Navigation Links
MIT neuroscientists explore how longstanding conflict influences empathy for others
Date:1/24/2012

CAMBRIDGE, Mass. -- MIT postdoc Emile Bruneau has long been drawn to conflict not as a participant, but an observer. In 1994, while doing volunteer work in South Africa, he witnessed firsthand the turmoil surrounding the fall of apartheid; during a 2001 trip to visit friends in Sri Lanka, he found himself in the midst of the violent conflict between the Tamil Tigers and the Sri Lankan military.

Those chance experiences got Bruneau, who taught high school science for several years, interested in the psychology of human conflict. While teaching, he also volunteered as counselor for a conflict-resolution camp in Ireland that brought Catholic and Protestant children together. At MIT, Bruneau is now working with associate professor of cognitive neuroscience Rebecca Saxe to figure out why empathy the ability to feel compassion for another person's suffering often fails between members of opposing conflict groups.

"What are the psychological barriers that are put up between us in these contexts of intergroup conflict, and then, critically, what can we do to get past them?" Bruneau asks.

Bruneau and Saxe are also trying to locate patterns of brain activity that correlate with empathy, in hopes of eventually using such measures to determine how well people respond to reconciliation programs aimed at boosting empathy between groups in conflict.

"We're interested in how people think about their enemies, and whether there are brain measures that are reliable readouts of that," says Saxe, who is an associate member of MIT's McGovern Institute for Brain Research. "This is a huge vision, of which we are at the very beginning."

Before researchers can use tools such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to evaluate whether conflict-resolution programs are having any effect, they need to identify brain regions that respond to other people's emotional suffering. In a study published Dec. 1 in Neuropsychologia, Saxe and Bruneau scanned people's brains as they read stories in which the protagonist experienced either physical or emotional pain. The brain regions that responded uniquely to emotional suffering overlapped with areas known to be involved in the ability to perceive what another person is thinking or feeling.

Failures of empathy

Hoping to see a correlation between empathy levels and amount of activity in those brain regions, the researchers then recruited Israelis and Arabs for a study in which subjects read stories about the suffering of members of their own groups or that of conflict-group members. The study participants also read stories about a distant, neutral group South Americans.

As expected, Israelis and Arabs reported feeling much more compassion in response to the suffering of their own group members than that of members of the conflict group. However, the brain scans revealed something surprising: Brain activity in the areas that respond to emotional pain was identical when reading about suffering by one's own group or the conflict group. Also, those activity levels were lower when Arabs or Israelis read about the suffering of South Americans, even though Arabs and Israelis expressed more compassion for South Americans' suffering than for that of the conflict group.

Those findings, published Jan. 23 in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society: Biological Sciences, suggest that those brain regions are sensitive to the importance of the opposing group, not whether or not you like them.

However, because the study did not reveal any correlation between the expression of empathy and the amount of brain activity, more study is needed before MRI can be used as a reliable measure of empathy levels, Saxe says.

"We thought there might be brain regions where the amount of activity was just a simple function of the amount of empathy that you experience," Saxe says. "Since that's not what we found, we don't know what the amount of activity in these brain regions really means yet. This is basically a first baby step, and one of the things it tells us is that we don't know enough about these brain regions to use them in the ways that we want to."

Bruneau is now testing whether these brain regions send messages to different parts of the brain depending on whether the person is feeling empathy or not. He hypothesizes that when someone reads about the suffering of an in-group member, the brain regions identified in this study send information to areas that process unpleasant emotions, while stories about suffering of a conflict-group member activate an area called the ventral striatum, which has been implicated in schadenfreude taking pleasure in the suffering of others.


'/>"/>

Contact: Caroline McCall
cmccall5@mit.edu
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Cutting-edge imaging techniques for neuroscientists available in latest laboratory manual
2. UC Riverside neuroscientists discovery could bring relief to epilepsy sufferers
3. Blocking crucial molecule could help treat multiple sclerosis, Jefferson neuroscientists say
4. Caltech neuroscientists discover brain area responsible for fear of losing money
5. 2 neuroscientists from Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory awarded transformative NIH grants
6. Caltech neuroscientists find brain region responsible for our sense of personal space
7. Neuroscientists discover long-term potentiation in the olfactory bulb
8. Bipolar disorder genes, pathways identified by Indiana University neuroscientists
9. Sea snails help scientists explore a possible way to enhance memory
10. Neuroethics of memory to be explored at Dec. 9 symposium
11. Research team explores how microbial diversity defends against disease
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:1/24/2017)... , Jan. 24, 2017 Biopharm Reports ... the laboratory use of nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy ... end-users and profiled current practices, developments, trends and ... well as growth and opportunities. These areas include ... NMR instruments, needs and innovation requirements, hyphenated NMR ...
(Date:1/23/2017)...  The latest mobile market research from Acuity Market ... The quarterly average price of a biometric smartphone decreased ... 2016.  There are now 120 sub-$150 models on the ... just 28 a year ago at an average price ... Most , Acuity Market Intelligence Principal, "Biometric Smartphones are ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... , January 19, 2017 According to a new report ... Forecast, 2014 - 2022," the global biometric sensor market is expected to garner ... 2022. In 2015, Asia-Pacific dominated the global market and ... sectors. Continue Reading ... ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:2/23/2017)... 23, 2017 /PRNewswire/ - The Fight Against Cancer Innovation ... (OICR) are pleased to report that Fusion Pharmaceuticals Inc. ... Johnson & Johnson Innovation – JJDC, Inc. (JJDC) as ... HealthCap, TPG Biotechnology Partners, and Genesys Capital, as well ... ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... February 23, 2017 , ... ... clearance to begin marketing the SPEAC® System, the Brain Sentinel® Seizure Monitoring and ... or in healthcare facilities during periods of rest. A lightweight, non-invasive monitor is ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... , Feb. 23, 2017  Capricor Therapeutics, Inc. (NASDAQ: CAPR), ... medical conditions, today announced that Linda Marbán, Ph.D, president and ... investor conferences: Cowen and Company 37th ... am ET Boston, MA ... 9:00 am PT (12:00 pm ET) Dana Point, ...
(Date:2/22/2017)... ... February 22, 2017 , ... Kernel ... Kendall Research Systems, LLC (KRS) clinical development program. KRS is a neurotechnology ... for research and clinical applications. The terms of the transaction were not disclosed. ...
Breaking Biology Technology: