Navigation Links
Scientists debate the accuracy of Al Gore's documentary 'An Inconvenient Truth'
Date:4/14/2008

There is no question that Al Gores 2006 documentary An Inconvenient Truth is a powerful example of how scientific knowledge can be communicated to a lay audience. What is up for debate is whether it accurately presents the scientific argument that global warming is caused by human activities. Climate change experts express their opinions on the scientific validity of the films claims in articles just published online in Springers journal, GeoJournal.

An Inconvenient Truth is about Al Gores campaign to educate citizens about global warming and inspire them to take action. The papers in GeoJournal agree that it does an excellent job of raising public awareness of man-made global warming and explains why increased atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases lead to warming. They also agree that its main weakness is that it tries to use individual extreme events, such as Hurricane Katrina, to prove the existence of global warming.

In the first opinion piece (1), Eric Steig from Washington University states that the film gets the fundamental science right. The minor factual errors do not undermine the main message of the film, which explains the theory that increasing carbon dioxide causes a warming tendency in the lower atmosphere.

John Nielsen-Gammon from Texas A&M University also agrees that the main scientific argument presented in the movie is for the most part consistent with the weight of scientific evidence (2). He comments that unfortunately, it neglects all information that can be gained from computer models, and instead relies entirely on past and current observational evidence. This increases the films emotional impact but weakens the scientific argument.

David Legates from the University of Delaware addresses assertions about trends in precipitation, floods, droughts and storms in particular (3). He concludes that there are significant errors in the film, owing to alarmism and exaggeration, which give a false i
'/>"/>

Contact: Joan Robinson
joan.robinson@springer.com
49-622-148-78130
Springer
Source:Eurekalert

0

GOOD

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Scientists compiled 20th century temperature data in Spain as evidence of climatic change
2. Atmospheric scientists gear up for collaborative airborne campaigns
3. AMNH scientists grace Science & Nature covers
4. Scientists uncover the potential to control adult stem cells
5. Scientists ask whether microscaffolding can help stem cells rebuild brain after stroke damage
6. Scientists find a fingerprint of evolution across the human genome
7. Death protein research secures funding for UCF scientists
8. Yale scientists visualize the machinery of mRNA splicing
9. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory scientists devise potential approach to treat spinal muscular atrophy
10. Scientists discover 356 animal inclusions trapped in 100 million years old opaque amber
11. Great Ape Trust to gather internationally recognized scientists for Decade of the Mind III
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/4/2008)...TON, Ill. --- Biological systems are constantly ev...vival amidst environmental fluctuations and intern...orthwestern University research team has found new...isms that are especially well suited to handle pot...utations. , The results, published online this...
(Date:9/4/2008)...NNATINew research from the University of Cincinnat...duce hard plasticsbisphenol A (BPA)as a risk facto... In a laboratory study, using fresh human fat tiss...ormone, adiponectin, which is responsible for regu...ople at a substantially higher risk for metabolic ...
(Date:9/4/2008)...IDGE, Mass., Sept. 4, 2008 Declaring the success ...anthropy, Los Angeles-based philanthropists Eli an...eased their total gift to the Broad Institute of H...evious gifts totaling $200 million, the Broads tod...e Institute, which had been launched as a 10-year ...
(Date:9/4/2008)...DENCE New research from Rhode Island Hospital fou...) can contribute to mild neurodegeneration with fe...irst study to show that obesity can cause neurodeg...lzheimer,s Disease Volume 15:1 (September 2008) .... Suzanne de la Monte, MD, MPH, of Rhode Island Hos...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):New evidence on the robustness of metabolic networks 2Bisphenol A linked to metabolic syndrome in human tissue 2Eli and Edythe L. Broad make unprecedented gift to endow Broad Institute of Harvard & MIT 2Eli and Edythe L. Broad make unprecedented gift to endow Broad Institute of Harvard & MIT 3Eli and Edythe L. Broad make unprecedented gift to endow Broad Institute of Harvard & MIT 4Eli and Edythe L. Broad make unprecedented gift to endow Broad Institute of Harvard & MIT 5Can SonicMood Help to Significantly Lower High Blood Pressure 3F The Latest Research Answers With a Resounding YES 21 20792 1Can SonicMood Help to Significantly Lower High Blood Pressure 3F The Latest Research Answers With a Resounding YES 21 20792 2Quest PharmaTech Announces Positive Results from Phase I Clinical Trial of its Photodynamic Therapy for Actinic Keratosis 5726 1Quest PharmaTech Announces Positive Results from Phase I Clinical Trial of its Photodynamic Therapy for Actinic Keratosis 5726 2Quest PharmaTech Announces Positive Results from Phase I Clinical Trial of its Photodynamic Therapy for Actinic Keratosis 5726 3Peregrine Pharmaceuticals Presents Promising Phase I Data at ASCO and Provides Clinical Update on Its Phase II Bavituximab Breast Cancer Study 5723 1Peregrine Pharmaceuticals Presents Promising Phase I Data at ASCO and Provides Clinical Update on Its Phase II Bavituximab Breast Cancer Study 5723 2Peregrine Pharmaceuticals Presents Promising Phase I Data at ASCO and Provides Clinical Update on Its Phase II Bavituximab Breast Cancer Study 5723 3Peregrine Pharmaceuticals Presents Promising Phase I Data at ASCO and Provides Clinical Update on Its Phase II Bavituximab Breast Cancer Study 5723 4Peregrine Pharmaceuticals Presents Promising Phase I Data at ASCO and Provides Clinical Update on Its Phase II Bavituximab Breast Cancer Study 5723 5Study Findings Show Infection Control Intervention Helps Keep Kids in School 2275 1Study Findings Show Infection Control Intervention Helps Keep Kids in School 2275 2Study Findings Show Infection Control Intervention Helps Keep Kids in School 2275 3
...l Association Journal shows that young farm childr...s the total population of young Canadian children ...lected and analyzed Canadian data on fatal agricul...s, identify patterns and devise prevention strateg... 1? years old, particularly boys, when on farms ar...
...sity of Leicester, Professor Sir Alec Jeffreys, is...ccolade later this year, it has been announced. , ...ofessor in the Department of Genetics, is to be aw...and Biophysics 2006 by the Royal Netherlands Acade...overy of the revolutionary technique. , The Dr H....
...ructure has been shown to make fat cells fatter an...ipose tissue, the primary energy depot in the body...d by a University of Michigan team acts as a metab... matrix that holds fat in place, which allows fat ...rative research team, headed by researchers Tae-Hw...
... on the environment near their dams, are also crit... Researchers have found that ponds created by beav...e Colorado River valley, keeping soil water levels...rwise dry valley bottom. The results will be publi... of the American Geophysical Union. , Cherie Westb...
Other Biology News:Eminent inventor of DNA fingerprinting gains new recognition 2Eminent inventor of DNA fingerprinting gains new recognition 3Expanding waistlines triggered by your genes 2Beaver dams create healthy downstream ecosystems 2
(Date:9/3/2008).../- Wyeth (NYSE: WYE ),toda... 54, to Vice,President, Corporate Communications. ...t, Corporate Affairs, Mr. McIntyre will be respons...for the corporation and its three,major divisions ...l health,-- around the world., Prior to joining W...
(Date:9/3/2008)...eeting to be held September 24 to 26 in Kansas Cit...) September 3, 2008 -— The U.S. Pharmacopeia...Meeting (ASM) will be held in Kansas City, Mo., Se... interact with the USP experts responsible for est... prescription and over-the-counter medicines, food...
(Date:9/3/2008).... 3 /- ESA Biosciences, a Magellan,Bi...on systems that improve,results for pharmaceutical...al-chemistry customers worldwide, announced that i...rican Technology Innovation Award in the,field of ...will present the,award to ESA,s Vice President of ...
(Date:9/3/2008)...swire/ -- US Oncology Specialty, LP, the,state-of-...ncology, has,received the Occupational Excellence ... for its outstanding safety achievements., The aw...t of the best",in safety and safety performance. T... from work resulting from workplace injuries or il...
Breaking Biology Technology:Wyeth Names Daniel J. McIntyre Vice President, Corporate Communications 2USP's 2008 Annual Scientific Meeting to Convene Scientific Experts from Around the World 2USP's 2008 Annual Scientific Meeting to Convene Scientific Experts from Around the World 3ESA Receives 2008 Frost & Sullivan North American Technology Innovation Award for Development of Integrated Metabolomics Systems 2ESA Receives 2008 Frost & Sullivan North American Technology Innovation Award for Development of Integrated Metabolomics Systems 3US Oncology Pharmaceutical Distribution Service Wins National Safety Council Award 2
...dison, Wis. - It may not rank with the Dating Ga... Madison-based online service is doing a little ma...nline service that matches privately held companie...ane County and Wisconsin, but it might be tempted ... highway. , ,The service has received inquiries ab...
...dison, Wis. - Virent Energy Systems, Inc. has b...rtment of Agriculture and the Department of Ener...a co-product of biodiesel production, into a renew...t was awarded as part of the joint USDA-DOE Bioma... established to develop of technologies that make ...
...urtevant, Wis. - The Center for Advanced Technol...perty management group that attempts to breath com...s, is taking its technology transfer model to nati...ing the launch of new products and companies in De...sconsin and elsewhere while building connections f...
... few weeks back, we took a look at the results of ...te for 2005. At that time, we saw that the Midwes... and we had another five states in the top 20 stat...he results for the leading universities for 2005 t...he NIH falls under the U.S. Department of Health ...
Other Biology Technology:Online service makes board connections 2Online service makes board connections 3Virent lands $2M grant for chemical production 2CATI takes tech transfer model national 2CATI takes tech transfer model national 3Midwest colleges strong contenders for NIH funds 2Midwest colleges strong contenders for NIH funds 3Midwest colleges strong contenders for NIH funds 4Midwest colleges strong contenders for NIH funds 5