Navigation Links
Survey highlights barriers to interdisciplinary environmental science
Date:8/21/2013

Efforts to promote interdisciplinary research that addresses complex interactions between humans and their environment have become commonplace in recent years, but success is often elusive. To better understand the obstacles facing natural and social scientists attempting such work, Eric D. Roy of Louisiana State University and seven coauthors from a variety of institutions surveyed researchers at all career stages who were interested and experienced in such research. Roy and his coauthors report their findings in the September issue of BioScience.

The 323 respondents, most of them from North America, largely agreed that interdisciplinary research yielded valuable benefits, including the development of new kinds of knowledge. But many said that their efforts to achieve truly integrative interdisciplinary research had been unsuccessful, and had resulted in merely additive research that, although it involved multiple disciplines, preserved the typical separate concerns of each one.

Researchers who responded to the survey most often reported new perspectives and intellectual stimulation as benefits of interdisciplinary research. But a majority reported experiencing tensions with departments and institutions, and most reported difficulty publishing research results because they did not fit within traditional disciplinary boundaries. Researchers also reported tension with collaborators arising from their different methods, theories, or approaches, but this was less common than tension with departments and institutions. Communication problems and difficulties with time allocation and funding were identified as the greatest obstacles to interdisciplinary research.

When Roy and his colleagues asked about institutional support for interdisciplinary research, limits to career advancement and lack of credit for promotion and tenure were the most commonly mentioned barriers. Natural scientists and social scientists agreed on the nature of the obstacles and thought that institutional barriers were more significant than interpersonal ones. Researchers reported, for example, concerns that they were seen as "spreading out too much."

The results make clear that achieving the goal of working together as a single unit with researchers from different disciplinary backgrounds is often hard to achieve. Roy and his colleagues conclude that "many academic departments and institutions have yet to sufficiently encourage and reward the necessary pragmatic environmental synthesis work" for contemporary environmental questions. They suggest that a balance of disciplinary expertise and integration appears necessary to the perception of success by others, and that increased emphasis on interdisciplinary integration should occur not only in graduate education, but at the undergraduate level, as well. The authors also suggest that challenges be discussed at the outset of a project, and that administrators and faculty recognize that conducting interdisciplinary work will often temporarily slow the rate at which a researcher publishesalthough over the long term such work will typically lead to many publications.


'/>"/>

Contact: Tim Beardsley
tbeardsley@aibs.org
703-674-2500 x326
American Institute of Biological Sciences
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Survey of physicians suggests tablets more useful than smartphones
2. National survey highlights perceived importance of dietary protein to prevent weight gain
3. NREL survey shows dramatic improvement in B100 biodiesel quality
4. New bone survey method could aid long-term survival of Arctic caribou
5. Global surveys show environmental concerns rank low among public concerns
6. New survey of ocean floor finds juvenile scallops are abundant in Mid-Atlantic
7. Antimicrobials from personal care products found in statewide survey of Minnesotas rivers and lakes
8. UC Berkeley survey shows college campuses can make good bird havens
9. NOAA plankton surveys, second longest in the North Atlantic, add to new global effort
10. Genetic survey of endangered Antarctic blue whales shows surprising diversity
11. AGU journal highlights -- Aug. 13, 2013
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:11/24/2016)... 23, 2016 Cercacor today introduced Ember TM ... trainers non-invasively measure hemoglobin, Oxygen Content, Oxygen ... Respiration Rate in approximately 30 seconds. Smaller than a ... immediate access to key data about their bodies to ... regimen. Hemoglobin carries oxygen to muscles. ...
(Date:11/21/2016)... VILNIUS, Lithuania , Nov. 21, 2016 /PRNewswire/ ... identification and object recognition technologies, today announced that ... for smart cards was submitted for the ... and successfully passed all the mandatory steps of ... III evaluation is a continuing test of fingerprint ...
(Date:11/17/2016)... 17, 2016  AIC announces that it has just released a new white paper ... high-performance scale-out plus high speed data transfer storage solutions. Photo - ... ... ... Setting up a high performance computing or HPC ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:12/7/2016)... , ... December 07, 2016 , ... ... today announced that it has become a Wonderware Certified System Integrator Partner. ... Partner by Schneider Electric Software. , “The System Integrator Partner certification gives customers ...
(Date:12/7/2016)... , Dec. 7, 2016  Nordion, a ... General Atomics (GA), welcome today,s award by the ... Security Administration (NNSA) of the Phase II cooperative ... with Nordion and the University of Missouri Research ... funding will support the establishment of a new, ...
(Date:12/7/2016)... 7, 2016  Genprex, Inc. a biopharmaceutical company ... treatments, today announced that it has retained ICR ... strategic communications and advisory firm, to develop and ... will combine investor relations, public relations and digital ... profile of Genprex and its lead candidate Oncoprex, ...
(Date:12/7/2016)... ... December 07, 2016 , ... Cambrian Innovation , ... facilities, today announced that one of the nation’s fastest growing craft breweries, ... purchase agreement (WEPA). Under the WEPA, a first for the industrial wastewater treatment ...
Breaking Biology Technology: