Navigation Links
Open science journal publishes attempt to reproduce high-profile stem cell acid bath study
Date:5/8/2014

In a study published today in F1000Research, Professor Kenneth Lee of the Chinese University of Hong Kong reveals the full experimental results of an attempt to replicate a controversial study published in Nature recently that suggested that bathing somatic cells in acid can reprogram them to induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS cells). With systematically collected and fully available data, Lee and his colleagues report that carefully replicating the original acid-treatment method does not induce pluripotency in two types of mouse somatic cells, including those used in the original study.

iPS cells have the unique ability to give rise to most other cell types, and have potentially wide therapeutic applications. This characteristic can be triggered in other cells by transforming them into iPS cells, which further increases the potential for stem cell therapies. Earlier this year, a group from Japan reported a greatly simplified procedure for producing iPS cells by bathing somatic cells in an acid bath.

To verify these claims, Kenneth Lee set out to replicate the work in his own lab, and documented his experiments online in the process, leading to lively online discussions between stem cell scientists who provided feedback and commentary along the way. Using both white blood cells isolated from the spleen of neonatal mice - the same cells used in the original study - and lung fibroblasts, Lee was unable to replicate the original findings, and has now published the full results of his study in F1000Research.

Unlike most journals, all research papers in the open access journal F1000Research are accompanied by the full underlying datasets so other researchers will be able to re-analyse and more easily reproduce the work. In addition, F1000Research employs open peer review by invited expert scientists, which occurs after publication and is published in full online alongside the paper, removing much of the potential bias that often occurs in traditional anonymous pre-publication peer review.

"Publishing Professor Lees attempted replication study in this unique and open manner will facilitate a less-hyped and more informed debate and demonstrates the value of this extra level of transparency in the publication process", says Daniel Marovitz, CEO of F1000.

Lee's study will now undergo this transparent invited peer review process and anyone interested to see referees' views as they come in can follow the paper by clicking 'Track' on the published article.


'/>"/>

Contact: Eleanor Howell
press@f1000.com
44-020-763-19129
Faculty of 1000
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. National Academy of Sciences elects Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies scientist
2. National Academy of Sciences elects 5 from UChicago, Marine Biological Laboratory
3. Study in Science finds missing piece of biogeochemical puzzle in aquifers
4. Jerry Melillo of MBL Ecosystems Center elected to National Academy of Sciences
5. Arizona State University professor is elected to the National Academy of Sciences
6. BRIC carries big science in small canisters
7. Two San Diego scientists elected to the National Academy of Sciences
8. New Translational Addiction Sciences Center poised to make headway in treatment of addiction
9. ESA to publish the Journal of Insect Science
10. Bioethicists use theatrical narratives to bridge the gap between society and science
11. PETA science consortium to present hazard testing strategy at nanotoxicology meeting
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:12/20/2018)... , ... December 20, 2018 , ... ... upgraded processes and the completion of a new usability/observation room. This addition will ... of ensuring medical devices and drug delivery devices/combination products are safe and easy ...
(Date:12/19/2018)... ... December 19, 2018 , ... ... study in Arthroscopy evaluating the use of novel surgical techniques, including ... These tears represent a painful, disabling condition for which there are historically few ...
(Date:12/18/2018)... ... 2018 , ... CP Merritt is a national champion Arabian horse that currently ... in 2006, he had a medical setback that caused him to limp at a ... cartilage degeneration in his right rear fetlock. Such an injury could be career ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:12/18/2018)... ... 2018 , ... Patients with early stages of breast cancer who undergo partial ... whole breast irradiation, a new study suggests. , Patients with early stage breast cancer ... removal of the cancerous tumor because there is a 30 to 40 percent change ...
(Date:12/13/2018)... ... December 12, 2018 , ... Helping conclude Healthy Aging Month this past ... hearing aid within its Vision and Hearing campaign that sets out to shed light ... that despite continued efforts to destigmatize hearing aids over the years, 9 out of ...
(Date:12/5/2018)... (PRWEB) , ... December 05, 2018 , ... The incredible ... paid tribute to in the European Parliament by Carlos Moedas, the European Commissioner for ... EU Research and Innovation in Our Daily Lives, Commissioner Moedas spoke at length of ...
(Date:11/28/2018)... ... November 28, 2018 , ... Earlier this month, Lajollacooks4u's Founder and Chef ... experience the height of truffle season. , Her first stop was Umbria, ... in the exclusive Black Truffle Lodge in the small mountain village of Pettino, Chef ...
Breaking Biology Technology: