Navigation Links
Study finds patients give 'broad endorsement' to stem cell research

In an early indication of lay opinions on research with induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs), which are stem cells made from skin or other tissues, a new study by bioethicists at Johns Hopkins University indicates that despite some ethical concerns, patients give the research "broad endorsement".

During focus group discussions patients were largely in favor of participating in iPSC research even if personal benefit was unlikely, though they raised concerns about consent, privacy and transparency when considering donating tissue for this research. The bioethicists report their findings in the journal Cell Stem Cell.

"Bioethicists, as well as stem cell researchers and policy-makers, have discussed the ethical issues of induced pluripotent stem cells at length, but we didn't have any systematic information about what patients think about these issues, and that is a huge part of the equation if the potential of this research is to be fully realized," says Jeremy Sugarman, the senior author of the report and the Harvey M. Meyerhoff Professor of Bioethics and Medicine at the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics.

Unlike human embryonic stem cells, iPSCs are derived without destroying a human embryo. Research with human iPSCs is valuable for developing new drugs, studying disease, and perhaps developing medical treatments. Sugarman explains that, while far off, scientists are hopeful that iPSCs could someday be used to develop organs for transplantation that the body's immune system will not attack, because they can be created from the person's own cells.

The study reveals the importance of prior informed consent for those asked to participate in it. According to the report, consent was highly important for patients in all five of the focus groups that were convened. Some patients even suggested that proper informed consent could compensate for other concerns they had about privacy, the "immortalization" of cells, and the commercialization of stem cells.

There was a "strong desire among participants to have full disclosure of the anticipated uses," the report notes, with some participants wanting to be able to veto certain uses of their cells. The authors acknowledge the "practical difficulties" of this request but hope that their findings will "prompt investigation into creative approaches to meeting these desires."

The study also revealed another side to some patients' selfless motivations to participate in research as they might relate to eventual commercialization. The report quotes one participant as saying, "It won't be just taken to become a money maker and the very people who need it the most will no longer be able to benefit from it" and another, "it was a donation. It's a humanitarian effort."

The authors also note that the unique characteristics of their small study could have influenced the results; for instance, the fact that it was conducted in Baltimore, Maryland, among patients who have received care at Johns Hopkins, where the first immortal cell line was created from tumor cells taken from Henrietta Lacks, put related issues at the forefront of many focus groups. "The idea that donated cells would potentially live forever was unnerving to some participants. In particular, the story about the creation of the HeLa cell line from Henrietta Lacks' cervical cancer tissue, taken without consent, was raised in four out of the five focus groups," the report states.

Additionally, the report indicates that the opinions that were expressed by patients may be influenced by their health, and whether or not they have personal experience with a debilitating illness, as some of the participants did.

"It seems fair to say that everyone experiences serious illness in their lives, whether themselves or through someone they know and care about, and this influences their opinions of healthcare and research," Sugarman says. "This study is a first step in getting crucial information about what values are factored into a decision to participate in iPSC research, and what those participants expect from the experience."


Contact: Leah Ramsay
Johns Hopkins Medicine

Related biology news :

1. Study by UC Santa Barbara researchers suggests that bacteria communicate by touch
2. Law that regulates shark fishery is too liberal: UBC study
3. New study will help protect vulnerable birds from impacts of climate change
4. Study jointly led by UCSB researcher supports theory of extraterrestrial impact
5. BYU study: Using a gun in bear encounters doesnt make you safer
6. 15-year study: When it comes to creating wetlands, Mother Nature is in charge
7. Pycnogenol (French maritime pine bark extract) shown to improve menopause symptoms in new study
8. Crystal structure of archael chromatin clarified in new study
9. EU-funded study underlines importance of Congo Basin for global climate and biodiversity
10. University of Houston study shows BP oil spill hurt marshes, but recovery possible
11. Study demonstrates cells can acquire new functions through transcriptional regulatory network
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/12/2015)... 2015 Hoyos Labs ... company, will introduce its new biometric four-finger ... simultaneously, providing an unprecedented level of security ... the new biometric standard for secure transactions ... from financial services to healthcare are implementing ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... DUBLIN , Oct. 12, 2015 ... the addition of the "Iris Recognition Market ... Others), Application (Access Control & Others), Industry (Travel ... Geography Global - Forecast to 2020" report ... --> Iris Recognition Market worth ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... Oct. 8, 2015 Synaptics Inc. (NASDAQ: ... solutions, announced today that it will report financial ... on Thursday, October 22, 2015, after the close ... conference call for analysts and investors at 2:00 ... may discuss forward-looking information. ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:10/9/2015)... ROCKVILLE, Md. , Oct. 9, ... biotechnology company developing next generation vaccines based on ... entered into an exclusive worldwide licensing agreement with ... treatment or prevention of any and all allergic ... Immunomic Therapeutics will receive an upfront payment of ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... , ... Leading microbial genomics startup uBiome today launched the first-ever microbiome app, ... management and the microbiome. The study uses the ResearchKit framework, designed by Apple, to ... The uBiome app is available as a free download from the App Store. The ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... 8, 2015  Genetic testing for mutations beyond those ... of more couples at risk of having a child ... at the 2015 American Society of Human Genetics (ASHG) ... Baltimore, Maryland . The study is one ... DGX ) are presenting at the conference this week ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... .   ... Goldman Small Cap Research, a stock market research ... sectors, announced today that it has published a ... (OTCQB - PMCB), a publicly traded, clinical stage ... for cancer and diabetes. To view the sponsored ...
Breaking Biology Technology: