Navigation Links
Plutonium or greenhouse gases? Weighing the energy options

Can nuclear energy save us from global warming? Perhaps, but the tradeoffs involved are sobering: thousands of metric tons of nuclear waste generated each year and a greatly increased risk of nuclear weapons proliferation or diversion of nuclear material into terrorists' hands.

So concludes University of Michigan professor Rodney Ewing, who has analyzed just how much nuclear power would need to be produced to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions worldwide, and the implications of the associated increase in nuclear power plants. Ewing will present his findings Oct. 23 as the Michel T. Halbouty Distinguished Lecturer at the annual meeting of the Geological Society of America in Philadelphia.

"Usually when people talk about nuclear power as a solution for global warming, the issues of nuclear waste and weapons proliferation are footnotes in the discussion," said Ewing, who is the Donald R. Peacor Collegiate Professor and Chair in the U-M Department of Geological Sciences and also has faculty appointments in the departments of Nuclear Engineering & Radiological Sciences and Materials Science & Engineering. "I think we have to find a way to consider the complete picture when choosing among energy sources."

In an effort to capture that complete picture, Ewing compared carbon-based fossil fuels with nuclear power, considering not only the technologies involved but also the environmental impacts. Similar comparisons have been made between different energy-producing systems, "but in the case of nuclear power, such an analysis is difficult because there are different types of nuclear reactors and there is not a single nuclear fuel cycle, but rather many variants, with different strategies for reprocessing and disposing of nuclear wastes," Ewing said.

His presentation, which considers various fuel cycles, shows that nuclear power generation would need to increase by a factor of three to ten over current levels to have a signi ficant impact on greenhouse gas emissions. "We currently have 400-plus nuclear reactors operating worldwide, and we would need something like 3,500 nuclear power plants," Ewing said.

Developing the necessary nuclear technologies and building the additional power plants is an enormous undertaking that probably would take longer than the 50 years that experts say we have in which to come up with solutions to global warming, Ewing said.

Even if they could be built and brought online quickly, that many power plants would generate tens of thousands of metric tons of additional nuclear waste annually. "The amount that would be created each year would be equal to the present capacity anticipated at the repository at Yucca Mountain," Ewing said, referring to the proposed disposal site in Nevada that has been under study for more than two decades. Ewing recently co-edited a book, "Uncertainty Underground," that reviews uncertainties in the analysis of the long-term performance of the Yucca Mountain repository.

Plutonium created as a byproduct of nuclear power generation also is a concern because of its potential for use in nuclear weapons.

"Not everyone thinks this way, but I consider the explosion of a nuclear weapon to be a pretty large environmental impact with global implications," Ewing said. "A typical nuclear weapon will kill many, many hundreds of thousands of people, and the global impact would be comparable to something like Chernobyl in the spread of fallout."

So the real question, said Ewing, is: "Plutonium versus carbon---which would you rather have as your problem? I don't have the answer, but the points I'm raising are ones I think people need to be considering."


'"/>

Source:University of Michigan


Related biology news :

1. New research indicates a troubled greenhouse is brewing
2. Asleep in the deep: Model helps assess ocean-injection strategy for combating greenhouse effect
3. Food-crop yields in future greenhouse-gas conditions lower than expected
4. Siberian lakes burp time-bomb greenhouse gas
5. Team Invents Device For Weighing Individual Molecules
6. Growth in biomass could put US on road to energy independence
7. Hydrogen and methane provide raw energy for life at Lost City
8. Study of energy and health in Africa focuses spotlight on charcoal and forest management
9. UCSD study clarifies insulins role in blocking release of energy in patients with type II diabetes
10. Ethanol and biodiesel from crops not worth the energy
11. Free-energy theory borne out in large-scale protein folding
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:2/21/2017)... PORTLAND, Ore. , Feb. 22, 2017 /PRNewswire/ ... of Companies (Avamere Health Services, Infinity Rehab, Signature Hospice, ... study that will apply the power of IBM cognitive ... and health centers. By analyzing data streaming from sensors ... into physical and environmental conditions, and obtain deeper learnings ...
(Date:2/16/2017)... Feb. 16, 2017  Genos, a community for ... it has received Laboratory Accreditation from the College ... presented to laboratories that meet stringent requirements around ... rigorous processes. "Genos is committed to ... practices. We,re honored to be receiving CAP accreditation," ...
(Date:2/13/2017)... SAN FRANCISCO , Feb. 13, 2017 /PRNewswire/ ... a centralized platform that is designed to enhance ... the latest release in the RSA Fraud & ... to enable organizations to leverage additional insights from ... anti-fraud tools to better protect their customers from ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:3/1/2017)... IA (PRWEB) , ... March 01, 2017 , ... ... announce finalization of an agreement that formalizes their clinical research partnership. Effective ... McFarland Clinic. This collaboration brings an increased opportunity for McFarland Clinic patients and ...
(Date:3/1/2017)... March 1, 2017  Elizabeth Young and Joshua ... the George Washington University,s Health Workforce Speaker series. ... Rosenthal will be speaking on March 9, 2017 ... Washington, DC at 12:00pm. ... invites nationally renowned speakers to examine new workforce configurations, ...
(Date:2/28/2017)... ... February 28, 2017 , ... ... Inc. (Newark, DE) have formed a strategic partnership to develop and market ... renewable energy laboratories. These automated testing solutions will save analysis time and ...
(Date:2/28/2017)... and REYKJAVIK, Iceland , Feb. 28, ... group company and the contract genomics organization enabling precision ... Hannes Smarason has been appointed as the company,s chief executive ... and Alex Fowkes have been named chief ... "WuXi NextCODE is executing on its vision to enable anyone ...
Breaking Biology Technology: