Navigation Links
Hastings Center resources chart progress in debate over medical research with animals

The scientific and ethical debate over the use of animals in medical research has raged for years, but perspectives are shifting, viewpoints are becoming more nuanced, and new initiatives are seeking alternatives to animal testing, according to a special report by The Hastings Center, "Animal Research Ethics: Evolving Views and Practices." The report is available on a new Web site,, a hub of educational information that defines and interprets this changing landscape.

These resources are the outcome of a project on the ethics of medical research with animals, which brought together people with different points of view and areas of expertise to share their knowledge and exchange ideas and insights. The project was led by Gregory Kaebnick, a research scholar at The Hastings Center; Thomas Murray, senior research scholar and President Emeritus; and Susan Gilbert, public affairs and communications manager.

"Our goal was to produce educational resources for a wide audience, including biomedical researchers, scholars, students, institutional animal care and use committees, policymakers, and journalists who follow animal research issues," says Kaebnick.

The special report, published with the Hastings Center Report, contains commentaries from the participants that cite examples of changes under way that are improving the welfare of animals in research and in some cases replacing them with alternative models.

One example is the recent set of limitations on the use of chimpanzees in federally-funded research. Jeffrey Kahn, who chaired the Institute of Medicine committee that recommended the limitations, discusses their implications and the decision by the National Institutes of Health to implement them. "The policy changes represent a watershed in animal research policy," writes Kahn, the Robert Henry Levi and Ryada Hecht Levi Professor of Bioethics and Public Policy in the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics. The recommendations "will impose the strongest restrictions to date on the use of any animal species for research in the United States, a major change in animal research policy in general."

Another example of change is a "paradigm shift" in toxicology testing that aims to replace animals with a process that uses human cells to study a chemical's "pathway of toxicity." Traditionally, rats and mice have been used to study the toxicity of new chemicals before they are tested in humans, but these experiments require large number of animals, take years to complete, and predict human toxicity only 43 percent of the time, writes Joanne Zurlo, director of science strategy for the Center for Alternatives to Animal Testing at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. She describes a new experimental approach that uses human cells to study a chemical's toxicity. "The paradigm shift in toxicology testing is the most significant force to date leading to the ultimate elimination of animal use for biomedical research and testing," Zurlo concludes.

A commentary by Kathleen Conlee and Andrew Rowan, senior officials at the Humane Society of the United States, argues that phasing out invasive research on nonhuman primates must be a priority for ethical, scientific, and economic reasons. The authors state that most nonhuman primate research is unnecessary and animal maintenance is expensive, with the government spending $1 billion of its $32 billion annual budget on the nation's primate research centers.

But Dr. D. Eugene Redmond, Jr., professor of psychiatry and neurosurgery at the Yale University School of Medicine, makes the case that nonhuman primates still play a vital role in key areas of medical research. Redmond, who studies Parkinson disease, says that the monkey model "is the best model we have and can predict benefits and side effects of new treatments."

Other authors are Larry Carbone, a veterinarian specializing in the care of laboratory animals; Susan Kopp, a veterinarian and professor of health sciences in the veterinary technology program at LaGuardia Community College, City University of New York, and a scholar at the Yale Interdisciplinary Center for Bioethics; Stephen R. Latham, director of the Interdisciplinary Center for Bioethics at Yale University; Joel Marks, professor emeritus of philosophy at the University of New Haven and co-director of the animal ethics study group at Yale; and Bernard E. Rollin, university distinguished professor, professor of philosophy, animal sciences, and biomedical sciences, and university bioethicist at Colorado State University.

Additional educational resources can be found on the Hastings animal research Web site,, including statistics on the use of different animal species, alternative research models, links to other significant reports, animal studies programs, a selected and updated bibliography, and an interactive glossary of terms used in debates on research with animals that can have multiple meanings such as the word "alternative." In the interest of fostering clear and civil discussion of the ethical controversies, The Hastings Center invites visitors to offer suggestions on the further development of the glossary.


Contact: Susan Gilbert
845-424-4040 x244
The Hastings Center

Related biology news :

1. Medical societies unite on patient-centered measures for nonsurgical stroke interventions
2. KAIST and Saudi Aramco agreed to establish a joint CO2 research center in Korea
3. Lyncean Technologies Inc. sells Compact Light Source to Munich biomedical-imaging research center
4. Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center Launches Wake Forest Innovations
5. Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center partners with GlaxoSmithKline to develop muscular dystrophy therapeutics
6. Surgical Theater, LLC sells first Surgical Rehearsal Platform to UH Case Medical Center
7. Mainz University Medical Center agrees partnership with Yale University
8. UH Case Medical Center leads international study
9. Israels first Green Roofs Ecology research center dedicated at University of Haifa
10. TESARO and Virginia G. Piper Cancer Center announce first patient in clinical trial of TSR-011
11. Feinstein Institute receives $1 million grant to study impact of World Trade Center attacks on responders
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/5/2015)... 5, 2015 ) ... NXT-ID, Inc. (NASDAQ: NXTD ), a biometric authentication ... --> ) releases the following ... NXTD ), a biometric authentication company focused on the ... Group ( ) releases the following ...
(Date:9/30/2015)... , Sept. 30, 2015  With nearly 300,000 ... number of new SCIs estimated to reach 12,500 annually, ... Southern California Resource Services for Independent Living (SCRS-IL) ... in California opening doors to ... of programs and services, notably assistive technology services and ...
(Date:9/29/2015)... , Sept. 29, 2015 ... employee productivity while also saving energy , Minimized ... as Low Power Active Mode and embedded Fujitsu PalmSecure ... Fujitsu today shows that good things ... and refreshed models to its enterprise desktop and mobile ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:10/12/2015)... 12, 2015  Rebiotix Inc. today announced that ... its lead Microbiota Restoration Therapy (MRT) RBX2660 as ... Clostridium difficile (C diff) infection, a ... 29,000 deaths in the U.S. annually. 1 ... was founded to revolutionize the treatment of debilitating ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... , Oct. 12, 2015  Patara Pharma, a ... and inflammatory diseases and conditions, today announced the ... stock financing. Concurrent with the close of its ... a Loan and Security Agreement with Silicon Valley ... $7 million. Patara will use the funds from ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... ... October 12, 2015 , ... Dr. Carl Peck, MD, ... the firm as a Premier Expert consultant. NDA Partners Premier Experts are ... value to the company's clients. Premier Experts collaborate to design and implement ...
(Date:10/10/2015)... , le 10 octobre 2015 Le 8 octobre, ... intégré dans le Registre du Congrès sa déclaration ... pour la sensibilisation autour du plasma (IPAW), qui ... sponsorisée par la Plasma Protein Therapeutics Association ... à : , Sensibiliser l,opinion publique ...
Breaking Biology Technology: