Navigation Links
Evolving to fight epidemics: Weakness can be an advantage
Date:3/30/2012

When battling a deadly parasite epidemic, less resistance can sometimes be better than more, a new study suggests.

A freshwater zooplankton species known as Daphnia dentifera endures periodic epidemics of a virulent yeast parasite that can infect more than 60 percent of the Daphnia population.

During these epidemics, the Daphnia population evolves quickly, balancing infection resistance and reproduction.

A new study reveals that the number of vertebrate predators in the water and the amount of food available for Daphnia to eat influence the size of the epidemics and how these "water fleas" evolve during epidemics to survive.

The journal Science published the results in this week's issue. The National Science Foundation (NSF) and the James S. McDonnell Foundation supported the research.

"This study is a great example of why the most obvious response to disease, increased resistance, may not be the best solution," says Saran Twombly, program director in NSF's Division of Environmental Biology.

"When populations are stressed by other factors such as food or predators, remaining susceptible to a disease is the best route to long-term success."

The study shows lakes with high nutrient concentrations and lower predation levels exhibit large epidemics, and the yeast in the water, Metschnikowia bicuspidata, has less effect on Daphnia as the Daphnia become more resistant to infection.

However, in lakes with fewer resources and high predation, epidemics remain small and Daphnia evolve increased susceptibility to the parasite.

"It's counterintuitive to think that hosts would ever evolve greater susceptibility to virulent parasites during an epidemic, but we found that ecological factors determine whether it is better for them to evolve enhanced resistance or susceptibility to infection," said the paper's lead author Meghan Duffy, a biologist at Georgia Tech.

"There is a trade-off between resistance and reproduction because any resources an animal devotes to defense are not available for reproduction. When ecological factors favor small epidemics, it is better for hosts to invest in reproduction rather than defense."

In addition to Duffy, also contributing to this study are Indiana University biologists Spencer Hall and David Civitello; Christopher Klausmeier, a plant biologist at Michigan State University; and Georgia Tech researchers Jessica Housley Ochs and Rachel Penczykowski.

For the study, the researchers monitored the levels of nutritional resources, predation and parasitic infection in seven Indiana lakes on a weekly basis for a period of four months.

They calculated infection prevalence on live hosts using established survey methods, estimated resources by measuring the levels of phosphorus and nitrogen in the water, and assessed predation by measuring the size of uninfected adult Daphnia.

The researchers also conducted infection assays in the laboratory on Daphnia collected from each of the seven lake populations at two time points: in late July before epidemics began and in mid-November as epidemics waned

The assays measured the zooplankton's uptake of Metschnikowia bicuspidata and the infectivity of the yeast once consumed.

The infection assays showed a significant evolutionary response of Daphnia to epidemics in six of the seven lake populations.

The Daphnia population became significantly more resistant to infection in three lakes and significantly more susceptible to infection in three other lakes.

The hosts in the seventh lake did not show a significant change in susceptibility, but trended toward increased resistance.

In the six lake populations that showed an evolutionary response, epidemics were larger when lakes had lower predation and higher levels of total nitrogen.

"Daphnia became more susceptible to the yeast in lakes with fewer resources and higher vertebrate predation, but evolved toward increased resistance in lakes with increased resources and lower predation," says Duffy.

The study's combination of observations, experiments and mathematical modeling supports the researchers' theoretical prediction that when hosts face a resistance-reproduction tradeoff, they evolve increased resistance to infection during larger epidemics and increased susceptibility during smaller ones.

Ultimately, ecological gradients, through their effects on epidemic size, influence evolutionary outcomes of hosts during epidemics.

"While the occurrence and magnitude of disease outbreaks can strongly influence host evolution, this study suggests that altering predation pressure on hosts and productivity of ecosystems may also influence this evolution," says Duffy.

The team plans to repeat the study this summer in the same Indiana lakes to look at whether the relationships between ecological factors, epidemic size and host evolution they found in this study can be corroborated.


'/>"/>

Contact: Cheryl Dybas
cdybas@nsf.gov
703-292-7734
National Science Foundation
Source:Eurekalert  

Related biology news :

1. Cheskin Added Value EVP Lee Shupp Discusses Evolving Dynamics of Consumers and Imaging Tech at 6Sight
2. Quickly evolving bacteria could improve digestive health
3. Beyond Darwin: Evolving new functions
4. Reports highlight the evolving role of clinical microbiology laboratories
5. Fast-evolving genes control developmental differences in social insects
6. British butterfly is evolving to respond to climate change
7. Vitiligo skin disorder could yield clues in fight against melanoma
8. Plant-eating predator to fight superweed is not magic bullet
9. UCSB study finds physical strength, fighting ability revealed in human faces
10. Scripps Florida scientists awarded $1.5M to fight major water and food parasites
11. A new weapon in the fight against obesity and diabetes
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Evolving to fight epidemics: Weakness can be an advantage
(Date:2/28/2017)... February 28, 2017 News solutions for biometrics, ... ... from 14 to 16 March, Materna will present its ... how seamless travel is a real benefit for passengers. To ... to their passenger touch point solutions to take passengers through the ...
(Date:2/26/2017)...  Securus Technologies, a leading provider of civil ... investigation, corrections and monitoring, announces the appointment of ... "Too often, too many offenders return to jail ... trying to tackle this ongoing problem and improve ... members. While significant steps are underway, Securus continues to ...
(Date:2/21/2017)... PORTLAND, Ore. , Feb. 22, 2017 /PRNewswire/ ... of Companies (Avamere Health Services, Infinity Rehab, Signature Hospice, ... study that will apply the power of IBM cognitive ... and health centers. By analyzing data streaming from sensors ... into physical and environmental conditions, and obtain deeper learnings ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:3/22/2017)... , March 22, 2017  Ascendis Pharma ... its innovative TransCon technology to address significant unmet ... results for the full year ended December 31, ... year for our company as we broadened our ... leading, integrated rare disease company with an initial ...
(Date:3/22/2017)... 22, 2017   iSpecimen ®, the ... Doctors Pathology Service (DPS), a full-service anatomic pathology ... the United States , has joined a program ... Network (DHIN) to make human biospecimens and associated ... novel program, announced in 2015 as a collaboration between ...
(Date:3/22/2017)... CAMBRIDGE, Mass. , March 22, 2017   ... of next-generation cancer therapeutics designed to target cancer stemness ... Patricia S. Andrews as Chief Executive Officer, ... will succeed Chiang J. Li , M.D., FACP, ... company ten years ago. Under his leadership, Boston Biomedical ...
(Date:3/22/2017)... ... March 21, 2017 , ... Proper glycosylation is critical ... desired increase and/or decrease in antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity or complement-dependent cytotoxicity, there is ... antibodies. , To meet this demand, the team at SCIEX has developed ...
Breaking Biology Technology: