Navigation Links
More talk, less agreement: Risk discussion can hurt consensus-building on science/technology
Date:11/4/2010

When it comes to public issues pertaining to science and technology, "talking it out" doesn't seem to work. A new study from North Carolina State University shows that the more people discuss the risks and benefits associated with scientific endeavors, the more entrenched they become in their viewpoint and the less likely they are to see the merit of other viewpoints.

"This research highlights the difficulty facing state and federal policy leaders when it comes to high-profile science and technology issues, such as stem cell research or global warming," says Dr. Andrew Binder, an assistant professor of communication at NC State and lead author of the study. "Government agencies view research on these issues as vital and necessary for the country's future, but building public consensus for that research is becoming increasingly difficult."

The researchers set out to see how people talk about risks associated with unfamiliar science and technology issues, Binder explains. "Most people, when faced with an issue related to science and technology, adopt an initial position of support or opposition," Binder says. "Our results demonstrate very clearly that the more people talk about divisive science and technology issues, the less likely the two camps are to see the issue in the same way. This is problematic because it suggests that individuals are very selective in choosing their discussion partners and hearing only what they want to hear during discussions of controversial issues."

In the study, the researchers focused on public debate related to the National Bio- and Agro-Defense Facility (NBAF), which the federal government discussed building in one of six sites around the country. Some members of the public opposed building a facility housing highly infectious animal diseases in their community. The six proposed sites were Athens, Ga., Manhattan, Kan., Plum Island, N.Y., Butner, N.C., Flora, Miss., and San Antonio, Texas. Manhattan was
'/>"/>

Contact: Matt Shipman
matt_shipman@ncsu.edu
919-515-6386
North Carolina State University
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Animals talk, sing and act like humans?
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/30/2014)... Salk professor and Howard Hughes Medical Institute investigator, ... named recipients in the 2014 round of grants ... the BRAIN (Brain Research through Advancing Innovative Neurotechnologies) ... announced September 30, provides more than $3 million ... years. , The BRAIN Initiative, launched last year, ...
(Date:9/30/2014)... water may increase the risk of stillbirth and ... by a Boston University School of Public Health ... Environmental Health , compared 1,091 PCE-exposed pregnancies ... Cape Cod, Ma., where water was contaminated in ... the installation of vinyl-lined asbestos cement pipes. PCE ...
(Date:9/30/2014)... live in almost any aquatic environment on Earth, but ... species are pushed to the limit. The amount of ... critical for how different species cope in the future, ... of Gothenburg, published in the scientific journal Proceedings ... continues apace thanks to increasing levels of greenhouse gases ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Salk scientists receive $3 million for BRAIN Initiative grant 2Contaminated water linked to pregnancy complications, BU study finds 2Shape up quickly -- applies to fish, too! 2
... in ecological or environmental conservation remains contentious the ... demand that governments regulate and encourage restoration projects; ... corporations makes such interventions politically difficult. However, ... a handful of developing nations, alongside South Africa, ...
... , RIVERSIDE, Calif. Alan McHughen , a ... University of California, Riverside, has been chosen by the ... Sciences to receive a 2011-2012 Jefferson Science Fellowship ... selected for the fellowships this year. Successful ...
... is redefining the rules by which we live and at ... level, several areas of the globe are in danger of ... and maybe, one day, live in floating houses. Depending ... others in their adjustment to the effects of global warming, ...
Cached Biology News:UC Riverside plant biotechnologist receives prestigious Jefferson Science Fellowship 2UC Riverside plant biotechnologist receives prestigious Jefferson Science Fellowship 3Floating houses 2Floating houses 3
(Date:9/30/2014)... , September 30, 2014 ... intuitive browsing of chemistry in documents ... software solutions and consulting services for life science ... information and generate Markush structures from documents. ... organizations intellectual property, however generating and understanding Markush ...
(Date:9/30/2014)... Sept. 30, 2014 FemCap Inc., www.femcap.com ... its receipt of a patent No: US, 8,795,248 B2 ... also received FDA clearance in the U.S., 510(K) K121857, ... in Europe. This patent is related to its menstrual cup ... the company is releasing FemmyCycle Teen, a third menstrual ...
(Date:9/30/2014)... SoundConnect, an award ... dedicated to supporting business communication solutions, including business ... a carrier services specialist has joined ... connected and productive at all times. This growth ... businesses to cloud communications services. On a ...
(Date:9/30/2014)... Back in the 1970’s, many companies calculated their ... which included space for circulation and file storage. “It ... at Nidea Corporate Real Estate / ITRA Global , ... 2000, however, 250 square feet per employee became the ... to 175 to 225 square feet, and over the next ...
Breaking Biology Technology:ChemAxon Introduces ChemCurator for Chemical Information Extraction and Markush Structure Creation 2The FemmyCycle 2SoundConnect Expands Carrier Services Division 2ITRA Global Reports on How Companies Are Squeezing More Employees into Less Office Space 2ITRA Global Reports on How Companies Are Squeezing More Employees into Less Office Space 3
... , ... , , , Antibodies ... arrays) or as biopharmaceutical therapeutics. In,all cases the successful production ... criteria include: protein identification,quantitation and the monitoring of purity and ...
... , ... , , , ... of the Agilent 2100 bioanalyzer in combination,with the Protein 200 Plus ... denaturing gel-elctrophoresis (SDSPAGE).,The results showed that the Agilent 2100 bioanalyzer provides,fast ...
... , ... , , , , ... an siRNA sequence,for a target gene, which are of,high importance ... crucial.,An efficient method to optimize,transfection and gene silencing,is critical for ...
Cached Biology Technology:Quality control of antibodies using the,2100 bioanalyzer and the Protein 200,Plus assay 2Quality control of antibodies using the,2100 bioanalyzer and the Protein 200,Plus assay 3Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 2Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 3Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 4Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 5Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 6Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 7Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 8Comparison of different protein,quantitation methods 9Confirming gene silencing,mechanism by pGFP/GFP22 ,siRNA co-transfection 2Confirming gene silencing,mechanism by pGFP/GFP22 ,siRNA co-transfection 3Confirming gene silencing,mechanism by pGFP/GFP22 ,siRNA co-transfection 4