Navigation Links
Forest health versus global warming: Fuel reduction likely to increase carbon emissions
Date:12/20/2011

CORVALLIS, Ore. Forest thinning to help prevent or reduce severe wildfire will release more carbon to the atmosphere than any amount saved by successful fire prevention, a new study concludes.

There may be valid reasons to thin forests such as restoration of forest structure or health, wildlife enhancement or public safety but increased carbon sequestration is not one of them, scientists say.

In research just published in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, Oregon State University scientists conclude that even in fire-prone forests, it's necessary to treat about 10 locations to influence fire behavior in one. There are high carbon losses associated with fuel treatment and only modest savings in reducing the severity of fire, they found.

"Some researchers have suggested that various levels of tree removal are consistent with efforts to sequester carbon in forest biomass, and reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide levels," said John Campbell, an OSU research associate in the Department of Forest Ecosystems and Society. "That may make common sense, but it's based on unrealistic assumptions and not supported by the science."

A century of fire suppression in many forests across the West has created a wide range of problems, including over-crowded forests, increased problems with insect and pathogen attack, greater risk of catastrophic fire and declining forest health.

Forest thinning and fuel reduction may help address some of those issues, and some believe that it would also help prevent more carbon release to the atmosphere if it successfully reduced wildfire.

"There is no doubt you can change fire behavior by managing fuels and there may be other reasons to do it," said Mark Harmon, holder of the Richardson Chair in Forest Science at OSU. "But the carbon does not just disappear, even if it's used for wood products or other purposes. We have to be honest about the carbon cost and consider it along with the other reasons for this type of forest management."

Even if wood removed by thinning is used for biofuels it will not eliminate the concern. Previous studies at OSU have indicated that, in most of western Oregon, use of wood for biofuels will result in a net loss of carbon sequestration for at least 100 years, and probably much longer.

In the new analysis, researchers analyzed the effect of fuel treatments on wildfire and carbon stocks in several scenarios, including a single forest patch or disturbance, an entire forest landscape and multiple disturbances.

One key finding was that even a low-severity fire released 70 percent as much carbon as did a high-severity fire that killed most trees. The majority of carbon emissions result from combustion of surface fuels, which occur in any type of fire.

The researchers also said that the basic principles in these evaluations would apply to a wide range of forest types and conditions, and are not specific to just a few locations.

"People want to believe that every situation is different, but in fact the basic relationships are consistent," Campbell said. "We may want to do fuel reduction across much of the West, these are real concerns. But if so we'll have to accept that it will likely increase carbon emissions."


'/>"/>
Contact: Mark Harmon
mark.harmon@oregonstate.edu
541-737-8455
Oregon State University
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Satellite data shows that Kirtlands warblers prefer forests after fire
2. Forests cooler or warmer than open areas depending on latitude, study finds
3. Holm oaks will gain ground in northern forests due to climate change
4. Forest Service part of team sequencing 1,000 fungal genomes
5. Tropical forests are fertilized by air pollution
6. Savannas, forests in a battle of the biomes, Princeton researchers find
7. Forests not keeping pace with climate change
8. Fewer marten detections in California forest linked to decline in habitat
9. Forest fires are becoming larger and more frequent
10. Production of biofuel from forests will increase greenhouse emissions
11. Leaf litter ants advance case for rainforest conservation in Borneo
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:3/2/2017)... 2, 2017 Summary This report provides ... its partnering interests and activities since 2010. ... Read the full report: ... since 2010 report provides an in-depth insight into the partnering ... On demand company reports are prepared upon purchase ...
(Date:3/2/2017)... Australia , March 2, 2017 Australian ... Ltd (ASX: CYP), has signed an agreement with ... from the Monash Biomedicine Discovery Institute and Department of ... to conduct a further preclinical study to support the ... treatment of asthma.  Asthma is a ...
(Date:2/28/2017)... , February 28, 2017 News solutions for ... ... from 14 to 16 March, Materna will present ... show how seamless travel is a real benefit for passengers. ... biometrics to their passenger touch point solutions to take passengers through ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:3/23/2017)... March 23, 2017 Kineta, Inc., a ... novel therapies in immuno-oncology, today announced the discovery ... molecule compounds that activate interferon response factor 3 ... demonstrate immune-mediated tumor regression in a murine colon ... who demonstrated complete tumor regression to initial drug ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... New York , March 23, 2017 ... blood plasma products and derivatives market is fragmented due to the presence ... players, such as Proliant, Thermo Fisher , and Sigma-Aldrich, compete ... leader, these three companies, collectively, held more than 76% of this ... ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... YORK , March 23, 2017 ... look at four equities in the Biotech industry: Sangamo ... Synthetic Biologics Inc. (NYSE MKT: SYN), and Regulus Therapeutics ... 21 st , 2017, Credit Suisse upgraded its rating on ... by downloading their free report at: ...
(Date:3/22/2017)... TARRYTOWN, N.Y. , March 22, 2017 Regeneron ... among the Regeneron Genetics Center (RGC), U.K. Biobank and GSK ... in the U.K. Biobank resource. The initiative will enable researchers ... of new medicines for a wide range of serious and ... ...
Breaking Biology Technology: