Navigation Links
MIT: No easy answers in evolution of human language
Date:2/17/2008

CAMBRIDGE, Mass. The evolution of human speech was far more complex than is implied by some recent attempts to link it to a specific gene, says Robert Berwick, professor of computational linguistics at MIT.

Berwick will describe his ideas about language in a session at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science on Sunday, Feb. 17. The session is called Mind of a Toolmaker, and explores the use of evolutionary research in understanding human abilities.

Some researchers in recent years have speculated that mutations in a gene called Foxp2 might have played a fundamental role in the evolution of human language. That was based on research showing that the gene seems to be connected to language ability because some mutations to that gene produce specific impairments to language use, and because our closest living relatives, the chimpanzees, lack both these gene mutations and the capacity for language. But the claim that the gene mutation is directly connected to the development of language is very unlikely to be right, says Berwick, who holds appointments in MITs Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science and Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences.

This kind of straightforward connection is just not the way organisms are put together, he says. When it comes to something as complex as language, one would be hard-pressed to come up with an example less amenable to evolutionary study. And the specific Foxp2 connection is based on a whole chain of events, each of which is speculative, so theres little chance of the whole story being right.

Its so chaotic, its like weather forecasting, he says. The noise overwhelms the signal.

Rather, language is almost certainly the result of a far more complex and subtle interplay among a variety of factors, Berwick says, and it may never be possible to connect it to specific genetic changes. There are some things in science that are ver
'/>"/>

Contact: Elizabeth Thomson
thomson@mit.edu
617-258-5402
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. Fungus genome yielding answers to protect grains, people and animals
2. Dartmouth researchers find the root of the evolutionary emergence of vertebrates
3. Tomato pathogen genome may offer clues about bacterial evolution at dawn of agriculture
4. Oldest Australian crayfish fossils provide missing evolutionary link
5. Lessons from evolution applied to national security and other threats
6. Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa commits 180M to revive farmers depleted soils
7. Biophysical Society to host discussions on the teaching of evolution and on the energy crisis
8. Gene Networks in Animal Development and Evolution Feb. 15 and 16
9. Snoozing worms help Penn researchers explain the evolution of sleep
10. Evolution of the sexes: What a fungus can tell us
11. New book reveals an evolutionary journey of the human body
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:4/24/2014)... largest study of animal intelligence to-date finds that animals with ... this week in the journal Proceedings of the National ... long history of research aimed at understanding the animal mind. ... make and use tools, read social cues, or even understand ... studies of animal intelligence have focused on only one or ...
(Date:4/24/2014)... The alligator snapping turtle is the largest river turtle ... pounds and living almost a century. Now researchers from ... it is not one species but three. , ... deep evolutionary divisions in this ancient reptile. , Once ... the main ingredient of Campbell,s Turtle Soup in the ...
(Date:4/23/2014)... have added "playwright" to their resumes in an effort ... onslaught of ethical issues as genomic science transitions to ... first sequenced. , Until now the plays of ... performed for, and by, their peers and others in ... classrooms. With Oxford University Press, publication of the ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Animals with bigger brains, broader diets have better self control 2Animals with bigger brains, broader diets have better self control 3Two new US turtle species described 2Two new US turtle species described 3Bioethicists use theatrical narratives to bridge the gap between society and science 2Bioethicists use theatrical narratives to bridge the gap between society and science 3
... Columbia study has found traces of the bacteria listeria in ... food microbiologist Kevin Allen tested a total of 40 ready-to-eat ... seven large chain stores and 10 small retailers in Metro ... fish jerky. The findings published in a ...
... could do more than just save people the trouble ... researchers have found that the "universal" vaccine could for ... of flu by limiting the influenza virus, ability to ... named for their effectiveness against several flu strains ...
... Institute (IVI), an international organization based in Seoul devoted ... for the developing world, reached a milestone in its ... shigellosis or bloody diarrhea), a deadly disease that affects ... the bacterial pathogen Shigella , is a major ...
Cached Biology News:Traces of listeria found in Vancouver ready-to-eat fish products: UBC study 2'Universal' vaccines could finally allow for wide-scale flu prevention 2'Universal' vaccines could finally allow for wide-scale flu prevention 3'Universal' vaccines could finally allow for wide-scale flu prevention 4'Universal' vaccines could finally allow for wide-scale flu prevention 5IVI granted 2 US patents on dysentery vaccine inventions 2
(Date:1/15/2014)... Automotive, a group of car dealerships headquartered in ... Center and offering free oil change coupons for participation in ... 18 at the Bill Jacobs Cadillac and Chevrolet location from ... )  The Bill Jacobs Auto annual blood ...
(Date:1/15/2014)... (PRWEB) January 15, 2014 Cynvenio, a ... management through the genomic analysis of tumor cells in ... Finder™, a web-based cancer decision support application powered by ... with Cynvenio’s ClearID™ genomic test, Therapy Finder will provide ...
(Date:1/15/2014)... , January 15, 2014 A study has ... on the Formula 1 track could help to tackle the ... Technologies (MAT), Stowhealth (a GP surgery based in Stowmarket) and ... provider Simplyhealth. Telemetry technology, which is inspired by ...
(Date:1/15/2014)... January 15, 2014 DTS Language Services, ... Online Web Portal for Life Science organizations who need document ... the subject matter of their documents in advance with a ... reduce time-to-delivery of translations, often a critical factor in clinical ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Join the Bill Jacobs Auto blood drive and receive a free oil change 2Cynvenio Offers New Breast Cancer Therapy Finder Application for its ClearID Breast Cancer Genomic Test 2Cynvenio Offers New Breast Cancer Therapy Finder Application for its ClearID Breast Cancer Genomic Test 3Formula 1 Technology Tackles Obesity in Unique Healthcare Partnership 2Formula 1 Technology Tackles Obesity in Unique Healthcare Partnership 3Formula 1 Technology Tackles Obesity in Unique Healthcare Partnership 4DTS Improves Efficiency for Life Science Document Translations 2
... tech arena: even when the economy is down, people keep ... ventures (whether self-funded, friends-and-family backed or fueled some other creative ... jobs. They create lots of jobs. In fact, small businesses ... shows no sign of slowing. , ,It can be appealing ...
... Wis. Having judged last years a success, ... it has opened the second annual Wisconsin Governor's ... plans. , ,Interested businesses will submit 250-word business proposals ... information technology, and business services. The proposals will be ...
... children, December is full of excitement and anticipation of what may ... as I screen the final onslaught of companies vying for a ... wait until February to unwrap the selected 70 or so companies ... along the way that just wont wait until the conference ...
Cached Biology Technology:How to duck the 3 most common entrepreneurial hiring traps 2How to duck the 3 most common entrepreneurial hiring traps 3How to duck the 3 most common entrepreneurial hiring traps 4Governors business-plan competition starts another round 2Governors business-plan competition starts another round 3An early Christmas gift 2