Although reducing consumption may have a place as a temporary measure in smoking cessation, this study proves quite clearly that the only safe way out of the risk caused by smoking is to quit, say the authors.
They base their findings on more than 51,000 men and women, all of whom were aged between 20 and 34 at the start of the study.
Participants were initially assessed for cardiovascular risk factors, and then screened again twice at an interval of three to 10 years, adding up to an average monitoring period of over two decades.
Participants were classified as never smokers; ex smokers, quitters (those who gave up between the first and second check); moderate smokers (1 to 14 cigarettes daily); reducers (more than 15 cigarettes a day, cut by more than half at the second check); and heavy smokers (more than 15 cigarettes a day).
Among men, deaths from lung cancer and cancers associated with smoking were not significantly lower in those who had cut back compared with heavy smokers. But this was not true of women who cut back, where the reverse was true.
And men who cut back only had slightly lower death rates from all causes combined than the heavy smokers during the first 15 years. After that, death rates were comparable.
And there were no significant differences in death rates from specific causes, including early death from cardiovascular disease, among women who cut back their daily consumption, compared with those who continued to smoke heavily.
Women who cut back actually had higher death rates from all causes combined than heavy smokers.
The authors conclude that long term monitoring provides no evidence that heavy smokers, who halve their daily cigarette consumption, significantly cut their risk of early death. T
hey add that people may be misled if they are advised that cutting back will help them stave off disease.
Source:BMJ Specialty Journals
Related biology news :
1. Re-analysis of cigarettes confirms tobacco companies increased addictive nicotine 11 percent
2. New cigarette designs dont offer lower predicted cancer risks
3. Chemists create Superbowl molecule; May lead to better health
4. New push for public health, AIDS spending at African Union summit
5. Scientists collaborate to assess health of global environment
6. Highly adaptable genome in gut bacterium key to intestinal health
7. Genetically modified rice in China benefits farmers health, study finds
8. How the environment could be damaging mens reproductive health
9. Mutation in clams protects against paralytic shellfish poisoning but raises human health risk
10. Study of energy and health in Africa focuses spotlight on charcoal and forest management
11. Genome study of beneficial microbe may help boost plant health