Navigation Links
Are journal rankings distorting science?

This week’s BMJ raises concerns over whether journal rankings (known as impact factors) are distorting publishing and science.

The impact factor is a measure of the citations to papers in scientific journals. It was developed as a simple measure of quality and has become a proxy for the importance of a journal to its field.

But a report by the BMJ this week warns that the popularity of this ranking is distorting the fundamental character of journals, forcing them to focus more and more on citations and less on readers.

Concerns include the fact that a bad paper may be cited because of its infamous errors and that a journal’s rank has no bearing on the quality of individual papers it publishes. But more worrying is the trend towards using impact factors to guide decisions on research funding. This has been particularly noticeable in the UK, where universities now prioritise scientific fields that produce research published in the highest impact factor journals, causing substantial damage to the clinical research base.

In an accompanying article, two researchers discuss whether impact factors should be ditched.

Gareth Williams of Bristol University believes that the academic community should consign the impact factor to the dustbin. He sees the measure as fatally flawed and highly damaging to the academic community.

"The impact factor is a pointless waste of time, energy, and money, and a powerful driver of perverse behaviours in people who should know better," he writes. "It should be killed off, and the sooner the better."

But Richard Hobbs of Birmingham University thinks that rather than just discarding impact factors we should consider solutions to the problems. For example, extending the citation surveillance period, applying weightings to adjust for the average number of references across journals, or scoring journals on only their most important papers.

It’s easy to criticise bibliome trics, but we should attempt to refine them and debate in parallel how we can track academic careers and encourage fewer, but better studies that affect the wider community, he concludes.

Source:BMJ-British Medical Journal

Related biology news :

1. Open Access journals get impressive impact factors
2. New journal article urges use of animal serum-free media for growing live cells
3. Impressive new Impact Factors for BioMed Centrals open-access journals
4. Funding and bureaucracy, not access to journals, are chief obstacles to scientific productivity
5. Public Library of Science to launch new, open access journal on neglected tropical diseases

Post Your Comments:

(Date:11/11/2015)... MedNet Solutions , an innovative SaaS-based eClinical technology company that ... announce that it will be a Sponsor of the ... held November 17-19 in Hamburg , Germany.  ... iMedNet , MedNet,s easy-to-use, proven and affordable eClinical ... able to deliver time and cost savings of up to ...
(Date:11/9/2015)... JOSE, Calif. , Nov. 9, 2015  Synaptics ... human interface solutions, today announced broader entry into the ... vehicle-specific solutions that match the pace of consumer electronics ... and biometric sensors are ideal for the automotive industry ... vehicle. Europe , ...
(Date:10/29/2015)... Calif. , Oct. 29, 2015  The J. ... new report titled, "DNA Synthesis and Biosecurity: Lessons Learned ... the Department of Health and Human Services guidance for ... in 2010. --> ... it also has the potential to pose unique biosecurity ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... Zenith Epigenetics Corp. ("Zenith" or the "Company") today announced that ... its Board of Directors to replace Dr. Peter Johann ... experience as co-founder of Resverlogix, with expertise in the fields ... --> Dr. Wong remarked, "I am very excited ... standing expertise in epigenetics and the advanced stage of the ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... , Nov. 30, 2015  Champions Oncology, Inc. (CSBR), ... services to personalize the development and use of oncology ... Executive Officer, will be presenting at the LD MICRO ... Pacific Standard Time (PST).  The conference, held at the ... Angeles, CA , will feature 200 small/micro-cap companies ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... 2015  HUYA Bioscience International, the leader in accelerating ... innovations, today announced it has signed a Memorandum of ... foster collaboration between KDDF and HUYA with the ultimate ... products for the global market. ... new innovative preclinical and clinical stage compounds. The company ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... Germany , November 30, 2015 ... Vienna, Austria to be held December ... (ECNR) in Vienna, Austria to ... wholly owned subsidiary of Vycor Medical, Inc. ("Vycor") (OTCQB: VYCO), ... NovaVision Therapy Suite at the 3rd European Congress of ...
Breaking Biology Technology: