequential
ligation of blunt- and cohesive DNA ends using different
temperatures for the two processes. Therefore,
we started the reaction at 26C, which was reported
to be the optimal temperature for the joining of bluntended
termini by T4 DNA ligase [7]. We followed this
with cohesive-end ligation and circularization of our
DNA at 14C, the temperature generally regarded as
the best compromise to retain sufficient activity of the
enzyme while still allowing relatively stable hydrogenbonded association of cohesive termini [8]. This strategy
led to a more than 10-fold increase in the number
of transformants obtained compared with a control
ligation performed at single temperature (Table 1).
Using a protocol for the Rapid DNA Ligation Kit that
was still suboptimal with respect to DNA concentration
and recommended dephosphorylation of the
vector DNA, the yield of transformants was 5-fold
higher than with the optimized conventional ligation
procedure. This remarkably high efficiency of the kit
is most likely due to an optimized composition of the
ligation buffer.
Although, in theory, 100% correct clones can be
obtained by a strategy involving fragments that are
designed to join in the desired order and orientation,
a notable number of false-positive clones arose in all
our ligation experiments. Most of them were due to
contamination resulting from incompletely cleaved
and self-ligated phage DNA backbone. A relatively
small proportion of deletion mutants and clones containing
a doubled phage backbone was also found.
The excellent performance of the Rapid DNA Ligation
Kit was reproducible with different insert pairs. Thus,
the kit provides a reliable and remarkably efficient
way for the three-fragment assembly DNA ligation to
generate circular DNA under minimal time requirements.
'"/>Source:
Page: All 1 2 3 4 Related biology technology :1.
New Yeast Cloning System for Producing Proteins with Native Amino Acid
Sequences2.
Enhanced PCR Cloning System3.
pfuturbo DNA Polymerase:
A High-Performance, High-Fidelity Enzyme Ideal for PCR Cloning4.
Functional Cloning Using
ViraPort Retroviral cDNA Expression Libraries5.
Mammalian Expression Vector for Efficient Cloning of PCR Fragments6.
QIAGEN PCR CloningPlus Kit7.
Efficient Cloning and Electro-transformation of Large Eukaryotic DNA Fragments8.
Fluorescence-Based Single-Tube Assays to Rapidly Detect Human Gene Mutations9.
Development of a Multiplex Bead-Based Assay for Antibody Screening of a Nonhuman Primate Colony on the Bio-Plex System10.
A Mix-and-Read Cell-Based Assay for Hybridoma Screening Using the FMAT
8100 HTS System11.
Mix-and-Read, Bead- and Cell-Based Immunoassays Using the FMAT 8100 HTS System