Navigation Links
What's in a name? Broadening the biological lexicon to bolster translational research

So-called model organisms have long been at the core of biomedical research, allowing scientists to study the ins and outs of human disorders in non-human subjects.

In the ideal, such models accurately recapitulate a human disorder so that, for example, the Parkinson's disease observed in a rat model would be virtually indistinguishable from that in a human patient. The reality, of course, is that rats aren't human, and few models actually faithfully reflect the phenotype of the disease in question. Thus, in the strictest sense of the word, many "models" aren't truly models at all. To developmental biologist and Whitehead Institute Member Hazel Sive, this is no small matter.

"The term model is used very loosely," says Sive. "That was a problem to me: Everything's a model!"

Sive sees the need to adopt a new term to expand the language of biological research to encompass systems that, although not technically models, can still offer tremendous utility in studying the etiology of human disorders. In this setting, she proposes the use of the word "tool."

Sive formally states her case in the March issue of Disease Models & Mechanisms. In an editorial entitled "'Model' or 'Tool'? New definitions for translational research," Sive calls for using 'tool' as a way to define a biological system that, though failing to recapitulate a phenotype, can, by virtue of its molecular makeup, provide important insights into a human disorder.

"This is not semanticthere really is a difference," says Sive. "Mice have a cachet and are thought of as similar to humans, but obviously they're really quite different from humans. Frogs, flies, fish, and yeast, are serious systems for understanding fundamental biological questions, but they're seen as less valuable when it comes to studying human disease.

Although the publicity around Sive's proposal is new, she conceived of this construct nearly eight years ago for her own research with zebrafish. She uses zebrafish as a something of a test tube in which to study human mental health disorders, including schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and autism. Knowing full well that zebrafish don't get autism, Sive nonetheless has employed the fish successfully as tools because she also knows that mental health risk genes in humans have homologs in zebrafish and that these genes are active during brain development. Because of this, Sive and her lab are able to conduct loss-of-function studies on these genes, examine what happens to the developing brain, and screen for chemicals that can alter the genes' activity. Such work could help identify potential therapeutic targets.

Having heard Sive discuss this 'tool-model' construct several years ago, Vivian Siegel, editor of Disease Models & Mechanisms, encouraged Sive to share it with the scientific community at large.

"She did exactly what I was hoping she would do." Siegel says of Sive's editorial. "We wanted to emphasize that you can find utility without the disease being recapitulated, as long as you know the limitations of the system."

Both Sive and Siegel, whose journal focuses on publishing basic research with translational impact, believe increased but judicious adoption of the term 'tool' should encourage researchers to consider new uses for their systems of choice, help educate grant reviewers evaluating related applications, and ultimately lead to greater understanding of human disorders.

"If you adhere strictly to the term 'model', you can be misled by your own system," says Siegel. "This approach has a lot of benefits. My hope is that by publishing this in Disease Models & Mechanisms, it reaches out to people interested in translational research, and lets others know that they needn't be so dismissive of certain aspects of looking at organisms. This offers a new way to help recognize the potential contributions of organisms that aren't necessarily traditional 'models'."


Contact: Nicole Giese
Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research

Related biology news :

1. Symposium to explore broadening partnerships to spur medical advances for war injuries
2. Biological sand filters, a practical approach to combat poverty and inequality
3. Argonne scientists peer into heart of compound that may detect chemical, biological weapons
4. GEN reports on novel tools for deciphering biological networks
5. Animal and biological science highlights: San Antonio Fluid Dynamics Conference, Nov. 23-25
6. Argonne scientists discover possible mechanism for creating handedness in biological molecules
7. Study finds most wars occur in Earths richest biological regions
8. Biological control of tropical weeds using arthropods
9. Musicians have biological advantage in identifying emotion in sound
10. Unclear regulations obstacle to biological diversity
11. New explanation for a puzzling biological divide along the Malay Peninsula
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/18/2015)... ALBANY, New York , November 18, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... Transparency Market Research has published a new market report ... Share, Growth, Trends, and Forecast, 2015 - 2021. According to ... bn in 2014 and is anticipated to reach US$29.1 ... 2015 to 2021. North America ...
(Date:11/17/2015)... LIVERMORE, Calif. , Nov. 17, 2015  Vigilant ... has joined its Board of Directors. ... Vigilant,s Board after recently retiring from the partnership at ... owning 107 companies with over $140 Billion in revenue.  ... performance improvement across all the TPG companies, from 1997 ...
(Date:11/12/2015)... 2015  A golden retriever that stayed healthy despite ... has provided a new lead for treating this muscle-wasting ... Institute of MIT and Harvard and the University of ... Cell, pinpoints a protective gene that ... effects. The Boston Children,s lab of Lou Kunkel ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:12/1/2015)... 1, 2015 Frost & Sullivan is ... program addresses ways companies can innovate and transform ... --> ... --> ... well as the disrupting factors altering the industry, ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... DUBLIN , Dec. 01, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... announced the addition of the "2016 ... Sales Forecasts, Innovative Technologies, Competitive Strategies, Opportunities ... report to their offering. --> ... the "2016 Europe Cell Surface Markers: ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... , ... December 01, 2015 , ... ... announces that its best selling system laboratory animal colony management software solution, ezColony®, ... without investing in on-site IT resources., , Many organizations ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... SUNNYVALE, Calif. , Dec. 1, 2015 ... part of its participation at the Piper Jaffray Healthcare ... later this morning, the Company is reaffirming its outlook ... guidance for 2016, in addition to discussing longer term ... Chairman and Chief Executive Officer.  "We continue to be ...
Breaking Biology Technology: