Navigation Links
'Uniquely human' component of language found in gregarious birds

Although linguists have argued that certain patterns of language organization are the exclusive province of humans -- perhaps the only uniquely human component of language -- researchers from the University of Chicago and the University of California San Diego have discovered the same capacity to recognize such patterns and distinguish between them in Sturnus vulgaris, the common European starling.

In the April 27, 2006, issue of Nature, the researchers show that these starlings ?long known as virtuoso songbirds and expert mimics ?can be trained to reliably discriminate between two different patterns of organizing the sounds they use to communicate.

"Our research is a refutation of the canonical position that what makes human language unique is a singular ability to comprehend these kinds of patterns," said Timothy Gentner, assistant professor of psychology at UCSD and lead author of the study. "If birds can learn these patterning rules, then their use does not explain the uniqueness of human language."

The researchers focused on recursion, or center-embedding, a characteristic, found in all human languages. Recursion is one way of creating of new and grammatically correct meanings by inserting words and clauses within sentences -- theoretically, without limit. So, for example, "The bird sang," can become "The bird the cat chased sang."

Following the lead of language theorist Noam Chomsky, linguists have held that this recursive center-embedding is a universal feature of human language and, moreover, that the ability to process it forms a unique computational ability important for human language.

"Linguists have developed a mathematically rigorous set of definitions, a hierarchy of syntactical complexity, that governs the process of how humans create and understand utterances," said Daniel Margoliash, professor of anatomy and organismal biology at the University of Chicago and co-author of the study. "These rules govern how
'"/>

Source:University of Chicago Medical Center


Page: 1 2 3 4 5

Related biology news :

1. Breast Cancer May Be Uniquely Sensitive To Inhibitors Of PI3K Pathway
2. Cancer scientists create human leukemia process to map how disease begins, progresses
3. New evidence of human culture among primates
4. New component of the brakes on nerve regeneration found
5. Gap-climbing fruit flies reveal components of goal-driven behaviors
6. Study uncovers dirty little secret: Soil emissions are much-bigger-than-expected component of air pollution
7. Solexa and collaborating scientists illuminate the small RNA component of the transcriptome
8. Mice lacking key immune component still control chronic viral infections
9. African parasite makes component of fat differently from all other organisms
10. New study reveals components of cocoa may enhance the appearance of the skin
11. Researchers in Montréal and the US create model of key immune-system component

Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/23/2009)... University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) researc...ing medical conditions (co-morbidity) do not expla...mericans compared to Caucasians who also have colo... Cancer , a journal of the American Cancer Societ... co-morbidity are independent predictors of poor s...
(Date:11/23/2009)... existed for 360 million years and survived when t...hreatening to make many of them extinct, according...ogy Today . , The fungus, Batrachochytrium den...waves of amphibian extinctions in Central America ...cts over 350 amphibian species by penetrating thei...
(Date:11/23/2009)...ronmental irritants such as air pollution and ciga...lished today in the American Journal of Respirato... study, from Imperial College London and the Unive... the lungs that can trigger coughing when a person...ey suggest that their findings may ultimately lead...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Racial disparity in colon cancer survival not easily explained, UAB researchers say 2Research reveals exactly how coughing is triggered by environmental irritants 2AEterna Zentaris Receives US 245 5 Million from Institutional Investors 14577 1AEterna Zentaris Receives US 245 5 Million from Institutional Investors 14577 2AEterna Zentaris Receives US 245 5 Million from Institutional Investors 14577 3Gauze based NPWT Capable of Achieving Same Treatment Goals as Foam based NPWT 5665 1Gauze based NPWT Capable of Achieving Same Treatment Goals as Foam based NPWT 5665 2Gauze based NPWT Capable of Achieving Same Treatment Goals as Foam based NPWT 5665 3Gauze based NPWT Capable of Achieving Same Treatment Goals as Foam based NPWT 5665 4Governor Rendell Says Hundreds of Jobs Coming to York County as Medical Device Manufacturer Prepares to Expand 5662 1Governor Rendell Says Hundreds of Jobs Coming to York County as Medical Device Manufacturer Prepares to Expand 5662 2Governor Rendell Says Hundreds of Jobs Coming to York County as Medical Device Manufacturer Prepares to Expand 5662 3
...to resist the effects of cheap and popular antivir...tionary tale about U.S. plans to use the antiviral...ction in humans, scientists say. , Researchers an...nza strains to document where and when the virus d...called adamantanes and how far resistant strains s...
...xposed to low temperatures develop more blood vess...t more quickly, according to a new study from Karo...w to control blood vessel development in humans in...th of fat cells and their metabolism depend on oxy...egulate the amount of body fat in order, for inst...
...more efficient that exploits the inertia of a wind...d speed variation, according to research published...s . , Wind power is being touted as a clean and i...he wind is intermittent and so the power output of...smooth these power fluctuations usually involve th...
Other Biology News:Study: Excessive use of antiviral drugs could aid deadly flu 2Study: Excessive use of antiviral drugs could aid deadly flu 3Study: Excessive use of antiviral drugs could aid deadly flu 4Study: Excessive use of antiviral drugs could aid deadly flu 5Tilting at wind farms 2
(Date:11/24/2009)... Health care employment gre... the only one to show consistent growth during the...spitals remain in trouble, and health systems are ...rsonnel, instead of just administrators. , ...lth care employment continued growing in October d...
(Date:11/24/2009)..., SANMATEO,Calif.,Nov.24/PRNewswire-FirstCall/--...mpanyfocusedondevelopingandcommercializingnovelpai...nno,PresidentandChiefExecutiveOfficer,isscheduledt...rence,tobeheldDecember1-2,2009atTheNewYorkPalaceHo...iglieri,ChiefFinancialOfficer,willbeavailabletores...
(Date:11/24/2009)... The FBI recently approved th...tories participating in or generating DNA records ... Madison, WI USA (PRWEB) -- The FBI rec...ystem for use by laboratories participating in, o...ex System (NDIS). NDIS currently contains more tha...
(Date:11/24/2009)..., DUBLIN,November24/PRNewswire-FirstCall/--Shire...pharmaceuticalcompany,today,announcedthatithassubm...rasealfa,thecompany,senzymereplacementtherapyindev...isthethirdmarketing,applicationforvelaglucerasealf...eUnitedStatesandCanada. , Basedonaglobalsuppl...
Breaking Biology Technology:The MedZilla Report for October 2009 - Health Care Employment Grows Again in October Even As Clinics, Specialty Centers Close 2The MedZilla Report for October 2009 - Health Care Employment Grows Again in October Even As Clinics, Specialty Centers Close 3The MedZilla Report for October 2009 - Health Care Employment Grows Again in October Even As Clinics, Specialty Centers Close 4NeurogesX to Present at Piper Jaffray Health Care Conference 2NeurogesX to Present at Piper Jaffray Health Care Conference 3NDIS Approval of Promega PowerPlex Kit Clears Path for More DNA Profiles to be Added to U.S. Database 2Shire Submits European Marketing Authorization Application (MAA) for velaglucerase alfa for the Treatment of Type 1 Gaucher Disease 2Shire Submits European Marketing Authorization Application (MAA) for velaglucerase alfa for the Treatment of Type 1 Gaucher Disease 3
...., March 31 Watson Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NYSE: ..., announced today that the United States District ...Watson,s generic version of Concerta (methylphenid...ot infringe United States Patent No. 6,919,373 (th.... The opinion, dated March 30, 2009, was issued b...
...ologics announces the filing of two important prov...h 31 Quantum Immunologics, Inc. (QI), a Florida-b... has recently filed two provisional patent applica...py. , , The company,s research is focused on the...cifically, iLRP - immature Laminin Receptor Protei...
...March 31 ArunA Biomedical, Inc., a leader in huma...today that it has been awarded a Department of Def...r utilizing its human stem cell technology. , ,...080819/CLTU003LOGO ) , , The company will furth...lular model for use in a prototype biosensor devel...
Other Biology Technology:Delaware Court Rules That Watson Does Not Infringe Patent Related to Generic Version of Concerta(R) and Declares Patent Invalid 2Immunotherapy-Based Provisional Patents Mark Significant Discovery 2Immunotherapy-Based Provisional Patents Mark Significant Discovery 3ArunA Biomedical Awarded Department of Defense Contract to Further Develop Environmental Biosensor for National Security 2
Vybrant Apoptosis Assay Kit #7 - Hoechst 33342/YO-PRO-1/propidium iodide - 200 assays from Molecular Probes (Invitrogen)
Rat TIMP-1 ELISA Kit from R&D Systems
Human Embryonic Stem Cell Marker Antibody Panel. Contains 25 g each of anti-Alkaline Phosphatase, anti-Nanog, anti-Oct-3/4, anti-SSEA-1, and anti-SSEA-4. from R&D Systems
HSV 1 IgG ELISA Kit from Biomeda Corporation
Biology Products: