Navigation Links
Analysis of Biofuels Indirect Land Use Effects Finds the Science Lacking: 'Too Diffuse and Subject To Too Many Arbitrary Assumptions To Be Useful for Rule-making.'
Date:8/19/2009

WASHINGTON, Aug.19 /PRNewswire/ -- A scholarly analysis of the keystone of indirect land use study - Searchinger et al. - found the science fell far short of acceptable scientific standards. Professor John Mathews and Dr. Hao Tan, researchers from Macquarie University in Sydney, Australia, undertook an exhaustive analysis of Searchinger et al. which revealed that the framework used was inappropriate in that it started with assumptions as to diversion of grain to ethanol production in the U.S. but then extrapolated these to parts of the world, such as sugarcane growing in Brazil, which are actually (much) more bio-efficient. Mssrs. Mathews and Tan's analysis concluded that Searchinger et al. failed sound scientific standards on many fronts and that government agencies relying on Searchinger et al. findings for evaluating biofuels would be better served by utilizing other controls.

"Indirect land use change effects are too diffuse and subject to too many arbitrary assumptions to be useful for rule-making," stated Professor Mathews. "The use of direct and controllable measures such as building statements of origin or biofuels into the contracts that regulate the sale of such commodities would secure better results."

The issue is where to draw the boundary for life cycle analysis and how to address ILUC effects within the boundary. Non-industry experts are concerned that this is taking regulatory action too far, and the science underpinning such actions, including the ILUC calculations of authors such as Searchinger et al., cannot stand the scientific weight being placed upon them.

The Mathews and Tan analysis states that the real target of the Searchinger et al. paper would appear to be the model of U.S. ethanol production developed by the Argonne National Laboratory in the U.S. Researchers at Argonn
'/>"/>

SOURCE Professor John Mathews and Dr. Hao Tan
Copyright©2009 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology technology :

1. BioNanomatrix Announces Issuance of Key Nanofluidics Patent Enabling Single Molecule Whole Genome Analysis
2. SeqWright Unveils ABI SOLiD(TM) Next Generation Genetic Analysis System
3. Topline Findings from Comparative Analysis of INVEGA(TM) and Quetiapine in Schizophrenia to be Postered at the 20th Annual U.S. Psychiatric and Mental Health Congress
4. Massive reanalysis of genome data solves case of the lethal genes
5. ARRIVE Registry Analysis Demonstrates Continued Safety and Efficacy of TAXUS(R) Stent in Complex Real-World Patients
6. Gene Codes Corporation Announces Version 4.8 of Sequencher Software for DNA Sequence Assembly & Analysis
7. Pharsights Reporting and Analysis Services Business Reaches Quality Assurance Milestone
8. Center for Molecular Medicine Selected to Provide DNA Analysis for Childrens Oncology Group Leukemia Study
9. Credit-card-sized platform for volatile compound analysis CAREER project goal
10. New Glycobiology Analysis Manual 2nd Edition Provides Valuable Resource for Novices and Experts in the Field
11. Pharsights Reporting and Analysis Services Business Unit to Leverage New Validated Data Management System
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:7/10/2014)... the basis of psychiatric disorders has been extremely challenging ... risk but are insufficient to cause disease. Now investigators ... Press journal Cell Stem Cell describe a ... risks interact with other risk factors or environmental exposures ... research pinpoints a genetic variant that may predispose individuals ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... RICHLAND, Wash. The lithium-ion batteries that power our ... run longer on a single charge with the help ... the porous material to replace the graphite traditionally used ... more than 10 times the energy storage capacity of ... lithium-ion battery electrode was published today in Nature ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... shelled out for crude 3-D glasses, polarized glasses, ... These basic devices, used to trick the brain ... be rendered obsolete with the introduction of new ... , TAU doctoral students Yuval Yifat, Michal Eitan, ... based on nanoantennas that could be used for ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... new alliance will see the two universities and NPL ... with business and industry and their complementary academic strengths., ... help to shape the scientific priorities of the UK. ... up to 300 high-calibre PhD students, will provide a ... NPL, the potential of the Laboratory will be grown ...
Breaking Biology Technology:New strategy could uncover genes at the root of psychiatric illnesses 2Silicon sponge improves lithium-ion battery performance 2Silicon sponge improves lithium-ion battery performance 3Projecting a 3-dimensional future 2Projecting a 3-dimensional future 3Universities of Surrey and Strathclyde selected as strategic partners in the future operation of the National Physical Laboratory 2Universities of Surrey and Strathclyde selected as strategic partners in the future operation of the National Physical Laboratory 3
... DRRX ) announced today that James E. ... NewsMakers in the Biotech Industry Investment,Conference to be ... 2007 at 11:30 a.m.,Eastern Time. (Logo: ... the presentation will be available by accessing,DURECT,s homepage ...
... Text provides cardiologists with an overview of cardiovascular genetics ... ... TORONTO, Aug. 29 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ - GeneNews Limited (TSX: GEN),a ... and staging of virtually any disease or medical,condition, today announced ...
... Pharmaceuticals,Inc. (Amex: ANX ) a biopharmaceutical research ... for the treatment,of cancer and infectious diseases, announced ... is scheduled to present at the 2007,Thomas Weisel ... 1:30 p.m. Eastern Daylight Time. The conference takes ...
Cached Biology Technology:GeneNews' Chief Scientist Dr. C.C. Liew co-editor of new genomics reference book 2ADVENTRX Pharmaceuticals to Present at the 2007 Thomas Weisel Partners Healthcare Conference 2
(Date:7/11/2014)... burning in eastern New South Wales, Australia when NASA,s ... 03:35 UTC on July 11 (12:35 p.m. local time/11:35 ... eastern New South Wales (NSW), the Moderate Resolution Imaging ... the region and spotted smoke (light brown) from various ... are outlined in red. , The New South Wales, ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... USC Stem Cell scientists have set a "mouse TRAP" ... described by a recent study published in the ... line uses a technique called TRAP to extract cellular ... , Invented by scientists at the Rockefeller Institute for ... tag to the protein-making machinery, or ribosomes, of the ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... from the Max Planck Institute for Medical Research in ... understanding photosynthesis, the process by which the Earth first ... and which is therefore crucial for all higher forms ... the first direct visualization of a crucial event in ... specific protein complex, photosystem II, splits water into hydrogen ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):A first direct glimpse of photosynthesis in action 2
... of earth scientists report movement of warmed sea water through ... is greater than that off midocean volcanic ridges. The finding ... once considered barren. With about 71 percent of the ... under the sea, its geology, and the life it supports. ...
... German . Scientists at the Max ... have decoded the genome of the Pristionchus pacificus nematode, ... their work, which has been published in the latest ... Professor Ralf J. Sommer,s department in Tbingen have shown ...
... UC Davis researchers have defined a cellular process ... found an important starting point for identifying and ... rheumatoid arthritis, cardiovascular disease and some cancers. ... sPLA2-IIA binds to two integrins labeled alpha-V-beta-3 and ...
Cached Biology News:Ocean floor geysers warm flowing sea water 2Insight into the evolution of parasitism 2Insight into the evolution of parasitism 3UC Davis researchers discover new drug target for inflammatory disease 2
... The GSTTag Monoclonal Antibody is ... high affinity to the 26 kDa ... . This purified antibody is suitable ... GSTTag sequence expressed in E. coli ...
... LNA microarray slides for microRNA expression ... incorporate Exiqons unique Locked Nucleic Acid (LNA) ... mismatch discrimination for short microRNA (miRNA) targets. ... 1 g total RNA (no need for ...
... many modifications to the original formulas in efforts ... play an important role in tissue,culture. A salt ... osmotic balance in the medium and to provide ... is as valuable today as when it was ...
Imject Freund's Complete Adjuvant (FCA)...
Biology Products: