Navigation Links
Scholar unconvinced new lie-detection methods better than old ones
Date:6/2/2009

CHAMPAIGN, lll. When a crime has been committed, the usual modus operandi for police detectives and their fictional counterparts has been to dust the scene for fingerprints. And once they have a suspect in custody, out comes the polygraph, or lie detector.

But in today's forensically sophisticated, "CSI"-influenced world, polygraphy which bases its results on functions of the autonomic nervous system is increasingly dismissed as dated and unreliable. Rapidly replacing older truth-seeking technologies are new brain-based techniques such as functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), and the electroencephalography(EEG)-based technology known as Brain Fingerprinting.

Because they are "brain-based," both methods have been promoted in the media as being more precise, accurate and trustworthy.

"Functional magnetic resonance imaging and Brain Fingerprinting have been hailed as the next, best technologies for lie detection in America, particularly in the context of post-9/11 anxiety," University of Illinois professor Melissa Littlefield says in an article published in the May issue of the journal Science, Technology & Human Values.

"Far from describing the brain and its functions, fMRI and Brain Fingerprinting produce models of the brain that reinforce social notions of deception, truth and deviance," she concludes in the paper's abstract.

In other words, Littlefield is unconvinced that the new technologies are necessarily superior to the old ones. In fact, the professor of English and of kinesiology and community health believes polygraphy may have more in common with the new technologies than many scientists particularly neuroscientists would suggest.

"They would argue that traditional polygraphy tests the autonomic nervous system. That's respiration, heart rate, pulse, electrical skin conductance.

But, Littlefield said, using the old-fashioned lie detector, "you're not really getting decept
'/>"/>

Contact: Melissa Mitchell
melissa@illinois.edu
217-333-5491
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Source:Eurekalert

0

GOOD

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related biology news :

1. Five outstanding young gastroenterologists receive AGA Foundation 2009 Research Scholars Award
2. WPI professor receives Fulbright Scholarship to work on tissue engineering in Ireland
3. UC San Diego senior named Churchill Scholar for extraordinary undergraduate research
4. Celebrated UH researcher invited to Caltech as distinguished scholar
5. Case Western Reserve receives Ellison Medical Foundation New Scholar in Aging award
6. Rutgers scholar authors definitive biography of reproductive medicine pioneer
7. JDRF announces 2008 Scholar Award recipients
8. UC Berkeley virologist named Keck Distinguished Young Scholar
9. W.M. Keck Foundation announces 2008 class of Distinguished Young Scholars in Medical Research
10. Julia Zeitlinger named Pew Scholar
11. BP funds energy scholarships for K20 scholars
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/18/2012)... for energy, but too much sugar can create ... unwanted structural changes. Standard methods to monitor glucose ... cell culture. A team of engineers at the ... Microelectronics is developing an alternative approach that takes ... and controlled process, the researchers created small droplets ...
(Date:5/18/2012)... are making significant progress on rust-proofing steel using ... nontoxic alternative to coatings that contain hexavalent chromium, ... experiments, pieces of steel coated with the high-tech ... when immersed continuously in saltwater, an environment that ... dispersion of graphene within the composite, the researchers ...
(Date:5/18/2012)... will gather from the 21th to the 23rd May ... transfer of biodiversity knowledge from the scientific community into ... part in a project funded by the European Commission: ... by researchers and practitioners to help all actors in ... better informed decisions. This project aims at developing an ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Using graphene, scientists develop a less toxic way to rust-proof steel 2Using graphene, scientists develop a less toxic way to rust-proof steel 3A network of knowledge on biodiversity and ecosystem services in Europe 2Seven Secrets to Successful Caregiving of Older Adults 55536 1Seven Secrets to Successful Caregiving of Older Adults 55536 2Joint Commission Alert 3A Effective Leadership Critical to Preventing Medical Errors 55534 1Joint Commission Alert 3A Effective Leadership Critical to Preventing Medical Errors 55534 2Joint Commission Alert 3A Effective Leadership Critical to Preventing Medical Errors 55534 3Spinal Implant Developed by Sanford Clinic Neurosurgeon Receives FDA 510 28k 29 Market Clearance as a Lumbar Intervertebral Body Fusion Device 55532 1Spinal Implant Developed by Sanford Clinic Neurosurgeon Receives FDA 510 28k 29 Market Clearance as a Lumbar Intervertebral Body Fusion Device 55532 2Spinal Implant Developed by Sanford Clinic Neurosurgeon Receives FDA 510 28k 29 Market Clearance as a Lumbar Intervertebral Body Fusion Device 55532 3
... their cushy haploid environs to take up residence in ... biologists, but Indiana University Bloomington scientists report in this ... flowering plants. , "Plants that reproduce clonally or ... the mitochondrion to the nucleus," said graduate student Yaniv ...
... help shape our understanding of how tool use has ... at least under some conditions, are capable of habitually ... work, reported by Jill Pruetz of Iowa State University ... appear online in the journal Current Biology on February ...
... for HSV control measures, including vaccine, to rank high on ... are published , Treating women who are infected with both ... the amount of HIV in the blood and genital secretions, ... the New England Journal of Medicine. , A collaborative ...
Other Biology News:Mitochondrial genes move to the nucleus -- but it's not for the sex 2Chimpanzees found to use tools to hunt mammalian prey 2Anti-herpes treatment reduces HIV levels in women infected with both viruses 2Anti-herpes treatment reduces HIV levels in women infected with both viruses 3
(Date:5/15/2012)... SHENZHEN, China, May 15, 2012 ... today that a new Roche GS FLX+ System has ... The goal is to complement the existing array of ... sequencing capability. The GS FLX+ System, developed ... unique combination of long reads, exceptional accuracy and high-throughput, ...
(Date:5/14/2012)... light with 20 times the efficiency of an incandescent ... store data 100 times faster than those we use ... we could turn waste heat into electricity, or improve ... efficient, and more accessible? , The (IEE) at ... collaborative research campus that boasts five Nobel laureates among ...
(Date:5/14/2012)... billion people worldwide have a vision condition called presbyopia(1), which ... in the eye to change its shape to focus on ... read menus and newspapers. Maybe it has even happened to ... often begins around age 40, many people rely on contact ... both multifocal and daily disposable are very limited. Presbyopes ...
(Date:5/14/2012)... 14, 2012 Shire plc (LSE: SHP, NASDAQ: ... today announced its support of the first global hereditary ... with a new Facebook page "Shire Supports HAE Awareness ... every person who likes the Facebook page by May ... Angioedema Association (HAEA) up to $7,500. Visitors can learn ...
Breaking Biology Technology:BGI Installs Roche GS FLX+ System to Enhance Long Read Sequencing Capabilities for Genome and Transcriptome Research 2BGI Installs Roche GS FLX+ System to Enhance Long Read Sequencing Capabilities for Genome and Transcriptome Research 3Oracle chairman Jeff Henley makes $50 million gift to UC Santa Barbara 2Oracle chairman Jeff Henley makes $50 million gift to UC Santa Barbara 3Oracle chairman Jeff Henley makes $50 million gift to UC Santa Barbara 4New Daily Disposable Multifocal Contact Lenses from CooperVision Offer Comfort, Performance, Health, and Convenience to Fit Your Life 2New Daily Disposable Multifocal Contact Lenses from CooperVision Offer Comfort, Performance, Health, and Convenience to Fit Your Life 3Shire Facebook Page Increases Awareness of Hereditary Angioedema (HAE) in Support of First HAE Awareness Day May 16th 2Shire Facebook Page Increases Awareness of Hereditary Angioedema (HAE) in Support of First HAE Awareness Day May 16th 3Shire Facebook Page Increases Awareness of Hereditary Angioedema (HAE) in Support of First HAE Awareness Day May 16th 4
... Israel and JERSEY CITY, New Jersey, November 26, Rosetta ... release third quarter financial results on December 5, 2008, ... conference call with a,simultaneous webcast to discuss these results ... To access the live ...
... the experts in,strong authentication, today announced that its ... with the SAFE-BioPharma(TM),digital identity and signature standard. , ... is an online digital signature workflow solution that,manages ... PDF documents,using Adobe Reader. The ability to leverage ...
... Zounds Hearing, a unique manufacturing,and retail company ... point and professional service, announces the introduction of,assistive ... all who are hard of,hearing. The various devices ... Hearing,Centers retail locations effective November 24, 2008. ...
Other Biology Technology:Rosetta Genomics Announces Conference Call and Webcast of Third Quarter Financial Results 2MySignatureBook Certified Compliant With SAFE-BioPharma Digital Standard(TM) 2MySignatureBook Certified Compliant With SAFE-BioPharma Digital Standard(TM) 3Zounds Offers the Gift of Hearing This Holiday Season With a Range of New Products 2
... western blots ,• Optically clear plastic construction ... western blots. The reduced size (60 x ... tray requires less dye and antibodies resulting ... user. Pour spouts in each corner facilitate ...
... has been designed and created in order ... friendly genotyping analysis tool. We incorporated the ... into the software. Their main requirements were ... low acquisition cost. GeneMarker can perform ...
...
... Free Epitope Design consultation. Peptide ... 17 amino acids). Conjugation to KLH. ... Immunization of 2 New Zealand white ... 5 immunizations and 4 production bleeds. ...
Biology Products: