Navigation Links
Which came first, the moth or the cactus?

HOUSTON, Aug. 13, 2007 It's not a good idea to put all your eggs in one basket unless you're a senita moth.

Found in the parched Sonoran desert of southern Arizona and northern Mexico, the senita moth depends on a single plant species -- the senita cactus -- both for its food and for a place to lay eggs. The senita cactus is equally dependent upon the moth, the only species that pollinates its flowers. Senita cacti and senita moths have a rare, mutually dependent relationship, one of only three known dependencies in which an insect actively pollinates flowers for the purpose of assuring a food resource for its offspring.

"Mutualistic relationships like this present a problem for ecological theory," said Rice University ecologist Nat Holland, who co-discovered the senita moth-senita cactus mutualism in 1995 and has studied it ever since.

The problem is that the moths lay their eggs inside the cacti's flowers immediately after pollination, and when the eggs hatch the moth larvae eat the fruit, destroying the flowers' chances to produce seeds. Historic theory predicts extreme ecological instability for this relationship; as moth populations increase, more flowers are destroyed, fewer new cacti appear, and the spiral continues until both species disappear.

Yet that hasn't happened, and Holland, assistant professor of ecology and evolutionary biology, spends several months each year observing moths and cacti in the Mexican desert to document why.

Holland, whose lab is just a few steps down the hall from his Houston office, jokes that his "real" lab is 1,500 miles away. He's studied senita at several locations in the Sonoran Desert, including the Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument in southern Arizona. But his primary site for more than a decade is a desolate, 30-acre patch of desert straddling three ranches near Bahia de Kino on the Gulf of California. Holland said he and his students sometimes go weeks without seeing other people at the sites, with the exception of a cowboy on horseback here and there.

There isn't much to see on the long drives to and from Houston either, but Holland said hours of solitude provide a valuable time for thinking and synthesizing what he's learned in the desert. That's important because his ultimate goal reaches far beyond the Sonoran Desert to a fundamental rethinking of ecological theory for such mutualistic interactions.

"I develop theoretical models, equations that attempt to explain mutualistic relationships like the one between the moth and the cactus, and I take those models into the field and examine them empirically to find out how well they predict what really happens," Holland said.

Traditional theory of such mutualistic interactions leads to predictions of unbounded population growth or instability and eventual doom due to one species overexploiting another. These predictions clearly don't square with what Holland and his students see happening in the Sonoran Desert, where both species thrive. Holland's models differ from traditional theory, suggesting that one mutualist may exert some control over the other's population increases, such that neither unbounded growth nor overexploitation ensue.

"I have always been interested in the community ecology of mutualism -- the larger puzzle -- and this moth-cactus relationship is just one piece of that," Holland said. "When we discovered the relationship in 1995, I immediately thought of using it to look at the bigger picture. But in aiming to do that, I wound up spending a decade working on the population ecology of mutualisms, a prerequisite for then understanding this larger puzzle."

Having made some progress on the population ecology of mutualism, some of Holland's current work, which is slated for publication later this year, returns to his earlier interests in community ecology. "We want to understand how the structure of mutualistic communities influences their stability and dynamics, both of individual species and of whole networks of species." The results suggest that the structures of mutualistic communities compliment those of predator-prey food webs, a finding that presents the tantalizing possibility of developing an overarching scheme that incorporates elements of both.

Contact: Jade Boyd
Rice University

Related biology news :

1. Identification of specific genes predicts which patients will respond to Hepatitis C treatment
2. Overbearing colored light may reveal a second mechanism by which birds interpret magnetic signals
3. Bacteria which sense the Earths magnetic field
4. Researchers discover which organs in Antarctic fish produce antifreeze
5. First-ever genomic test predicts which lung cancer patients need chemotherapy to live
6. Researchers discover key mechanism by which lethal viruses Ebola and Marburg cause disease
7. Newts which regrow their hearts
8. Reminding doctors which antibiotics to prescribe cuts C. difficile infection rates
9. Killing the messenger RNA -- But which one?
10. Scientists discover stage at which an embryonic cell is fated to become a stem cell
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/29/2015)...   MedNet Solutions , an innovative SaaS-based eClinical ... research, is pleased to announce that it has been ... one of only three finalists for a 2015 ... Growing" category. The Tekne Awards honor Minnesota ... innovation and leadership. iMedNet™ eClinical ...
(Date:10/29/2015)... , Oct. 29, 2015  Rubicon Genomics, Inc., ... U.S. distribution of its DNA library preparation products, ... Rubicon,s new ThruPLEX Plasma-seq kit. ThruPLEX Plasma-seq has ... preparation of NGS libraries for liquid biopsies--the analysis ... and prognostic applications in cancer and other conditions. ...
(Date:10/29/2015)... Today, LifeBEAM , a leader ... a global leader in technical performance sports clothing ... advanced bio-sensing technology. The hat will allow fitness ... biometrics to improve overall training performance. As a ... bring together the most advanced technology, extensive understanding ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... -- Human Longevity, Inc. (HLI), the genomics-based, technology-driven company, ... Inc., a leading genome informatics company offering highly accurate, ... San Diego -based company has 14 ... Ashley Van Zeeland , Ph.D., who is now ... the deal were not disclosed. Van ...
(Date:11/30/2015)...  Aytu BioScience, Inc. (OTCQB: AYTU), a commercial-stage specialty ... present at two upcoming investor conferences. Aytu is scheduled ... conference, to be held December 3, 2015, and at ... December 2 nd & 3 rd , 2015 ... live via webcast. Josh Disbrow , Chief ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... Md. , Nov. 30, 2015  Northwest Biotherapeutics ... company developing DCVax® personalized immune therapies for solid tumor ... adding an additional independent director, and the Company welcomes ... of allegations in a recent anonymous internet report on ... both initiatives. Linda Powers stated, "We ...
(Date:11/28/2015)... ... November 28, 2015 , ... • Jeon Jin Bio ... porcine and rodent control solutions , Bird ... oil, works across all sensory modalities including visual, smell, taste and touch, enabling safe, ...
Breaking Biology Technology: