Navigation Links
CWRU class earns Science magazine prize for innovation

Science magazine has awarded a prize for Inquiry-Based Instruction to a Case Western Reserve University class that melds biology, computer modeling, mathematical analysis and writing.

"Dynamics of Biological Systems," taught by Biology Professor Hillel Chiel and three graduate assistants, abandons traditional lectures altogether in favor of learning by doing. The teachers call the class an example of the use of the continual improvement model in education.

In it, Chiel pairs biology majors with engineering, physics or math majors, and has them concentrate on building academic and collaborative skills as they apply math to biological questions. Teachers provide guidance, not answers, often working one-on-one through class time.

Chiel, and doctoral students Jeffery P. Gill, Jeffrey M. McManus and Kendrick M. Shaw, describe "Dynamics" and the philosophy behind the course in this week's issue of Science. The story is embargoed until 2 p.m. U.S. Eastern Time Thursday, May 24.

The Science Prize for Inquiry-Based Instruction was established to encourage innovation and excellence in education by recognizing outstanding, inquiry-based science and design-based engineering education. Winners are selected by the editors of Science with the assistance of a judging panel composed of teachers and researchers in relevant science and engineering fields.

Each month, Science publishes an essay by a recipient of the award, which explains the winning project. Only 20 percent of submitted entries go on to become winners.

"The vast majority of biologists hate math and usually don't like programming," Chiel said. "Many engineers have been forced to take biology and hate it because of the memorization." The prevalence of these attitudes is reflected in questionnaires the students complete at the beginning of the semester.

This class, however, puts the two disciplines firmly in students' hands, to explore and build proficiency, and, eventually, to replicate and build on recent math models used in the biological sciences. The course is cross-listed as both a biology and biomedical engineering class.

"I've previously taken regular calculus classes with engineers and wondered what would the classes ever be useful for," said Kate Coyle, a biology major who completed the Dynamics class and graduated this semester. "Labs I've had in biology and physics show you the protocol and the expected result.

"This is not the same, at all. We were solving real problems every day."

Students work through problems using an online interactive textbook, Dynamics of Biological Systems: A Modeling Manual Chiel wrote and the computer programming language Mathematica, which scientists worldwide rely on to build mathematical models of complex systems. Chiel's book is available free to students as well as teachers who may want to use it as is or as a model for their own classes.

When teams become stuck on a problem, ,Chiel or a teaching assistant makes suggestions, gives clues and tries to coax out the answer. After success, teachers quiz individuals about how they found the solution and what they'd learned.

The class of 30 is spread out among hexagonal tables. Teams power up their laptops and go to work. Each day the teachers rotate to a different group of students, and after each class they compare notes on who has mastered the skills and who needs extra help, Gill said.

When the second half of the semester begins, teams choose a mathematical model that was recently published in a scientific journal, begin reconstructing and analyzing it and then writing in detail what they learn. The students then extend the model to answer new questions that they ask themselves, and write up results as if they were writing for a scientific journal.

Coyle and her teammates Valencia Williams and Joshua DeRivera focused on a paper that used math models to describe HIV's effects on the body, based on T-cell and free virus populations in the blood. Coyle, Williams and DeRivera found the model worked well in early stages of the disease, but was not as accurate for the late stages.

The team varied one parameter over time to simulate an exponential increase in the replication rate of the virus as it mutates from a slow-growing to a fast-growing strain, Coyle explained. This allowed them to preserve the original model's accuracy during early behavior and also reach a realistic end-stage value.

Chiel has developed the class over a decade, based on feedback from students and evidence that individuals learned and retained skills and understood concepts of biology, math and programming better under this process.

"What I find so cool is that by the last few weeks of the module, we're having really professional discussions with students," Chiel said.

By the end of the course, biology majors feel more competent in computer programming and the engineers more competent in biology and programming, according to end-of-semester questionnaires.

Since abandoning lectures for hands-on, continual development and reinforcement, overall class scores are higher on the final, conceptual exam and final grades, on average, have increased by slightly more than one letter grade.

It is much more challenging to teach the class in this way, Chiel concludes, but on the whole much more fun and effective for both students and teachers.

Contact: Kevin Mayhood
Case Western Reserve University

Related biology technology :

1. Reliant Technologies Announces Canadian Launch of Fraxel re:pair(R) Laser: A New Class of Treatment Therapy for CO2 Laser Skin Resurfacing
2. Abeome Forms First Class Scientific Advisory Board
3. Ameristar National Charity Golf Classic Raises More Than $1.1 Million for Buoniconti Fund to Cure Paralysis and Christopher & Dana Reeve Foundation
4. Shareholder Class Action Filed Against Elan Corporation, plc by the Law Firm of Barroway Topaz Kessler Meltzer & Check, LLP
5. Laboratory Customers Name bioMerieux Top Of Class for Microbiology
6. Northwest Biotherapeutics Settles Class Action Complaint, and SEC Investigation Closed Without Action
7. ACTE Releases Paper Highlighting Policy Trend to Support Recognition of Academic Credit for CTE Classes
8. UKs Institute of Cancer Research and Silicon Graphics Establish Long-Term Alliance to Design and Outfit World-Class Network Biology Lab
9. NexBio Completes Clinical Advisory Board for the Advanced Development of DAS181 (Fludase(R)*), a First-In-Class Medicine for Influenza
10. CellGard ES NU-480 Class II Biological Safety Cabinet Now Available
11. Enerkem Announces World-Class Advanced Energy Research Center in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Post Your Comments:
(Date:12/1/2015)...  Twist Bioscience, a company focused on synthetic DNA, today ... been selected as one of Foreign Policy,s 100 ... blocks of life . Each year, Foreign Policy ... work have changed lives and are shaping the world. ... honor to be recognized among these incredible global leaders," said ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... 2015  The Minnesota High Tech Association (MHTA) has ... Award in the Small and Growing Healthcare award category. ... Minneapolis Convention Center, the Tekne Awards honor ... in developing new technologies that positively impact the lives ... Clostridium difficile infection ( C. diff. ), ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... December 01, 2015 , ... ... (AFM) announces Park NX10 SICM Module, an add-on scanning ion conductance microscopy module ... power of SICM to an AFM. , Park SICM benefits virtually all materials ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... , Dec. 1, 2015  Symic, a clinical-stage ... the extracellular matrix (ECM), today announced that it has ... advance the company,s pipeline, including its lead candidates SB-030 ... and includes the participation by all existing major investors, ... brings the total capital raised by Symic to over ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
(Date:11/17/2015)... 2015 Paris from 17 ... Paris from 17 th until 19 ... innovation leader, has invented the first combined scanner in the ... same scanning surface. Until now two different scanners were required: one ... capture both on the same surface. This innovation is ...
(Date:11/17/2015)... 2015  Vigilant Solutions announces today that Mr. ... Directors. --> --> ... the partnership at TPG Capital, one of the largest ... Billion in revenue.  He founded and led TPG,s Operating ... companies, from 1997 to 2013.  In his first role, ...
(Date:11/16/2015)... 16, 2015  Synaptics Inc. (NASDAQ: SYNA ... today announced expansion of its TDDI product portfolio ... controller and display driver integration (TDDI) solutions designed ... new TDDI products add to the previously-announced ... (WQHD resolution), and TD4322 (FHD resolution) solutions. All ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):