Navigation Links
Scientists debate the accuracy of Al Gore's documentary 'An Inconvenient Truth'
Date:4/14/2008

There is no question that Al Gores 2006 documentary An Inconvenient Truth is a powerful example of how scientific knowledge can be communicated to a lay audience. What is up for debate is whether it accurately presents the scientific argument that global warming is caused by human activities. Climate change experts express their opinions on the scientific validity of the films claims in articles just published online in Springers journal, GeoJournal.

An Inconvenient Truth is about Al Gores campaign to educate citizens about global warming and inspire them to take action. The papers in GeoJournal agree that it does an excellent job of raising public awareness of man-made global warming and explains why increased atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases lead to warming. They also agree that its main weakness is that it tries to use individual extreme events, such as Hurricane Katrina, to prove the existence of global warming.

In the first opinion piece (1), Eric Steig from Washington University states that the film gets the fundamental science right. The minor factual errors do not undermine the main message of the film, which explains the theory that increasing carbon dioxide causes a warming tendency in the lower atmosphere.

John Nielsen-Gammon from Texas A&M University also agrees that the main scientific argument presented in the movie is for the most part consistent with the weight of scientific evidence (2). He comments that unfortunately, it neglects all information that can be gained from computer models, and instead relies entirely on past and current observational evidence. This increases the films emotional impact but weakens the scientific argument.

David Legates from the University of Delaware addresses assertions about trends in precipitation, floods, droughts and storms in particular (3). He concludes that there are significant errors in the film, owing to alarmism and exaggeration, which give a false i
'/>"/>

Contact: Joan Robinson
joan.robinson@springer.com
49-622-148-78130
Springer
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Scientists compiled 20th century temperature data in Spain as evidence of climatic change
2. Atmospheric scientists gear up for collaborative airborne campaigns
3. AMNH scientists grace Science & Nature covers
4. Scientists uncover the potential to control adult stem cells
5. Scientists ask whether microscaffolding can help stem cells rebuild brain after stroke damage
6. Scientists find a fingerprint of evolution across the human genome
7. Death protein research secures funding for UCF scientists
8. Yale scientists visualize the machinery of mRNA splicing
9. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory scientists devise potential approach to treat spinal muscular atrophy
10. Scientists discover 356 animal inclusions trapped in 100 million years old opaque amber
11. Great Ape Trust to gather internationally recognized scientists for Decade of the Mind III
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/18/2015)... , Aug. 18, 2015  Navitas today ... contributor to the Submission Content Management webinar ... a non-profit forum. Dedicated to the Implementation of ... neutral platform for industry, vendors, health authorities, ... and work towards a standard method of ...
(Date:8/12/2015)... , Aug. 12, 2015  New research ... can attack Android phones to steal users, fingerprints. ... increasing availability of fingerprint scanners on mobile devices, ... concern. To secure biometrics on mobile devices, HYPR ... augment these convenient authentication systems with strong cryptographic ...
(Date:8/6/2015)... Calif. , Aug. 6, 2015  Today, ... will visit Crossmatch ™ to learn firsthand ... and protect data. Crossmatch is a world leader ... technologies and expertise are helping federal agencies and ... and security.   "The vast majority ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Navitas, a Key Contributor in IRISS Forum Webinar 2Navitas, a Key Contributor in IRISS Forum Webinar 3HYPR Corp. Addresses Android Vulnerability That Exposes Ecosystem-wide Biometric Security Challenges 2HYPR Corp. Addresses Android Vulnerability That Exposes Ecosystem-wide Biometric Security Challenges 3Rep. Honda to Visit Crossmatch in Redwood City 2
... tea may slow down weight gain and serve as another ... food scientists. Obese mice that were fed a compound ... weight significantly more slowly than a control group of mice ... Lambert, assistant professor of food science in agricultural sciences. ...
... Va.Society of Interventional Radiology member Barry T. Katzen, ... medical director of Baptist Cardiac & Vascular Institute ... Disease Foundation,s Julius H. Jacobson II MD Award ... contributions to physician education, leadership or patient care ...
... States will meet some specific biofuel mandates under the ... are developed or policies change, says a new congressionally ... that the standard may be an ineffective policy for ... would likely increase federal budget outlays as well as ...
Cached Biology News:Green tea helps mice keep off extra pounds 2Society of Interventional Radiology member receives award for career contributions 2Society of Interventional Radiology member receives award for career contributions 3Certain biofuel mandates unlikely to be met by 2022; unless new technologies, policies developed 2Certain biofuel mandates unlikely to be met by 2022; unless new technologies, policies developed 3Certain biofuel mandates unlikely to be met by 2022; unless new technologies, policies developed 4
(Date:9/2/2015)... ... September 02, 2015 , ... Drug companies increasingly ... BCC Research reveals in its new report that the U.S. will generate ... category and generates the most market demand. , BCC Research examines plant-derived ...
(Date:9/2/2015)... FRANCISCO, Calif. , Sept. 2, 2015 ... Bonnie H. Anderson , president and chief executive ... Conference on Wednesday, September 16, 2015 at 10:30 a.m. ... The live audio webcast and subsequent ... . The webcast will be available shortly after conclusion ...
(Date:9/2/2015)... ... September 02, 2015 , ... ... to aid high-risk surgeries. From vital sign monitoring in ICU to 3D skull ... enables surgeon to make real-time clinical decisions with simultaneous access to high precision ...
(Date:9/2/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Genedata, a leading provider of advanced software ... ® version 13.0 at ELRIG Drug Discovery 2015. This latest version of the ... new capabilities. Screener now supports High Throughput Flow Cytometry (HT-Flow) and Drug Metabolism ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Plant-derived Compounds Poised to Assume Greater Role in Global Drug Markets, According to BCC Research 2Plant-derived Compounds Poised to Assume Greater Role in Global Drug Markets, According to BCC Research 3Veracyte to Present at Morgan Stanley Global Healthcare Conference 2Surgical Workstation Powered by 6th Gen. Intel® Core™ Skylake Processors 2Surgical Workstation Powered by 6th Gen. Intel® Core™ Skylake Processors 3New Genedata Screener 13.0 with Support for High Throughput Flow Cytometry and DMPK Unveiled at ELRIG 2New Genedata Screener 13.0 with Support for High Throughput Flow Cytometry and DMPK Unveiled at ELRIG 3New Genedata Screener 13.0 with Support for High Throughput Flow Cytometry and DMPK Unveiled at ELRIG 4
... ... ... ... ...
... ... ... ... ...
... , , ... ... ... ...
Cached Biology Technology:PDI to Present at the ROTH Capital Partners 22nd Annual OC Growth Stock Conference 2BioMS Medical reports Spectral receives FDA approval to initiate pivotal trial and closes financing for $19.5 million 2BioMS Medical reports Spectral receives FDA approval to initiate pivotal trial and closes financing for $19.5 million 3BioMS Medical reports Spectral receives FDA approval to initiate pivotal trial and closes financing for $19.5 million 4China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 2China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 3China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 4China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 5China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 6China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 7China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 8China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 9China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 10China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 11China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 12China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 13China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 14China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 15China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 16China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 17China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 18China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 19China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 20China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 21China Medical Technologies Reports Third Fiscal Quarter Financial Results 22