Navigation Links
The importance of (experimental) design
Date:2/25/2014

evolution? tienne Danchin of the University of Toulouse and Richard Wagner of the Vetmeduni's Konrad Lorenz Institute of Ethology wondered whether the results might not be influenced too much by the experimental design. Together with ric Wajnberg, a modelling specialist at the INRA in Sophia Antipolis, they simulated the data in the original paper and found that the results could be generated by chance.

The problem stems largely from the fallacy known as "regression to the mean" (RTM), which was first identified by Sir Francis Galton, a cousin of Charles Darwin, in the 19th century. It results from the fact that uncommonly large or small measurements are generally followed by more normal measurements simply because normal values are by definition far more common than extreme ones. In the Browns' experiment, when individuals are fostered from small to large colonies they will on average recruit to colonies that are statistically smaller than their foster colony because these are closer to the mean colony size and vice versa.

Danchin and Wagner actually found a second problem with the original data analysis. The so-called "spatial fallacy" was discovered by Arie van Noorwijk in 1984 and occurs when the set of potential dispersal sites differs among individuals according to where they were born. Together the two fallacies can account for the experiment's results, even in the absence of an inherited component of the selection of colony size.

A question of design

The latest calculations are important for two reasons. First, they call the original conclusions into question and should thus encourage researchers to reconsider the role of genetic factors in certain behavioural decisions. Secondly, they sound a clear warning to all those working in behavioural science. As Wagner says, "The biggest shock is that the very experimental design that is widely used to control for all extraneous effects actually creates the RTM f
'/>"/>

Contact: Richard Wagner
richard.wagner@vetmeduni.ac.at
43-148-909-15831
University of Veterinary Medicine -- Vienna
Source:Eurekalert  

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. EU-funded study underlines importance of Congo Basin for global climate and biodiversity
2. Study sheds new light on importance of human breast milk ingredient
3. Differences between human twins at birth highlight importance of intrauterine environment
4. Programming cells: The importance of the envelope
5. Video study shows which fish clean up coral reefs, showing importance of biodiversity
6. Gene discovery reveals importance of eating your greens
7. National survey highlights perceived importance of dietary protein to prevent weight gain
8. Emerging importance of computerized cognitive testing -- new therapies for dementia
9. Researchers have identified a novel immunological mechanism of great importance for vaccine developm
10. Keck award enables Carnegie Mellon and Stanford to dramatically expand crowdsourced RNA design
11. Report presents designs for study of cancer risks near US nuclear facilities
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
The importance of (experimental) design
(Date:9/17/2014)... R.I. [Brown University] After decades of decline, grasses ... saltmarshes. To the eye, the marsh in those places ... that a key service of the marsh coastal ... back but the ecosystem function hasn,t come back," said ... senior author of the study in the journal ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... been growing significantly faster since the 1960s. The typical ... but they have accelerated -- by as much as ... carried out by scientists from Technische Universitt Mnchen based ... been continuously observed since 1870. Their findings were published ... ago, "forest dieback" was a hot topic, with the ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... United Kingdom forms a new crime unit designed to ... last year over horse meat being passed off as ... for detecting meat adulteration. They describe their approach, which ... Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry . , ... a major global economic problem. But they also say ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Cape Cod saltmarsh recovery looks good, falls short 2Cape Cod saltmarsh recovery looks good, falls short 3Global change: Trees continue to grow at a faster rate 2Global change: Trees continue to grow at a faster rate 3
... University of Delaware have developed a "smart" hydrogel that can ... Over the past few decades, smart hydrogels have been created ... "The idea of a smart hydrogel that can release ... professor of materials science and engineering and biomedical engineering. "What,s ...
... Living organisms have adapted to the day-night cycle and, in ... are not completely known yet but its functioning has been ... of normal circadian rhythms can have deleterious effects on health; ... the time of feeding was shown to affect the ability ...
... of the white-throated sparrow has identified a biological pathway connecting ... wild to variation in their genome. The Proceedings ... is publishing the results of the experiments, conducted by the ... Psychology. The research, which comprised behavioral observations ...
Cached Biology News:UD-developed smart gels deliver medicine on demand 2The internal clock and feeding rhythm set the pace of the liver 2Wild sparrow study traces social behaviors in the field to specific gene 2Wild sparrow study traces social behaviors in the field to specific gene 3Wild sparrow study traces social behaviors in the field to specific gene 4
(Date:9/17/2014)... BioClinica®, Inc., a leading provider of outsourced ... of its experts are speaking at the 20th ... be held September 28 to October 1 in ... announced the innovative Compass technology, a risk-based ... acquired earlier this year, is up for the ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... 17, 2014 Immunomic Therapeutics, Inc. announced ... (SBIR) grant to support the continued preclinical development of ... with approximately $255,000 over one year to conduct vaccine ... food allergy, affect over one million Americans and are ... Tree nut exposure is also a risk for peanut ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... 2014 Terracon Corporation has announced the ... tank . This addition to the company’s industry-leading ... linear polyethylene and available in 125 or 250 gallon ... in two weeks or less. , The new pre-engineered ... in Terracon’s existing TerraPure tank line – plus quick ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... Intarcia Therapeutics, Inc. today announced ... of the cost and predictability of non-adherence in type ... Meeting of the European Association for the Study of ... Frois , Ph.D., of Analysis Group, Inc. presented data ... retrospective studies to characterize the prevalence of non-adherence and ...
Breaking Biology Technology:BioClinica to Present at 20th Annual SCDM Conference 2BioClinica to Present at 20th Annual SCDM Conference 3Immunomic Therapeutics Awarded SBIR Grant to Develop Multi-Nut Allergy Immunotherapy 2Immunomic Therapeutics Awarded SBIR Grant to Develop Multi-Nut Allergy Immunotherapy 3Terracon Introduces Pre-Engineered TerraPure® Tank for Ultrapure Water Applications 2Intarcia Reveals New Insights At EASD Meeting Characterizing The Burden Of Poor Control And Non-Adherence To Anti-Diabetic Therapies 2Intarcia Reveals New Insights At EASD Meeting Characterizing The Burden Of Poor Control And Non-Adherence To Anti-Diabetic Therapies 3Intarcia Reveals New Insights At EASD Meeting Characterizing The Burden Of Poor Control And Non-Adherence To Anti-Diabetic Therapies 4Intarcia Reveals New Insights At EASD Meeting Characterizing The Burden Of Poor Control And Non-Adherence To Anti-Diabetic Therapies 5
... Global Products, BASINGSTOKE, England, October 8 ... global specialty biopharmaceutical,company, announces that it has agreed ... Almirall for a cash consideration of $213m. The ... sodium),and VANIQA(R) (eflornithine hydrochloride), and six other non-promoted,products1 ...
... about the origins of quantum dot blinking, researchers ... Laboratory, the University of Chicago and the California ... characterize it on faster time scales than have ... also known as quantum dots, are being intensively ...
... to Vice President, Research Operations ... Non-Profit Foundation, CARLSBAD, Calif., Oct. 5 ... focused on the discovery and,development of small-molecule therapeutics ... diseases, today announced changes to its,research management. Dr. ...
Cached Biology Technology:Shire Divests Non-Core Product Portfolio to Almirall 2Shire Divests Non-Core Product Portfolio to Almirall 3Argonne researcher studies what makes quantum dots blink 2Ardea Biosciences Announces Changes to Research Management 2Ardea Biosciences Announces Changes to Research Management 3
... Anti-Natural Killer Cell Receptor-P1, ... Immunogen: Hybridoma produced ... from BALB/c mice immunized (BALB/c ... (LAK) cells and mouse myeloma ...
... Yersinia pestis This antibody is ... Immunogen: Purified F1 ... vaccine strain EV76. Specificity: ... capsular antigen. There is no cross-reactivity ...
Rabbit polyclonal to ZFP200 ( Abpromise for all tested applications). Antigen: Synthetic peptide: CGKSFNHKTNLNKHER (Human) Entrez Gene ID: 7752 Swiss Protein ID: P98182...
Anti-human C3a/C3a des-Arg (neo-epitope), Clone 2991, Monoclonal Antibody...
Biology Products: