Navigation Links
MIT: No easy answers in evolution of human language
Date:2/17/2008

CAMBRIDGE, Mass. The evolution of human speech was far more complex than is implied by some recent attempts to link it to a specific gene, says Robert Berwick, professor of computational linguistics at MIT.

Berwick will describe his ideas about language in a session at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science on Sunday, Feb. 17. The session is called Mind of a Toolmaker, and explores the use of evolutionary research in understanding human abilities.

Some researchers in recent years have speculated that mutations in a gene called Foxp2 might have played a fundamental role in the evolution of human language. That was based on research showing that the gene seems to be connected to language ability because some mutations to that gene produce specific impairments to language use, and because our closest living relatives, the chimpanzees, lack both these gene mutations and the capacity for language. But the claim that the gene mutation is directly connected to the development of language is very unlikely to be right, says Berwick, who holds appointments in MITs Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science and Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences.

This kind of straightforward connection is just not the way organisms are put together, he says. When it comes to something as complex as language, one would be hard-pressed to come up with an example less amenable to evolutionary study. And the specific Foxp2 connection is based on a whole chain of events, each of which is speculative, so theres little chance of the whole story being right.

Its so chaotic, its like weather forecasting, he says. The noise overwhelms the signal.

Rather, language is almost certainly the result of a far more complex and subtle interplay among a variety of factors, Berwick says, and it may never be possible to connect it to specific genetic changes. There are some things in science that are ver
'/>"/>

Contact: Elizabeth Thomson
thomson@mit.edu
617-258-5402
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. Fungus genome yielding answers to protect grains, people and animals
2. Dartmouth researchers find the root of the evolutionary emergence of vertebrates
3. Tomato pathogen genome may offer clues about bacterial evolution at dawn of agriculture
4. Oldest Australian crayfish fossils provide missing evolutionary link
5. Lessons from evolution applied to national security and other threats
6. Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa commits 180M to revive farmers depleted soils
7. Biophysical Society to host discussions on the teaching of evolution and on the energy crisis
8. Gene Networks in Animal Development and Evolution Feb. 15 and 16
9. Snoozing worms help Penn researchers explain the evolution of sleep
10. Evolution of the sexes: What a fungus can tell us
11. New book reveals an evolutionary journey of the human body
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:12/5/2014)... 4, 2014 Increased emphasis on product ... new testing and inspection technologies. The convergence of ... a range of innovative test solutions. This trend ... Y, which is generally more inclined towards communication, ... development strategies of test equipment vendors will cater ...
(Date:12/3/2014)... Dec. 2, 2014 As part of our ... Technologies is pleased to announce the release of a ... to collect the workforce data that they need. ... been left by existing readers. Many such devices have ... and modern technology. Older models force users to navigate ...
(Date:11/21/2014)... Wash. , Nov. 20, 2014 C-Labs ... for the Internet of Things (IoT), today announced the ... of chief operating officer. Previously a strategic advisor to ... finance, and operations. Mr. Traynor is based out of ... . He reports to Chris Muench , Chief ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Emerging Technologies Enable Smarter Monitoring of Assets, Push Industrial Testing, Inspection and Monitoring Market 2Emerging Technologies Enable Smarter Monitoring of Assets, Push Industrial Testing, Inspection and Monitoring Market 3Emerging Technologies Enable Smarter Monitoring of Assets, Push Industrial Testing, Inspection and Monitoring Market 4Inception Technologies to Release New Biometric Reader 2C-Labs Names Former Microsoft and Bsquare Executive as Chief Operating Officer 2
... attaining a reliable water supply for California and ... realized until better planning can identify how trade-offs ... water is limited, says a new report from ... been ineffective in meeting these goals because management ...
... Research led by Lauren Cole, a public health graduate ... Health and Director of the Epidemiology Program at LSU ... of head and neck cancer has risen at sites ... greatest increase among middle-aged white men. At the same ...
... An international team of researchers led by the University ... discovery of a breast cancer risk gene and could assist ... Melissa Southey of the Genetic Epidemiology Laboratory, Department of Pathology ... it was a significant discovery and the first breast cancer ...
Cached Biology News:Increasing water scarcity in California's Bay-Delta will necessitate trade-offs; 'hard decisions' needed to balance various environmental risks 2Increasing water scarcity in California's Bay-Delta will necessitate trade-offs; 'hard decisions' needed to balance various environmental risks 3Increasing water scarcity in California's Bay-Delta will necessitate trade-offs; 'hard decisions' needed to balance various environmental risks 4LSUHSC research finds HPV-related head & neck cancers rising, highest in middle-aged white men 2Breast cancer risk gene discovery fast tracked by new technology 2
(Date:12/19/2014)... -- Decision Resources Group finds that the Latin American ... compound annual growth rate through 2023. This is primarily ... increasing adoption of dental implants. Growing aesthetic consciousness in ... demand for dental biomaterials because they can improve the ... Other key findings from Decision Resources Group,s coverage ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... 18, 2014 BioPlus Specialty ... specialty pharmacies, has an expanded team of Regional ... consultants for prescriber offices in their regions, with ... “We have a variety of Regional Pharmaceutical Care ... specializing in hepatitis C help prescribers understand all ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... MA (PRWEB) December 18, 2014 LayerBio ... for ophthalmology and wound care. The National Eye Institute ... awarded LayerBio a Phase I SBIR grant to develop ... Cataracts are the most common cause of vision loss ... of blindness worldwide. According to Dr. Ken Mandell, LayerBio’s ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... 2014 Reports from CDC ... suffer from one or more chronic health conditions - ... can address some of these diseases, but may not ... sufferers face. While implanted nerve stimulation devices today offer ... nerve, which can induce side effects. , To ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Latin American Dental Biomaterial Market Will Expand at a 12 Percent Annual Growth Rate Through 2023 2Latin American Dental Biomaterial Market Will Expand at a 12 Percent Annual Growth Rate Through 2023 3BioPlus Specialty Pharmacy Expands ‘Regional Pharmaceutical Care Liaison’ Team 2BioPlus Specialty Pharmacy Expands ‘Regional Pharmaceutical Care Liaison’ Team 3LayerBio Awarded NIH Grant to Develop a Drug Delivery Device for Cataract Surgery 2Draper Wins GSK Funding for Smaller, Smarter Implantable Devices 2
... P&G,s Commitment to Sustainable Innovation., Accelerates LS9,s Entry into ... ... South San Francisco, CA (PRWEB) -- LS9, Inc., the ... Procter and Gamble (NYSE: PG), one of world,s largest consumer ...
... goBalto.com , ... San Francisco, CA ... partnering site for the pharmaceutical development and drug manufacturing industry, ... of India-based Investigator Sites and hospitals available on goBalto.com. , ...
... Reprints NRx for the Force.com AppExchange saves time for ... process from within Salesforce CRMSANTA MONICA, Calif., May 19 ... announced the availability of Reprints NRx for ... the Force.com platform, Reprints NRx for the AppExchange is ...
Cached Biology Technology:LS9 and Procter & Gamble Launch Sustainable Chemicals Partnership 2goBalto Partners with Maya Clinicals to Expand Its List of Investigator Sites 2goBalto Partners with Maya Clinicals to Expand Its List of Investigator Sites 3Reprints Desk Medical Reprint Service Now Available to Life Science Professionals on the Force.com AppExchange 2Reprints Desk Medical Reprint Service Now Available to Life Science Professionals on the Force.com AppExchange 3
Ms anti-Cyclophilin D...
... to qualitatively detect EGFR ... paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue sections, ... cell preparations, using Chromogenic ... Fluorescent In Situ Hybridization ...
Mouse GM CSF Construction Kit provides antigen affinity purified polyclonal capture and tracer antibodies, and antigen standard for development of approximately ten microplate assays....
Many mammalian cell types and experimental situations create challenges for standard transfection experiments. The ViraPower Lentiviral Expression System overcomes these challenges with efficient...
Biology Products: