Navigation Links
Public must be involved in nanotech policy debate demands groundbreaking

Decision-making on science especially emerging technologies such as nanotechnology must become more democratic, a new report on science policy released today argues. The group of leading European academics behind the 'Reconfiguring Responsibility' report argue forcefully that current governance activities are limiting public debate and may repeat mistakes made in managing GM.

The DEEPEN report comes in the wake of a move within UK and European science policy-making to govern 'upstream' in a technology's development, before its impacts become irreversible, and to involve the public in decision-making. Analysing this move in the context of nanotechnology, the 'Reconfiguring Responsibility' report argues that these developments do not go nearly far enough. According to Professor Phil Macnaghten - who is based at Durham University and who has led the EU-funded project involving researchers from the UK, Germany, the Netherlands and Portugal - while talk of 'responsible development' is a step in the right direction, it often hides outdated assumptions: "Technologies are being driven forward with insufficient reflection on why they are being developed and on what this is likely to mean for future society. The public is keen to be involved in deliberating the often far-reaching questions that science is addressing, and policymakers need to find new ways to ensure that public views are heard, treated with respect and used to inform science policy."

Professor Richard Jones FRS, a leading nanoscientist who until recently was the senior advisor for nanotechnology for the UK government's science funding agency, agrees. "I believe that involving the public in decision making on science can lead to better outcomes as well as being fascinating and rewarding for the scientists involved. If we are to continue to make nanotechnology a more socially responsible science we need to build on research such as that discussed in the 'Reconfiguring Responsibility' report."

The need for action is made more pressing by the fact that nanotechnology has the potential to fundamentally change everyday life and thus raises profound social and ethical questions. Attention has recently focussed on the uncertainties surrounding its long-term effects on human health and the environment, but the 'Reconfiguring Responsibility' study indicates that public concern also focus on the kind of society being created by such technologies. "It's great that there is a move towards public dialogue and more responsible development of new technologies," continues Macnaghten, "but at the moment this move doesn't go far enough. In the case of nanotechnology we find public hunger to be included in shaping the technology's development. However, policy processes don't yet fully take this into account. We'd like to see the terms of the debate being shaken up."

As with the GM debate, the research has found that most non-scientists accept that a degree of risk is inevitable, but are concerned about the motivations driving technology. Indeed, many people question whether the vaunted benefits of nanotechnology in everything from defence to cosmetics to communications technology will in practice be beneficial at all.

The report gives a number of recommendations to policy makers involved in governing nanotechnology and similar technologies, including the need to be innovative in finding ways to involve the public and to move away from policy making that simply reacts to new findings or applications. "We want our analysis to be helpful to those at the cutting edge of decision making in science," says Macnaghten, "while at the same time not shying away from the fact that this presents a challenge to the way that things are being done."


Contact: Richard Hayhurst
Durham University

Related biology technology :

1. Alexandria Real Estate Equities, Inc. Announces Public Follow-on Offering of 3,000,000 Shares of Common Stock
2. Public attitudes to new technology: Lessons for regulators
3. Omeros Commences Initial Public Offering of Common Stock
4. Rigel Announces Pricing of Public Offering of 13,000,000 Shares of Common Stock
5. OrbusNeichs Genous(TM) Bio-engineered R stent(TM) is Feasible in Patients Requiring Undeferrable Non-Cardiac Surgery, International Journal of Cardiology Publication Reports
6. Greenway Medical Technologies Plays Leading Role in Interoperability Demonstrations at Seventh Annual Public Health Information Network (PHIN) Conference
7. Vasogen and IntelliPharmaCeutics to Combine to Create Publicly-traded Specialty Pharmaceutical Company
8. Accera Announces Peer-Reviewed Publication of the Results of its 90-Day Clinical Study of AC-1202 (Axona(TM) ) in Mild to Moderate Alzheimers Disease
9. Cumberland Pharmaceuticals Announces Pricing of Its Initial Public Offering of Common Stock
10. Micromet Closes $80.5 Million Public Offering of Common Stock
11. Human Genome Sciences Announces Closing of Public Offering
Post Your Comments:
(Date:12/1/2015)... 1, 2015 Frost & Sullivan is ... program addresses ways companies can innovate and transform ... --> ... --> ... well as the disrupting factors altering the industry, ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... December 01, 2015 , ... ... (AFM) announces Park NX10 SICM Module, an add-on scanning ion conductance microscopy module ... power of SICM to an AFM. , Park SICM benefits virtually all materials ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... , December 1, 2015 Dr. Harry Lander , President ... serving as Chief Science Officer and recruits five ... Harry Lander , President of Regen, expands his role to ... recruits five distinguished scientists to join advisory team ... expands his role to include serving as ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Global Stem Cells Group ... a new closed system for isolating adipose-derived stem cells. The announcement starts a new ... adipose tissue. SVF is a component of the lipoaspirate obtained from liposuction of excess ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
(Date:11/20/2015)... , November 20, 2015 NXTD ... focused on the growing mobile commerce market and creator ... Gino Pereira , was recently interviewed on The ... air on this weekend on Bloomberg Europe , ... . --> NXTD ) ("NXT-ID" or the ...
(Date:11/17/2015)... PARIS , November 17, 2015 ... November 2015.   --> Paris from ... --> DERMALOG, the biometrics innovation leader, has invented the ... and fingerprints on the same scanning surface. Until now two ... fingerprints. Now one scanner can capture both on the same ...
(Date:11/12/2015)... golden retriever that stayed healthy despite having the gene ... new lead for treating this muscle-wasting disorder, report scientists ... and Harvard and the University of São Paolo in ... pinpoints a protective gene that boosts muscle regeneration, ... Children,s lab of Lou Kunkel , PhD, is ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):