Navigation Links
Gender gap: Selection bias snubs scholarly achievements of female scientists

Women scientists must confront sexism when competing for awards that recognize their research, according to a new analysis.

Research funded by the National Science Foundation and sponsored by the Association for Women in Science found that female scientists win service or teaching awards in proportion to the number of women in the PhD pool for their discipline, says sociologist Anne Lincoln at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. That's not the case, however, for awards for their research, says Lincoln, one of three authors on the research, which was reported in Nature.

The number of women who win scholarly awards is far fewer, the authors report.

"Using data in the public domain on 13 disciplinary societies, we found that the proportion of female prizewinners in 10 of these was much lower than the proportion of female full professors in each discipline," the authors write.

Why the gap? Lincoln, an assistant professor in the SMU Sociology Department, and her co-authors point to the award selection process.

An analysis of selection practices found that selection committees carry out their duties with few guidelines, minimal oversight and little attention to conflict-of-interest issues, the authors write. The researchers' investigation found that the chances a woman will win an award for her research improve if a woman is serving on the committee.

The analysis found, however, that many committees don't have female members, that there are few female chairs and that female nominees are few, said the authors.

Nomination letters for women typically include personal details and contain stereotypically female adjectives, such as "cooperative" and "dependable," the authors report in the article.

"Notices soliciting nominations, by contrast, tend to use language that fosters male images, such as 'decisive' or 'confident,'" they report.

Co-authors were Stephanie H. Pincus, founder of the RAISE Project, sponsored by the Society for Women's Health Research; and biochemist Phoebe S. Leboy at the University of Pennsylvania and the Association for Women in Science.

Seven U.S. science societies are working now with the Association for Women in Science on the basis of the findings to change selection committee practices, say the authors.


Contact: Margaret Allen
Southern Methodist University

Related biology news :

1. Gender biases in leadership selection during competitions within and between groups
2. Two from one: Pitt research maps out evolution of genders from hermaphroditic ancestors
3. Gene linked to lupus might explain gender difference in disease risk
4. Age, gender can affect risk to radiation treatment
5. Sex on the brain: Doublesex gene key to determining fruit fly gender
6. Gender-specific disease risks start in the womb
7. Gender-bending fish problem in Colorado creek mitigated by treatment plant upgrade
8. Research shows gender difference in energy compensation effect
9. Research proves gender-bending chemicals affect reproduction
10. Ecologists say metabolism accounts for why natural selection favors only some species
11. New research shows how gene function drives natural selection in important class of genetic elements
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/8/2015)... Calif. , Oct. 8, 2015 ... of human interface solutions, announced today that it ... of fiscal 2016 on Thursday, October 22, 2015, ... host a corresponding conference call for analysts and ... during which management may discuss forward-looking information.    ...
(Date:10/7/2015)... Sweden , October 8, 2015 ... the revenues for Fingerprint Cards (FPC) during third quarter 2015 ... revenue guidance of around 860 MSEK that was communicated 20 ... Considering a further strengthened delivery capacity and a continued growing ... quarter 2015 is estimated to be higher than during the ...
(Date:10/6/2015)... , Oct. 6, 2015  Maverix Biomics, Inc., ... enhancements to its software portfolio with the debut ... for differential expression in eukaryotes. The software is ... a cloud-based genomic analysis solution that leverages proven ... from next-generation sequencing efforts. Garry Nolan,s ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:10/13/2015)... 2015 PharmaCyte Biotech, Inc. (OTCQB: PMCB) shares closed ... at near average with 1,308,352 shares being traded. PMCB shares ... hitting a low of $.072 in September, then bouncing back ... Our due diligence will show investors in PharmaCyte Biotech, ... report by using the link below at no cost. ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... , October 13, 2015 " Microbiology ... Forecast 2015 - 2023 " , the global ... is anticipated to reach US$7.59 bn by 2023, expanding at a ... --> " Microbiology Culture Market - Global Industry ... " , the global microbiology culture market was valued ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... TapImmune, Inc. (TPIV), a ... peptide and gene-based immunotherapeutics and vaccines for the treatment ... presenting company at the Dawson James Small Cap ... Jupiter, Florida on October 15, ... clinical-stage immunotherapy company specializing in the development of innovative ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... Charlotte, NC (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 ... ... high intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) technologies, announced today that it received de novo ... 450 in the U.S. for the ablation of prostate tissue. Sonablate® is ...
Breaking Biology Technology: