Navigation Links
Recent Reports Regarding Mercury and High Fructose Corn Syrup Flawed and Misleading

SAN FRANCISCO, Jan. 30 /PRNewswire/ -- ChemRisk, a leading scientific consulting firm, was asked by the Corn Refiners Association (CRA) to examine the recent publication by Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy (IATP), "Not So Sweet: Missing Mercury and High Fructose Corn Syrup," and the Environmental Health journal publication "Mercury from chlor-alkali plants: measured concentrations in food product sugar," by Dufault et al, 2009, and to offer our comments and analysis.

    In summary we found:
    -- The IATP report and Environmental Health article it references fall
       well below standards for proper scientific research and published
    -- The authors of both publications provide incomplete data and misleading
    -- Methods described by the authors deviate from standard procedure in
       testing for mercury.
    -- The authors ignore important distinctions between organic and other
       forms of mercury and their implications for assessing human health
    -- Even if it were assumed that the mercury content found in the extremely
       limited sampling of foods and beverages was representative, the amounts
       are far lower than levels of concern set by government agencies.
    -- The authors assume that the total mercury they detected in a
       questionably small sampling of consumer foods is primarily the result
       of high fructose corn syrup; an assumption that has not been properly
       tested or validated.  The recipes for the items studied may have had
       multiple sources of potential contamination

To imply that there is a safety concern to consumers based on the findings presented is both incorrect and irresponsible.

By combining the results of a four-year-old sampling analysis of high fructose corn syrup with a more recent testing of branded foods and beverages for total mercury, the IATP report fails to recognize basic scientific facts regarding mercury; ignores common dietary sources of mercury, an element that is widely present in our environment at low concentrations; and makes improper assumptions regarding the source of the mercury measured in various branded food products.

    -- More than two-thirds of the samples analyzed by IATP had no detectable
       level of mercury at all. In the remaining sample, most of these were at
       or near the limit of detection. The average concentration for the 17
       samples with detectable levels was only 128 parts per trillion (ppt).
       EPA sets limits for mercury in drinking water at two parts per billion.
    -- It is well known that small amounts of mercury are broadly present in
       our environment. For example, Health Canada reported in 2003 that the
       concentrations of total mercury in steak ranged from 420 to 1,800 parts
       per trillion (ppt); fresh pork contained 1,100 to 1,500 ppt; organ
       meats (liver and kidney) contained over 2,100 ppt; and lamb contained
       290 to 2,300 ppt of total mercury.  (Dabeka et al, 2003)  For the sake
       of reference, one part per trillion is equal to one drop of water
       spread out into 26 Olympic-size swimming pools.  (Washington Suburban
       Sanitary Commission, 2009)
    -- That same study by Health Canada looked at mercury in seafood, finding
       amounts that ranged from 40,000 ppt in fresh or frozen marine fish to
       148,000 ppt in canned fish.  Other foods, such as canned mushrooms, had
       5,100 to 16,000 ppt total mercury, grapes had 180 to 590 ppt,
       blueberries 210 to 640 ppt, rice 570 to 1,800 ppt, raisins upwards of
       700 ppt, and shelled seeds up to 1,000 parts per trillion (ppt).
    -- The levels noted above are substantially greater than those found by
       Wallinga and colleagues in their reports.  (Dabeka et al, 2003)  Other
       studies by other international authorities (FDA, United Kingdom Food
       Standards Agency and others) have found similar or higher levels of
       mercury in common components of a typical human diet.  (FDA, 2006;
       Ysart et al, 2000)
    -- IATP assumes that the total mercury they detected in a questionably
       small sampling of consumer foods is primarily the result of high
       fructose corn syrup; an assumption that has not been properly tested or
       validated. In fact, the authors do not attempt to characterize whether
       there may be mercury in any other ingredients contained within the
       consumer products tested, even while the recipes for the items studied
       may have had multiple sources of potential contamination. As we have
       mentioned, very small amounts of mercury are practically ubiquitous in
       our society.
    -- IATP demonstrates a gross lack of understanding of the current state of
       knowledge of the different forms of mercury and their effect on the
       human body. This is illustrated in their statement that "The mercury
       found in HFCS may be a different form of mercury than the methylmercury
       typically found in fish (we just don't know), but it poses a risk just
       the same.  Mercury in any form can be toxic to the developing brain."
       (Wallinga et al, 2009). The ATSDR (Agency for Toxic Substances and
       Disease Registry) is a sister agency of the Centers for Disease
       Control, and regularly provides reviews of chemicals in our
       society that may pose a risk to human health. Regarding mercury, it is
       clear that inorganic forms are considered to be much less dangerous to
       humans than organic forms, with absorption generally at least ten times
       less (ATSDR, Public Health Statement on Mercury, 1999).

Dr. Dennis Paustenbach is a board-certified toxicologist and industrial hygienist with nearly 25 years of experience in risk assessment, environmental engineering, ecotoxicology, and occupational health. He is currently the President of ChemRisk, Inc., a consulting firm which specializes in human and ecological risk assessment and risk analysis of pharmaceuticals and medical devices. ChemRisk's professionals have a longstanding reputation for thorough scientific analysis and for sharing their results both at major scientific meetings and in the peer-reviewed scientific literature. ChemRisk's more than 60 scientists are experienced in addressing health and safety concerns, with backgrounds including toxicology, industrial hygiene, epidemiology, ecotoxicology, environmental sciences, medicine, statistical analysis, and risk assessment. Many of the more than 1,000 papers presented at scientific conferences and 400 papers published by ChemRisk(R) scientists are frequently referenced in regulatory decision-making and relied upon in litigation proceedings.

Copyright©2009 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related biology technology :

1. Recent Advances in Organic Chemistry Using Real-Time In Situ FTIR
2. American Oriental Bioengineering Comments on Recent Property Purchase
3. Bionovo to Present Recent Findings of BN107, its Anticancer Agent, at the 31st Annual San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium
4. New Report Provides Expert Analysis of Recent Advances and Setbacks in Parkinsons Disease Drug Development
5. TorreyPines Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter 2008 Results and Recent Accomplishments
6. Nventa Biopharmaceuticals Announces Third Quarter 2008 Financial Results and Recent Corporate Highlights
7. [video] Wall St. Networks 3-Minute Press Show Features Executive Interviews and Highlights Recent Press for the Following: GTHR, BHRT, AGO
8. [video] Wall St. Networks 3-Minute Press Show Features Executive Interviews and Highlights Recent Press for the Following: IMMU, KYUS
9. Water Street Health Care Partners Completes Agreement With Gentiva Health Services to Acquire Majority Ownership of CareCentrix
10. MGT Capital Investments Reports Second Quarter 2008 Financial Results and Provides Update on Recent Developments
11. Arena Pharmaceuticals Announces Second Quarter 2008 Financial Results and Recent and Second Quarter Highlights
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/11/2017)... ... 2017 , ... ComplianceOnline’s Medical Device Summit is back for its 4th year. ... San Francisco, CA. The Summit brings together current and former FDA office bearers, regulators, ... government officials from around the world to address key issues in device compliance, quality ...
(Date:10/11/2017)... LAGUNA HILLS, Calif. , Oct. 11, 2017  SkylineDx ... London (ICR) and University of Leeds ... to risk-stratify patients with multiple myeloma (MM), in a multi-centric ... The University of Leeds is the ... UK, and ICR will perform the testing services to include ...
(Date:10/11/2017)... ... October 11, 2017 , ... Singh ... orphan drug designation to SBT-100, its novel anti-STAT3 (Signal Transducer and Activator of ... SBT-100 is able to cross the cell membrane and bind intracellular STAT3 and ...
(Date:10/10/2017)... ... October 10, 2017 , ... ... FirstHand program has won a US2020 STEM Mentoring Award. Representatives of the FirstHand ... Excellence in Volunteer Experience from US2020. , US2020’s mission is to change the ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
(Date:4/5/2017)... , April 5, 2017  The Allen Institute for ... Cell Explorer: a one-of-a-kind portal and dynamic digital window ... imaging data, the first application of deep learning to ... stem cell lines and a growing suite of powerful ... for these and future publicly available resources created and ...
(Date:4/4/2017)... 2017   EyeLock LLC , a leader of ... States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has issued U.S. ... of an iris image with a face image acquired ... company,s 45 th issued patent. ... given the multi-modal biometric capabilities that have recently come ...
(Date:3/30/2017)... KONG , March 30, 2017 The ... a system for three-dimensional (3D) fingerprint identification by adopting ground breaking ... into a new realm of speed and accuracy for use in ... at an affordable cost. ... ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):