Navigation Links
Consumers Ask California Appellate Court to Reconsider Cipro Anticompetitive Reverse Payment Agreements

SAN DIEGO, May 18 /PRNewswire/ -- Attorneys representing plaintiffs who overpaid for the antibiotic Cipro are asking a California appellate court to reverse a lower court ruling that set aside antitrust claims against Bayer Corporation.  The case involves the agreement Bayer made with generic competitors to prevent competition and to maintain Cipro prices at high levels. The plaintiffs are a certified class of California consumers, union health and welfare funds, and others.

In their brief, filed late last week with the California Court of Appeal for the Fourth Appellate District in San Diego, the attorneys ask the Court to allow a jury to determine whether a patent holder violates California antitrust laws by paying its generic competitors hundreds of millions of dollars not to compete.

That's what happened between 1997 and 2004 when Bayer, with U.S. headquarters in Pittsburgh, Pa., signed an exclusionary reverse payment agreement with Montvale, N.J.-based Barr Laboratories, under which Barr agreed not to produce its generic version of Cipro.  In exchange, Bayer paid Barr and other generic drug manufacturers $398.1 million, preserving Cipro as the only choice for consumers and thereby maintaining, even increasing, its cost.

While the patent on Cipro expired in 2004, attorneys representing consumers and third-party payers argue that those groups paid far more for the drug than they should have.  They're asking the California appellate court to set aside a summary judgment granted by a lower court in Bayer's and Barr's favor last year. 

In that ruling, California Superior Court Judge Richard E.L. Strauss adopted the standard set forth in a decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit in a reverse payment case involving the drug Tamoxifen. However, a panel of judges ruling in a separate Cipro case at the 2nd Circuit recently identified "compelling reasons" to reconsider the Tamoxifen case, and went so far as to invite the Cipro plaintiffs to petition for a hearing of the entire court to address "the important interests identified."

In addition, the Obama Administration; members of Congress; the Federal Trade Commission; the Department of Justice, state attorneys general, including the Attorney General of California; public interest groups; scholars and medical professionals are on record saying these exclusionary reverse payment agreements are wrong.

"The whole point of having generic drugs is to lower health care costs, including the money consumers pay for badly needed medications," says attorney Dan Drachler of Zwerling, Schachter & Zwerling, LLP, who represents the plaintiffs along with attorney Joseph Saveri of Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, LLP.  "The agreements between Bayer and the other companies avoided the law, kept prices high and protected unreasonable profits for the drug manufacturers - profits paid for by everyone who bought the drug.  If we truly are concerned about the high cost of health care in this country, courts must enforce the antitrust laws and prohibit exclusionary reverse payment agreements."

With offices in New York City, Garden City, N.Y., and Seattle, Zwerling, Schachter & Zwerling, LLP attorneys play a leading role in numerous major securities cases, complex commercial litigation and antitrust matters pending in federal and state courts across the nation. The firm has been recognized by courts throughout the country as highly experienced and skilled in complex litigation, particularly with respect to federal securities class-action litigation.

More information is available at

Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, LLP, with offices in San Francisco, New York and Nashville, Tenn., is among the largest law firms in the United States that represents plaintiffs only.  The firm has a comprehensive practice which includes antitrust, dangerous or defective products, environmental damage, and employment discrimination.  The firm has a national reputation for professional integrity and the efficient and responsible prosecution of its clients' claims.

More information is available at

For more information about the appeal in the California Cipro class-action case, please contact Mark Annick at 800-559-4534 (office), 214-213-1754 (mobile) or

SOURCE Zwerling, Schachter & Zwerling, LLP
Copyright©2010 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related biology technology :

1. Project on Emerging Nanotechnologies and Consumers Union collaborate on ConsumersTalkNano
2. Consumers Call On Interstate Stem Cell Group To Endorse Open Meetings
3. Genelex Corporation Defends Consumers Right to Obtain DNA Information:
4. Trusted LASIK Surgeons Welcomes Mobile Alabama Expert Refractive Eye Surgeon Richard Duffey, M.D. to Its LASIK Directory For Consumers
5. Consumers Looking to Sustainable Food Production to Feed Global Population
6. AIM Pharmakon (API) Announced a New Proprietary Premium-Quality Natural Concentrated Liquid Calcium and Mineral Supplement Now Available Direct to Consumers
7. Trusted LASIK Surgeons Welcomes Leading Laser Expert and Inventor Jon Dishler, M.D., to Its Unique LASIK Eye Surgeon Directory for Consumers
8. AGA Institute and Horizon Therapeutics Launch Connect to Protect Program to Educate Physicians and Consumers on Risks Associated With NSAID Use
9. I Walk Because Program Gives Consumers a Voice
10. iSource Networks Partners with inVentiv Health to Develop New Technology Platform for Reaching Healthcare Consumers
11. BioMarin Licenses Technology From Leading Cystic Fibrosis Research Laboratory at the University of California, San Francisco
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/25/2015)... 25, 2015 /PRNewswire/ - Aeterna Zentaris Inc. (NASDAQ:  AEZS; ... and prospects remain fundamentally strong and highlights the ... recently received DSMB recommendation to continue the ZoptEC ... of the final interim efficacy and safety data ... in men with heavily pretreated castration- and Taxane-resistant ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... LUMPUR, Malaysia , Nov. 24, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... global contract research organisation (CRO) market. The trend ... result in lower margins but higher volume share ... increased capacity and scale, however, margins in the ... Research Organisation (CRO) Market ( ), ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... ... November 24, 2015 , ... Copper is an ... is bound to proteins, copper is also toxic to cells. With a $1.3 ... Institute (WPI) will conduct a systematic study of copper in the bacteria Pseudomonas ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... ... November 24, 2015 , ... This fall, global software solutions leader ... five states to develop and pitch their BIG ideas to improve health and wellness ... competing for votes to win the title of SAP's Teen Innovator, an all-expenses paid ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
(Date:10/29/2015)... 2015 Daon, a global leader in mobile ... a new version of its IdentityX Platform , ... America have already installed IdentityX v4.0 and ... FIDO UAF certified server component as an ... FIDO features. These customers include some of the largest ...
(Date:10/29/2015)... 2015  Connected health pioneer, Joseph C. Kvedar ... technology-enabled health and wellness, and the business opportunities that ... The Internet of Healthy Things . Long before ... existed, Dr. Kvedar, vice president, Connected Health, Partners HealthCare, ... moving care from the hospital or doctor,s office into ...
(Date:10/29/2015)... Today, LifeBEAM , a leader ... a global leader in technical performance sports clothing ... advanced bio-sensing technology. The hat will allow fitness ... biometrics to improve overall training performance. As a ... bring together the most advanced technology, extensive understanding ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):