Navigation Links
The importance of (experimental) design
Date:2/25/2014

evolution? tienne Danchin of the University of Toulouse and Richard Wagner of the Vetmeduni's Konrad Lorenz Institute of Ethology wondered whether the results might not be influenced too much by the experimental design. Together with ric Wajnberg, a modelling specialist at the INRA in Sophia Antipolis, they simulated the data in the original paper and found that the results could be generated by chance.

The problem stems largely from the fallacy known as "regression to the mean" (RTM), which was first identified by Sir Francis Galton, a cousin of Charles Darwin, in the 19th century. It results from the fact that uncommonly large or small measurements are generally followed by more normal measurements simply because normal values are by definition far more common than extreme ones. In the Browns' experiment, when individuals are fostered from small to large colonies they will on average recruit to colonies that are statistically smaller than their foster colony because these are closer to the mean colony size and vice versa.

Danchin and Wagner actually found a second problem with the original data analysis. The so-called "spatial fallacy" was discovered by Arie van Noorwijk in 1984 and occurs when the set of potential dispersal sites differs among individuals according to where they were born. Together the two fallacies can account for the experiment's results, even in the absence of an inherited component of the selection of colony size.

A question of design

The latest calculations are important for two reasons. First, they call the original conclusions into question and should thus encourage researchers to reconsider the role of genetic factors in certain behavioural decisions. Secondly, they sound a clear warning to all those working in behavioural science. As Wagner says, "The biggest shock is that the very experimental design that is widely used to control for all extraneous effects actually creates the RTM f
'/>"/>

Contact: Richard Wagner
richard.wagner@vetmeduni.ac.at
43-148-909-15831
University of Veterinary Medicine -- Vienna
Source:Eurekalert  

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. EU-funded study underlines importance of Congo Basin for global climate and biodiversity
2. Study sheds new light on importance of human breast milk ingredient
3. Differences between human twins at birth highlight importance of intrauterine environment
4. Programming cells: The importance of the envelope
5. Video study shows which fish clean up coral reefs, showing importance of biodiversity
6. Gene discovery reveals importance of eating your greens
7. National survey highlights perceived importance of dietary protein to prevent weight gain
8. Emerging importance of computerized cognitive testing -- new therapies for dementia
9. Researchers have identified a novel immunological mechanism of great importance for vaccine developm
10. Keck award enables Carnegie Mellon and Stanford to dramatically expand crowdsourced RNA design
11. Report presents designs for study of cancer risks near US nuclear facilities
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
The importance of (experimental) design
(Date:7/24/2014)... Bhavani Iyer, O.D., a low vision specialist at The ... Medical School, has been awarded a grant to help ... with eyeglasses, medication or surgery. , Even with corrective ... at best. However, there are a variety of low ... to help offset their vision loss. , Iyer is ...
(Date:7/24/2014)... experts gathered at NJIT this week for an all-day ... U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to dredge toxic sediment ... , The EPA has called the plan, which proposes ... capping sections of the riverbed, one of the largest ... be dredged and disposed off-site. , "We need to ...
(Date:7/24/2014)... To reduce fire hazard in the United States, wildland ... woody shrubs and suppressed trees (ladder fuels). These ... periods of low fire danger in order to dispose ... hazardous air pollutants, managers often cover all or part ... referred to as agricultural plastic, in order to keep ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):UTHealth Dr. Bhavani Iyer awarded low vision grant 2Experts Weigh the Pros and Cons of a $1.7 Billion EPA Cleanup Plan for the Passaic River at an NJIT 2Study gives new perspective on agricultural plastic, debris burning, and air quality 2
... to the growing list of genetic variants that determine ... by Cell Press on December 30 in the ... previously unknown variants associated with height and might provide ... Although environmental variables can impact attained adult height, ...
... large quantities of nitrate-rich fertilizer to realize optimal ... to balance the amount of nitrogen needed for ... leach into ground and surface waters. Increased interest ... to identify genotypes that have a characteristic called ...
... producers have traditionally relied heavily on hand thinning, a ... increasing labor costs and a limited workforce, peach and ... such as string thinners to minimize the need for ... promising results when it was evaluated in four U.S. ...
Cached Biology News:Large-scale analysis identifies new genetic alterations associated with height 2Improving nitrogen use efficiency lessens environmental impact 2Hybrid string blossom thinner tested in peach orchards 2
(Date:7/25/2014)... July 25, 2014 According to a ... Drugs Market - Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, ... drugs market is estimated at USD 161,056.5 million in ... of 10.1% from 2014 to 2020, to reach an ... The biological drugs market is witnessing a significant growth ...
(Date:7/25/2014)... Lawrence Livermore scientists Charles Westbrook and William Pitz ... The World's Most Influential Scientific Minds ." , Westbrook ... were identified by analyzing citation data over the last ... work (2002-2012 and 2012-2013). The two were selected from ... , "This recognition is a great honor for Charlie ...
(Date:7/25/2014)... At the request of the AMA, the ... for the public comment period (Docket No. FAA-2014-0396) for ... established by Congress as part of the FAA Modernization ... the new deadline for comments as September 23, 2014. ... published in the Federal Register on July 25, 2014, ...
(Date:7/24/2014)... RIDGE, Tenn., July 24, 2014 -- A novel combination ... the Department of Energy,s Oak Ridge National Laboratory an ... for its unusual physical and electrochemical properties. , ... how oxygen affects the surface of a perovskite manganite, ... behavior. The new avenue to understand surface behavior could ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Biological Drugs Market: Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, Trends and Forecast 2014 - 2020 2Biological Drugs Market: Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, Trends and Forecast 2014 - 2020 3Scientists Burst onto Influential List for Combustion Research 2Scientists Burst onto Influential List for Combustion Research 3Scientists Burst onto Influential List for Combustion Research 4FAA Grants Comment Extension at the Request of AMA 2ORNL study reveals new characteristics of complex oxide surfaces 2
... 2011 Operational and Financial Results ... ... --> ... var first_result; // Results are keyed by longUrl, so we need to grab the first one. for (var r ...
... Nov. 11, 2010 StemCyte, Inc., one of the ... companies, is proud to announce that the Company has ... U.S. Internal Revenue Service,s Qualifying Therapeutic Discovery Project (QTDP) ... fewer than 250 employees. The Patient Protection ...
... (Nasdaq: ARAY ), a global leader in the ... to present at the Lazard Capital Markets, Healthcare Conference in ... a.m. ET/7:30 a.m. PT. A live webcast of ... page of the Company,s Web site at http://www.accuray.com . ...
Cached Biology Technology:YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 2YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 3YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 4YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 5YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 6YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 7YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 8YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 9YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 10YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 11YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 12YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 13YM BioSciences Reports Fiscal First Quarter 2011 Operational and Financial Results 14StemCyte Awarded $488,950 for Advanced Therapeutic Applications of Umbilical Cord Blood Stem Cells from the Qualifying Therapeutic Discovery Project (QTDP) 2Accuray Incorporated to Speak at Seventh Annual Lazard Capital Markets' Healthcare Conference 2
Preparation Note: Prepared by method of Wimmer, E., et al., Biochemistry, 7, 2623 (1968). Quality Clarifier: Acceptor Activity: approx. 1000 picomoles phenylalanine per A 260 unit (not determined b...
... which is based on a new flow-through technology, ... in situ hybridization of tissues on microscope slide ... study of gene expression, in situ hybridization (ISH) ... can be used to validate and confirm results ...
... Array Analyst Software has been optimized for ... algorithms allow the software to quickly and ... each well of an ELISA plate or ... Analyst Software has been customized to incorporate ...
... products feature a dual strength adhesive system which ... use. The adhesives on either side of the ... adheres to the glass has an easy release ... coverslip, forms a stronger bond. This means that ...
Biology Products: