Navigation Links
Ecologists question effects of climate change on infectious diseases
Date:4/1/2009

Recent research has predicted that climate change may expand the scope of human infectious diseases. A new review, however, argues that climate change may have a negligible effect on pathogens or even reduce their ranges. The paper has sparked debate in the ecological community.

In a forum in the April issue of Ecology, Kevin Lafferty of the U.S. Geological Survey's Western Ecological Research Center suggests that instead of a net expansion in the global range of diseases, climate change may cause poleward range shifts in the areas suitable for diseases as higher latitudes become warmer and regions near the equator become too hot.

The newly suitable areas for diseases will tend to be in more affluent regions where medicines are in widespread use and can more readily combat the diseases, Lafferty says. He cites model estimations that the most dangerous kind of malaria will gain 23 million human hosts outside of its current range by the year 2050, but will lose 25 million in its current range.

"The dramatic contraction of malaria during a century of warming suggests that economic forces might be just as important as climate in determining pathogen ranges," Lafferty says.

Mercedes Pascual of the University of Michigan sees the situation very differently. Pascual is the lead author of one of five Forum papers published in response to Lafferty. Although she agrees that disease expansion in some areas could be accompanied by retraction in others, she emphasizes that disease range does not always correlate with the number of humans infected. In regions of Africa and South America, for example, humans have historically settled in high latitudes and altitudes. If climate change makes these areas more fit for mosquito breeding and for pathogen development, she writes, then a number of infections could expand. She notes that scientists are already seeing evidence of this pattern.

"It would be very unfortunate if the conclusions in Lafferty's paper were taken as evidence that climate change does not matter to infectious diseases," Pascual says. "Range shifts will matter and should be better understood."

Lafferty agrees that range shifts mean there will be winners and losers among human populations. Knowing how disease ranges will shift, instead of assuming a global expansion of diseases, will be the key to distributing resources effectively, he says.

Scientists have used the fact that infectious diseases are most prevalent in the tropics to argue that warmer, wetter conditions that might occur under climate change would lead to an increase in infectious disease transmission. However, Lafferty points out that climate change isn't making the whole world warmer and wetter: Warming trends over the last 60 years have led instead to an increase in hot, dry, desert-like climates. Further, he says, infectious diseases don't all increase during warm, wet weather. Meningitis peaks during the tropical dry season, for example, and influenza is an obvious staple of winter weather in temperate climes.

Pascual argues, however, that humans have a history of altering the landscape to suit their needs and thus might unintentionally create better habitat for disease carriers. For example, humans seldom leave accessible arid areas alone; instead, they irrigate them for use as farmlands. According to Pascual, the creation of water sources could provide havens for mosquitoes, and thus malaria parasites, to remain in areas that would otherwise dry out.

"We live in a world in which urban and rural areas are increasingly interfacing with each other," says Pascual. "This underscores the challenges for predicting the Earth's changing environment."

Lafferty agrees that climate isn't the only issue that affects disease ecology, and maintains that climate may play only a small part in determining disease ranges.

"If we over-emphasize the role of climate, which we have little control over, at the expense of other factors that drive disease dynamics, we may be missing the forest for the trees," he says.


'/>"/>

Contact: Christine Buckley
christine@esa.org
202-833-8773
Ecological Society of America
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Ecologists report quantifiable measures of natures services to humans
2. Ecologists use oceanographic data to predict future climate change
3. Ecologists say metabolism accounts for why natural selection favors only some species
4. Studies of small water fleas help ecologists understand population dynamics
5. Biofuels and biodiversity dont mix, ecologists warn
6. Ecologists tease out private lives of plants and their pollinators
7. Ecologists, material scientists pursue genetics of diatoms elegant, etched casing
8. Ecologists discover city is uber-forest for big owls
9. Mountain on Mars may answer big question
10. New models question old assumptions about how many molecules it takes to control cell division
11. Similar survival rates for Pacific salmon in Fraser, Columbia Rivers raises new questions
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:11/30/2016)... Nov. 30, 2016  higi SH llc (higi) ... initiative targeting national brands, industry thought-leaders and celebrity ... respective audiences for taking steps to live healthier, ... in 2012, higi has built the largest self-screening ... 38 million people who have conducted over 185 ...
(Date:11/29/2016)... , Nov. 29, 2016   Neurotechnology ... and object recognition technologies, today released FingerCell ... fingerprint recognition solutions that run on low-power, ... template using less than 128KB of memory, ... devices that have limited on-board resources, such ...
(Date:11/28/2016)... -- "The biometric system market projected ... biometric system market is in the growth stage and ... The biometric system market is expected to be valued ... of 16.79% between 2016 and 2022. Government initiative in ... smartphones, rising use of biometric technology in financial institutes ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:12/9/2016)... (PRWEB) , ... December 09, 2016 , ... There’s a ... for 2016 by the Orange County Register, after winning the award last year as ... a sought-after employer. President and COO Daniel Vesely pointed to the tech company’s upbeat ...
(Date:12/9/2016)... 9, 2016  A platform of orthopedic device technologies ... one step closer to becoming viable options for ... Inc., a start-up company from Philadelphia, ... for these novel absorbable bone fixation and regenerative ... commercial use. The company has leased space within ...
(Date:12/8/2016)... -- The Board of Directors of the Pittsburgh Life ... only pure life sciences investment firm, today announced ... plan developed by the Nominating and Governance Committee over ... F. Jordan is selected to serve as President ... , who is elected to the position of Executive ...
(Date:12/8/2016)... Philadelphia, PA (PRWEB) , ... December 08, 2016 ... ... fan engagement platforms, the business of innovation is taking over sports. On Thursday, ... executive will explore how technology is disrupting the playing field at a Smart ...
Breaking Biology Technology: