Navigation Links
You say offset, I say tax? Study suggests labels and political affiliation may affect preferences
Date:1/12/2010

Would you pay more for certain products to save the planet? That's the question behind the burgeoning carbon-offset industry proponents pay more money for carbon-producing activities (such as flying), with the idea that the carbon emissions will be balanced out by funding for alternative energy sources. At the same time, economists and climate scientists agree that a carbon tax would be the most effective means through which the U.S. could lower carbon emissions and pay for alternative energy production. However, politicians are reluctant to propose a carbon tax because taxes tend to be unpopular with constituents, especially with Republican voters. But does word choice, such as offset versus tax, really make a difference? And in addition, does our political affiliation influence how we respond to certain labels?

Columbia University psychological scientists David J. Hardisty, Eric J. Johnson, and Elke U. Weber wanted to see how the way in which a concept is framed (that is, how it is labeled) affects our attitude towards it. In this experiment, volunteers (who self-identified as Democrats, Republicans, or Independents) read about a program that would increase the cost of certain carbon-producing activities but would use the proceeds to fund alternative energies or carbon capture and sequestration. For half the volunteers this surcharge was labeled as a "carbon offset," while for the other half it was labeled as a "carbon tax," yet the details of the program were the same in each case. Participants then had to choose between two identical items (e.g., airline tickets), where one cost more, because it included the surcharge. Volunteers were asked to write down their thoughts about the decision, make a choice, and also indicate whether they would support legislation making the surcharge mandatory for all products of that type.

The results, reported in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, suggest a strong link between our political affiliation and how we react to certain frames. In the "offset" condition, Democratic, Republican, and Independent volunteers tended to select the more expensive, albeit environmentally-friendly, product. They were also equally likely (across party) to support making the cost increase mandatory. However, in the "tax" condition, while Democratic volunteers still opted for the costlier item, Republican and Independent participants were more likely to choose the cheaper item, and did not support legislation.

In addition, analysis of the volunteers' thought processes indicates that labels may have resulted in differences in the order in which they thought about the options, in turn affecting their choices. For example, Republicans volunteers had an immediate, negative reaction to the "tax" option, which made them think about advantages of the cheaper item, which they ultimately chose. However, in the "offset" condition, Republicans listed supportive thoughts towards the surcharge, increasing the likelihood of the more expensive item being selected.

The authors suggest that "policymakers (and those who advise them) would be wise to note the differential impact that policy labels may have on different groups." They conclude, "What might seem like a trivial semantic difference to one person can have a large impact on someone else."


'/>"/>

Contact: Barbara Isanski
bisanski@psychologicalscience.org
Association for Psychological Science
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Study shows pine bark naturally relieves symptoms of acute hemorrhoids
2. Study shows that delivering stem cells improves repair of major bone injuries in rats
3. Study reveals how one form of natural vitamin E protects brain after stroke
4. What came first in the origin of life? A study contradicts the metabolism first hypothesis
5. Study examines calorie information from restaurants, packaged foods
6. Study provides insight into pathway linked to obesity
7. Sweet corn study provides large-scale picture of better fields
8. A global breakthrough in the study of a protein linked to the spread of viruses
9. Using modern sequencing techniques to study ancient modern humans
10. Short-term school closures may worsen flu pandemics, Pitt study finds
11. Researchers use new acoustic tools to study marine mammals and fish
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:4/3/2017)...  Data captured by IsoCode, IsoPlexis Corporation,s ... statistically significant association between the potency of ... objective response of cancer patients post-treatment. The ... cancer patients will respond to CAR-T cell ... to improve both pre-infusion potency testing and cell ...
(Date:3/30/2017)... -- Trends, opportunities and forecast in this market to ... AFIS, iris recognition, facial recognition, hand geometry, vein recognition, ... industry (government and law enforcement, commercial and retail, health ... and by region ( North America , ... , and the Rest of the World) ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... 27, 2017  Catholic Health Services (CHS) has ... Society (HIMSS) Analytics for achieving Stage 6 on ... . In addition, CHS previously earned a place ... an electronic medical record (EMR). "HIMSS ... of EMR usage in an outpatient setting.  This ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:9/19/2017)... ... September 19, 2017 , ... ... of Financial Services (NYS DFS) cybersecurity regulations have transitioned into full ... insurance organizations operating in the state (“Covered Entities”) to conduct an annual, ...
(Date:9/18/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... September 18, 2017 , ... ... has announced the move of the SPIE Digital Library ( http://www.spiedigitallibrary.org ) on ... SPIE to create an improved user experience and incorporate a number of enhancements ...
(Date:9/17/2017)... ... September 17, 2017 , ... ... South Korean Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (KMFDS) for an Investigational New ... the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV). The study in Korea represents the ...
(Date:9/14/2017)... ... September 14, 2017 , ... ... and biotech at the third annual DrugDev Summit, November 7-8, 2017 in Philadelphia, ... world’s most progressive clinical research leaders for best practice case studies, keynote presentations, ...
Breaking Biology Technology: