Navigation Links
IVF treatment and multiple births: Free-market patient rights versus government regulation
Date:7/26/2011

e aggressive use of single embryo transfer became possible, patients being prepared to risk a failure first time round, because the subsequent use of frozen embryos and/or a second cycle of treatment was still affordable. The authors say: "It is logical to use the cumulative pregnancy rate or cumulative live birth rate per initiated cycle, combining results from transfer of fresh and frozen embryos, as the standard measure of a patient's chances for a baby."

However, this paper then provoked a responding commentary by Dr Norbert Gleicher of Yale and New York, who attacks both the rationale and the ethics of the Quebec approach. First, he agrees that triplet pregnancies are a high risk to both mother and off-spring. But then he goes on to claim that both the risk to mother and babies, as well as the overall costs to the health system, of two serial singleton pregnancies are as great as, if not greater than, those of a twin pregnancy, implying that the gains of single embryo transfer are at best illusionary. Second, Gleicher objects to the intrusion of government into health care decisions on the grounds that this interferes with a patient's right to self-determination or "to choose". Indeed, Gleicher vociferously advocates the USA free market model over the European-style sympathy for government intervention in health care, his hope being "to keep government out of medicine".

This blast of free-market proselytizing is countered, appropriately from Europe, in a detailed response from Dr Yakoub Khalaf et al. of Guy's and Thomas' Hospital, London, who claim that practice should be based on solid data rather than personal judgment and proceed to dissect and question Gleicher's calculations on the relative outcomes of double versus serial single embryo transfer. They set the right of patient self-determination against a doctor's ethical duty to practice in the best interests of her patients, and not to acquiesce passively to requests she knows to be
'/>"/>

Contact: Gedis Grudzinskas
jgg@rbmonline.com
44-195-478-1812
Elsevier
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. BUSM awarded $9 million to investigate treatment for sickle cell disease using iPS cells
2. Penn vet researchers show lymphoma drug shrinks dog tumors, could lead to human treatment
3. UWM research offers hope for treatment of cocaine addiction
4. Stem cells restore cognitive abilities impaired by brain cancer treatment
5. Researchers closing in on safe treatment for parasitic diseases
6. Behavioral treatment for migraines a cost-effective alternative to meds, study finds
7. Extending the vase life of cut flowers: Pre-treatments and preservatives studied
8. Treatment approach to human Usher syndrome: Small molecules ignore stop signals
9. IOF calls for improved strategies to close the treatment gap and reduce future burden of fractures
10. Scripps Research scientists awarded $2.2 million to develop treatment for multi-drug addiction
11. Potential treatment for deadly E. coli disease
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/29/2014)... Researchers at UC Davis have made some surprising ... infection. Studying simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV), the team ... Paneth cells are early responders to viral invasion ... producing a cytokine called interleukin-1 beta (IL-1β). ... IL-1β causes breakdown of the gut epithelium that ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston has gone ... can completely protect monkeys against a lethal dose of Ebola ... when the disease is severe. , Thomas Geisbert, professor of ... discussing advances in Ebola treatment research. The filoviruses known ... deadly of pathogens, with fatality rates of up to 90 ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... available in German . ... the natural nitrogen cycle on Earth and in biological ... thought to depend on nitrite as their source of ... Daims, a microbiologist at the University of Vienna, has ... an alternative source of energy. The oxidation of hydrogen ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):The early cost of HIV 2Leading Ebola researcher at UTMB says there's an effective treatment for Ebola 2Hydrogen powers important nitrogen-transforming bacteria 2Hydrogen powers important nitrogen-transforming bacteria 3
... nation,s Upper Midwest have changed greatly since the time ... coming. That,s according to research done by Lisa ... of Natural Resource Ecology and Management and her team ... entire ecosystem," said Schulte, whose research has recently been ...
... be lacking for perennial wheat to be grown on any ... Dr. Charlie Rush, Texas Agricultural Experiment Station plant pathologist., ... plant breeders, Rush is finding a groundswell of interest as ... on his perennial wheat study., Rush obtained his initial ...
... may occur, in part, because of a problem in an ... key chemical messenger in the brain, scientists have found in ... that the gene is turned on at increasingly high rates ... the brain involved in higher functions like thinking and decision-making ...
Cached Biology News:Upper Midwest forests are losing diversity, complexity, ISU study finds 2A wheat for all seasons -- and reasons 2A wheat for all seasons -- and reasons 3How schizophrenia develops: Major clues discovered 2
(Date:8/29/2014)... on electrons, but one of the most promising technologies ... based on light (photons) instead of electrons. First, it ... of single photons and control their direction. Researchers around ... achieve this control, but now scientists at the Niels ... of photons emitted one at a time and in ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... Pittsburgh, PA (PRWEB) August 29, 2014 ... Chairman, Hub MacDonald, and colleague Koichiro Matsuda, Horiba Scientific, ... JASIS on September 5, 2014. JASIS , Asia’s ... September 3-5, 2014, in Makuhari Messe, Japan. , ... New Tools for Bioanalysis from Single Molecules to Single ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... California (PRWEB) August 29, 2014 ... of Energy's 2014 Hydrogen Production R&D Award ... -- by splitting water using sunlight. , Shared ... (NREL) and the University of Nevada, Las Vegas ... work developing models of photoelectrochemical solar-hydrogen production and ...
(Date:8/29/2014)... August 29, 2014 Intrinsic Imaging, ... certified, GAMP® 5 compliant imaging core lab, announced ... Phase II clinical trial to assess a new ... this trial, Intrinsic Imaging will provide comprehensive imaging ... protocol and charter development, site qualification, site training ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Breakthrough in light sources for new quantum technology 2Fifth Annual U.S. Symposium at JASIS Organized by Pittcon’s Program Chairman Hub MacDonald 2Livermore Team Awarded for Hydrogen Production Research 2Intrinsic Imaging Awarded Phase II Clinical Trial to Assess New Treatment for Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma 2
... cells is limited by a lack of methods for studying ... different methods, a team of Uppsala researchers have now provided ... on several levels at the same time. Their article is ... also show that the method can be used to determine ...
... decorative, flower-like defects in the nanomaterial graphene could have ... and mechanical properties, according to researchers at the National ... In a new paper,* the team for the first ... occur naturally or be induced to occur in graphene, ...
... of the March 11 earthquake and rolling blackouts that ... award-winning undergraduate internship program NanoJapan is scrambling to run ... U.S. undergraduates travel to Japan for lab internships, NanoJapan ... send 25-30 students to Rice University laboratories for three ...
Cached Biology Technology:Combo method reveals cells' signal systems 2Defect in graphene may present bouquet of possibilities 2Reverse NanoJapan: Rice to host 25-30 Japanese students 2
Goat polyclonal to MLH3 Immunogen: Synthetic peptide: RQSLQQSMPPCEPP (Human) from C Terminus of the protein sequence according to NP_055196....
Polyclonal Antibody to SHPRH...
Rabbit polyclonal to TetR ( Abpromise for all tested applications). Antigen: Synthetic peptide: AQKLGVEQPTLYWHVKNKR, corresponding to amino acids 31 - 49 of TetR...
Biotin anti-mouse Ly-49C/F/I/H...
Biology Products: