Navigation Links
Lessons offered by emerging carbon trading markets

DURHAM, N.C. -- Although markets for trading carbon emission credits to reduce greenhouse gas emissions have stalled in United States federal policy-making, carbon markets are emerging at the state level within the U.S. and around the world, teaching us more about what does and doesn't work.

In a Policy Forum article in the March 21 edition of Science magazine, Duke University's Richard Newell, William Pizer and Daniel Raimi discuss the key lessons from a decade of experience with carbon markets. They also discuss what it might take for these markets to develop and possibly link together in the coming years and decades.

These carbon markets are a key part of an emerging global policy framework that includes trading programs and other policies such as renewable energy incentives, carbon taxes, and traditional regulation. They have encouraged modest reductions in greenhouse gas emissions so far and expanded to cover a substantial and growing share of global emissions.

The Duke authors note that the emergence of a global system, built from the bottom up, faces a number of challenges including differences in program structure and the concern that business and industry may be driven away from a region or nation where programs are more stringent. While economic arguments tend to favor the linking of markets, other issues such as the challenge of comparing one program to the next, national and regional political concerns, and the financial flows resulting from international carbon trade will create challenges for the bottom-up linking of programs.

"The challenges are indeed real, but each time these markets have faced a challenge, they've learned something important," said Newell, director of the Duke University Energy Initiative and the Gendell Professor of Energy and Environmental Economics at the Nicholas School of the Environment.

"With these markets springing up, we have lessons from the past that can be applied to new markets such as the one in California, the one in Quebec, or the ones developing in China," Newell said. "As a result, they will hopefully avoid some of the problems that others have dealt with in the past."

The European Union's Emission Trading System (EU-ETS) has seen significant challenges recently, with prices falling to historic lows in 2013. Australia's carbon market is slated to be repealed this summer, after the new governing party makes good on its election promise to abolish it.

Still, such issues haven't stopped the development of new programs. China recently saw the establishment of five regional pilot carbon markets, nearly doubling the volume of emissions covered by existing trading programs. Kazakhstan also has a pilot program in place, and South Korea plans a new market. After successful launches in 2013, California and Quebec have recently linked their markets.

The authors review how these programs are addressing concerns such as uncertainty over carbon market prices and how to approach differences in policy and structure across programs.

"We are learning from the problems and successes of the past," said co-author William Pizer, an Associate Professor of Public Policy, Economics and Environment at Duke's Sanford School of Public Policy and a faculty fellow at the Nicholas Institute for Environmental Policy Solutions. "As governments revise existing market rules or new markets arrive, the system evolves. It's all being tried and updated in real time."

Contact: Margaret Lillard
Duke University

Related biology news :

1. Woolly mammoth extinction has lessons for modern climate change
2. Climate and drought lessons from ancient Egypt
3. Lessons from Bangladesh
4. Biodiversity conservation depends on scale: Lessons from the sience-policy dialogue
5. Biodiversity conservation depends on scale: Lessons from the science-policy dialogue
6. Bergen-Belsen lessons underline vital role that nurses can play in patient feeding
7. Mass extinction study provides lessons for modern world
8. Research, response for future oil spills: Lessons learned from Deepwater Horizon
9. Early music lessons boost brain development
10. Lessons from cockroaches could inform robotics
11. Managing waters shared across national boundaries: Treasury of papers helps capture 20 years of lessons
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/18/2015)... , Nov. 18, 2015  As new scientific discoveries ... doctors and other healthcare providers face challenges in better ... and patients. In addition, as more children continue to ... patient,s adulthood and old age. John M. ... Children,s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) . --> ...
(Date:11/17/2015)... 2015 Paris , ... --> Paris , qui s,est tenu ... le leader de l,innovation biométrique, a inventé le premier ... empreintes sur la même surface de balayage. Jusqu,ici, deux ... pour les empreintes digitales. Désormais, un seul scanner est ...
(Date:11/16/2015)... Nov 16, 2015  Synaptics Inc. (NASDAQ: ... solutions, today announced expansion of its TDDI product ... touch controller and display driver integration (TDDI) solutions ... These new TDDI products add to the previously-announced ... TD4302 (WQHD resolution), and TD4322 (FHD resolution) solutions. ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:11/23/2015)... Columbia, Md. (PRWEB) , ... November 23, 2015 ... ... R&D 100 award for the development of its Nexera UC Unified Chromatography system. ... the 100 most technically significant new products of the year in the analytical ...
(Date:11/23/2015)... , November 23, 2015 ... to develop daclatasvir for 112 ... countries   --> --> ... for a hepatitis C medicine, signing an agreement with Bristol-Myers ... to help cure multiple genotypes of the HCV virus.  The ...
(Date:11/23/2015)... November 23, 2015 biochar market ... in 2015, and it is expected to grow with ... factors driving the growth of the global market include ... property of biochar, increased government initiatives and stringent environmental ... and stringent environment regulations are the key drivers for ...
(Date:11/23/2015)... 23, 2015 BioInformant, the ... serve the stem cell sector, announces ... report, "Mesenchymal Stem Cells – Advances ... presents 250 pages of coverage for ... industry. ...
Breaking Biology Technology: