Navigation Links
Penn and Brown researchers demonstrate earthquake friction effect at the nanoscale
Date:11/30/2011

PHILADELPHIA Earthquakes are some of the most daunting natural disasters that scientists try to analyze. Though the earth's major fault lines are well known, there is little scientists can do to predict when an earthquake will occur or how strong it will be. And, though earthquakes involve millions of tons of rock, a team of University of Pennsylvania and Brown University researchers has helped discover an aspect of friction on the nanoscale that may lead to a better understanding of the disasters.

Robert Carpick, a professor who chairs the Department of Mechanical Engineering and Applied Mechanics in Penn's School of Engineering and Applied Science, led the research in collaboration with Terry Tullis and David Goldsby, professors of geological science at Brown. The experimental and modeling work was conducted by first author Qunyang Li, a postdoctoral researcher in Carpick's group, who has recently been appointed an associate professor in the School of Aerospace at Tsinghua University, China.

Their work will be published in the journal Nature.

The team's research was spurred by an unusual phenomenon that has been observed in both natural and laboratory-simulated faults: materials become more resistant to sliding the longer they are in contact with one another. This trait is actually fundamental to why earthquakes happen at all. The longer materials are in contact, the stronger the resistance between them and the more violent and unstable the subsequent sliding is. Energy is stored over the time the materials are in contact and is then catastrophically released as an earthquake.

While geologists, physicists and mechanics researchers have studied this phenomenon for decades, the mechanism behind this increase of friction over time has only been hypothesized. There are two main theories as to why this "frictional aging" occurs.

"One hypothesis is that points of contact deform and grow over time that contact quantity increases," Carpick said. "The other is that bonding at the points of contact strengthens over time that contact quality increases."

The difficulty in proving that either theory holds true lies in the fact that points of contact are necessarily embedded at the juncture of two materials and are therefore hard to observe. One of the original breakthrough experiments on these theories projected light through transparent materials held together to measure the growth of apparent contact points. While this lent credence to the contact quantity theory, there was not yet a way to assess the bond strengths at those individual points of contacts or to be sure that the observations were of single points of contacts or clusters of even smaller nanoscale contacts.

It was not until Carpick and Tullis met at a conference designed to bring physicists and mechanics researchers together with geologists that they realized that the tools of the former group could resolve the latter group's contact quality theory. The solution came from moving from the massive scale of earthquakes to the smallest scales imaginable.

"We want to simplify the case," Li said. "So in our experiment we look at only one point of contact: the tip of an atomic force microscope."

An atomic force microscope is an ideal tool for investigating bonding strength where two surfaces meet. Instead of using light, atomic force microscopes measure nanoscale details using an extremely sharp probe tip that is sensitive to the push and pull of individual atoms.

The researchers simulated rock-on-rock contact with silica, a major component in most geological materials. They pressed a silica tip against a silica surface for different lengths of time and then dragged it to measure the amount of friction it experienced. They repeated these experiments with surfaces made out of different materials: diamond and graphite. Critically, both diamond and graphite are chemically inert. As they don't easily form chemical bonds with silica, any frictional aging that occurred with them would necessarily be due to changing contact area and not increased bond strength.

The results showed a stark difference in the frictional aging between the materials.

"We saw a huge amount of aging with silica on silica. But with silica on diamond or graphite, even though the tip is experiencing about the same stress levels, we see almost no aging," Li said. "If the increasing contact area was responsible for the increase in frictional aging, you would see similar amounts in these cases. You might even see more aging with diamond because it is stiffer, leading to a slightly higher stress level in the silica, and this would cause more deformation on the tip."

The frictional aging seen in the silica-on-silica experiment was so intense that the researchers had another mystery on their hands: how to reconcile strong aging on the nanoscale with the weaker level seen on the macroscale where earthquakes actually occur.

The solution to that puzzle stems from the fact that not all contact points are created equal. Two different contact points on the same surface that are close to one another will sense each other's presence. This "elastic coupling," as it is known, means that only a few of the contact points within an area will be resisting the sliding motion at their full capacity; some will have started to slide earlier, and others will slide later. It is too difficult to make them all slide at once.

So, the overall level of resistance relies not only on the maximum resistance any contact point can provide, but also on the small fraction of contact points able to provide this resistance.

"When you take a lot of contact points,"Carpick said, "all of them could have this large amount of aging. But when you try to shear them, you see only a small fraction reach that very high value of friction at any given time. So, you need a very large effect on the level of a single contact point to get even a very modest effect on the macroscopic scale."

While showing that nansocale experiment can provide useful data for these kinds of applications was in itself an important finding for the research team, the ability to reconcile the laboratory data with geologists' observations will have a lasting effect on the field.

"If we can understand the fundamental physics," Tullis said, "then theories and equations based on that physics would have the capability of being extrapolated beyond the laboratory scale. Therefore we could use them with more confidence in all the earthquake modeling that's already being done."

"We're not ruling out the quantity argument, we're just ruling in the quality argument," Carpick said. "Future research will go to higher stress levels, where maybe contact quantity could start to come into play. We'd also like to look at different temperatures, which matter in the geological context, and do experiments where we can actually watch the contact in real time, using an electron microscope."


'/>"/>

Contact: Evan Lerner
elerner@upenn.edu
215-573-6604
University of Pennsylvania
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology technology :

1. [video] David Brown, President and CEO of LifeVantage Corporation, Discusses Record Page Views on WallSt.nets 3-Minute Press Show
2. NSTI Announces the 12th Annual Nanotech Conference & Expo 2009 May 3-7, at the George R. Brown Convention Center in Houston, Texas
3. Jennifer Brownstein, of CONNEXION Healthcare, Honored as Rising Star by Healthcare Businesswomens Association
4. Brown chemists create more efficient palladium fuel cell catalysts
5. TechConnect World Announces The CancerNano 2009 Symposium May 3-7, at the George R. Brown Convention Center in Houston
6. TechConnect World Conference Showcases Houston Leaders May 3-7, at the George R. Brown Convention Center
7. Marriott Resort Magically Turns Brown Grease "Green" With The Cost-Cutting Hydrologix GRS
8. Brown engineering professor wins prestigious White House award
9. Veteran Intellectual Property Team Joins Brown Rudnick
10. Brown physicist discovers odd, fluctuating magnetic waves
11. Silicon Kinetics Announces Addition of Dr. Rick Brown and Dr. Eric Topol to Its Board of Directors
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/4/2016)... ... , ... Many of the engineers at FireflySci, Inc. have been manufacturing quartz ... from other cuvette manufacturers is their supercharged customer service and their extensive database of ... steady flow of inside information, they have recently revamped their manufacturing techniques to reduce ...
(Date:2/3/2016)... WARRINGTON, Pa. , Feb. 3, 2016 /PRNewswire/ ... biotechnology company focused on developing aerosolized KL4 surfactant ... Board of Directors has approved an inducement award ... Craig Fraser , its newly appointed President and ... the Board,s Compensation Committee on February 1, 2016 ...
(Date:2/3/2016)... Feb. 3, 2016 Ascendis Pharma A/S (Nasdaq: ... applies its innovative TransCon technology to address significant unmet ... upcoming investor conference.Event:2016 Leerink Partners Global Healthcare Conference Location: ... Wednesday, February 10, 2016 Time:  , 11:55am EST ... --> An audio webcast of this event ...
(Date:2/3/2016)... Feb. 3, 2016 New Jersey Health Foundation ... $1 million for researchers in New ... research that demonstrates exciting potential.   ... for the New Jersey Health Foundation Research Grant ... these educational institutions— Princeton University, Rutgers University, Rowan ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
(Date:1/20/2016)... SAN JOSE, Calif. , Jan. 20, 2016 ... leading developer of human interface solutions, today announced ... touch controller solution for wearables and small screen ... appliances such as printers. Supporting round and rectangular ... the S1423 offers excellent performance with moisture on ...
(Date:1/13/2016)... ALBANY, New York , January 13, 2016 /PRNewswire/ ... Transparency Market Research has published a new market report ... Share, Growth, Trends, and Forecast, 2015 - 2023. According to ... mn in 2014 and is anticipated to reach US$1,625.8 ... from 2015 to 2023. In terms of volume, the ...
(Date:1/11/2016)... 11, 2016  higi, the leading retail and ... locations, web and mobile, today announced it has ... existing investors. --> ... further innovate higi,s health platform – its network ... – including expanding services and programs to retail ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):