Navigation Links
The great pond experiment: Regional vs. local biodiversity

Scientist Jon Chase once worked in a lab that set up small pond ecosystems for experiments on species interactions and food webs.

"We would try to duplicate pond communities with a given experimental treatment," he says.

"We put 10 of this species in each pond, and five of these species, and eight of the other species, and 15 milliliters of this nutrient and 5 grams of that and 'sproing,' every replicate would do its own thing and nothing would be like anything else.

"That made me curious. What if, instead of trying to eliminate the messiness, I tried to figure out where it was coming from?"

The results of that investigation are published online this week in Science Express. A seven-year experiment isolated one reason experimental ponds go wild: history.

If a pond has enough nutrients, the pond community that emerges depends on the order in which species were introduced, says Chase, an ecologist at Washington University in St. Louis.

The discovery has broad implications for highly productive ecosystems such as tropical rainforests and coral reefs, and for attempts to restore these ecosystems.

Restoration can fail if the original ecosystem bears the imprint or memory of its past in ways that are not understood.

"This study is an important experimental confirmation of the influence of primary productivity on regional biodiversity," says Alan Tessier, program director in the National Science Foundation (NSF)'s Division of Environmental Biology, which funded the research.

"The findings have broader relevance to the protection and restoration of biodiversity."

In the summer of 2002, Chase embarked on the long-term pond experiment at the Tyson Research Center, a 2,000-acre field station on the outskirts of St. Louis, and owned by Washington University.

He set out 45 cattle tanks in an old field, added dirt to each and filled them with well water.

The 300-gallon tanks are not as big as regular ponds, he says, but they're "decent-sized. I've even had herons try to fish in them, although they're a bit small for that."

He dosed the ponds with nutrients in the form of nitrogen- or phosphorus-containing chemicals. Each pond received low, medium or high levels of nutrients throughout the experiment.

Then he began adding species to the ponds. The species consisted of zooplankton; insects and small invertebrates such as snails; vascular aquatic plants; and filamentous green algae.

The first year, each pond had a randomly selected one-third of the species added. The following year, half the remaining species, again randomly selected, were added.

In the third year, the pond got a soup containing the remaining species.

Each pond received species in a different order but in the end, every pond got exactly the same species.

"Then we let nature take over," Chase says. "The plankton moved around in the wind and on frogs' backs, dragonflies flitted over and laid their eggs, beetles buzzed by, and it was a 'big happy wetland community.'"

Chase and a team of students sampled the ponds each summer to see how the communities were faring.

The low-productivity ponds all looked the same. But that was not the case for the high productivity ponds.

"The low productivity ponds were very predictable," he says. "The high productivity ponds were more stochastic [random]. Their history mattered more."

There were no big differences among the ponds when it came to number of species. The low productivity ones had roughly as many species as the high productivity ponds.

The biodiversity arose at a different scale, not within a pond but within a group of high-productivity ponds.

This kind of diversity is called beta diversity to distinguish it from local, or alpha diversity.

It directs our attention, Chase says, to ecosystem structure that emerges only at a certain scale. Beta diversity may emerge clearly only if we look regionally rather than locally.

Restorationists say ecology is plagued by the myth of the carbon copy, the idea that we can easily make an identical copy of an ecosystem because community assembly is predictable and always ends up in the same place.

Degrading an ecosystem resets it to an earlier stage, it was thought, from which it will develop in a predictable fashion to an end point.

But experience shows that replacement ecosystems often fall short of the original ones.

Chase's pond experiment suggests why.

Far from being carbon copies, ecosystems are historical artifacts, their final form a sensitive record of their past.


Contact: Cheryl Dybas
National Science Foundation

Related biology news :

1. Small mammals -- and rest of food chain -- at greater risk from global warming than thought
2. 700 international researchers gather for Great Lakes Research Conference
3. Food insecurity can lead to greater weight gain and complications during pregnancy
4. Plastic Surgeons Rate Auction of World-Class Florida Laterra Spa May 21 a Perfect 10, Great Business Opp for Celebrity Retreat
5. Invasive fish and mussels team up to transfer toxic substances into Great Lakes walleyes
6. Experts gather to solve mystery of largest recorded die-off of great whales
7. Veteran Great Lakes area journalist wins prestigious American Chemical Society award
8. American pika are thriving in the Sierra Nevada and southwestern Great Basin
9. World-class protection boosts Australias Great Barrier Reef
10. Great tits: birds with character
11. Deadly fish virus now found in all Great Lakes
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/29/2015)... Oct. 29, 2015  The J. Craig Venter Institute ... "DNA Synthesis and Biosecurity: Lessons Learned and Options for ... Health and Human Services guidance for synthetic biology providers ... --> --> Synthetic ... the potential to pose unique biosecurity threats. It now ...
(Date:10/29/2015)... , Oct. 29, 2015  Connected health pioneer, ... the explosion of technology-enabled health and wellness, and the ... book, The Internet of Healthy Things ... or smartphones even existed, Dr. Kvedar, vice president, Connected ... health care delivery, moving care from the hospital or ...
(Date:10/27/2015)... -- In the present market scenario, security is one ... verticals such as banking, healthcare, defense, electronic gadgets, and ... secure & simplified access control and growing rate of ... bank accounts, misuse of users, , and so on. ... and smartphones are expected to provide potential opportunities for ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:11/23/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Noblis, Inc., a leading provider of science, technology, and strategy ... Intelligence Agency (NGA), has joined the Noblis NSP team as President of the organization. ... community and the private sector,” said L. Roger Mason, Jr., Ph.D. , Senior ...
(Date:11/23/2015)... and PISCATAWAY, New Jersey , ... Crystallographic Data Centre (CCDC) announces the launch ... Database (CSD) and the CSD-System, now complemented by ... CSD-Discovery to support the discovery of new molecules, ... CSD-Enterprise, the complete set of the CCDC,s applications ...
(Date:11/23/2015)... -- CryoLife, Inc. (NYSE: CRY ), a leading medical device ... announced today that it will participate in the upcoming 27 ... 2, 2015 at The New York Palace Hotel in ... , President and Chief Executive Officer. --> ... --> A live webcast of the Company,s presentation is ...
(Date:11/23/2015)... , Nov. 23, 2015  Oxis Biotech, Inc. ... Inc. [OTC: OXIS] and [Euronext Paris: OXI.PA] announced ... Masonic Cancer Center received notification from the U.S. ... proceed with their planned combination Phase 1/Phase 2 ... rights to develop and commercialize OXS-1550, a novel ...
Breaking Biology Technology: