Navigation Links
Deforestation remedies can have unintended consequences, UF researchers say
Date:7/2/2014

GAINESVILLE, Fla. --- When it comes to fixing deforestation and forest degradation, good intentions can lead to bad outcomes.

That's the take-away from a new study by two University of Florida researchers who say efforts to restore damaged and destroyed tropical forests can go awry if the people making the plans of action don't choose wisely.

"We need to be careful about what is it we're losing and gaining," UF biology professor Francis E. "Jack" Putz said. Putz worked with UF biology professor Claudia Romero on the paper, which will appear in the July issue of Biotropica.

Deforestation continues at a rapid pace in much of South America, Southeast Asia and the Congo Basin. Similarly, escaped agricultural fires and uncontrolled logging harm huge areas of tropical forest around the world. That destruction is linked to loss of habitat for wildlife, soil erosion and even accelerated climate change. Estimates of how much land is deforested run as high as 18 million acres a year an area nearly as large as South Carolina and a similarly large area is degraded.

The people deciding what to do in those areas range from villagers to large landowners to global stakeholders. Options include letting the forests recover naturally, assisting natural regeneration, or planting new trees so as to make the areas more wildlife-friendly and biodiversity-rich but each comes at a cost, Putz said.

So, when developing forest access and use policies, people need to consider several factors, including short- and long-term financial profits, biodiversity and local needs for timber and non-timber forest products such as medicinal plants. The authors say it's possible to minimize environmental impacts if decision-makers pay attention to ecosystem structure, composition and dynamics. They shouldn't base everything on a single statistic, such as the total land area occupied by forest, especially if the state of that forest is not specified.

The authors point out that even when there's technically no net deforestation, tropical forests can still suffer. For example, if degraded natural forests are replaced by plantations of invasive exotic trees or low water-use efficiency trees, biodiversity will diminish, wildlife could suffer and soil erosion could render streams unusable by local villagers.

"When you save a forest from deforestation, it's great, but you might not have gotten the full package of what you wanted," he said.

The discussion, Putz said, needs to center on the definition of "forest." The Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations describes it as an area of more than 0.5 hectares, or a little more than an acre, with trees taller than about 16 feet and more than 10 percent canopy cover. Using that definition could obscure great losses of forest values, he said.

In general, the benefits of a forest are jeopardized when land-use decisions are based on that overly loose classification, according to the paper.

Under that designation, for example, tree plantations qualify as forests. Although plantations can supply services to society such as slope stabilization, firewood and carbon, they can also result in avoidable losses of biodiversity. They have less value in some ways, Putz said, and more value in others.

But once people differentiate among types of forests, alternatives to environmentally destructive management will become real options. Then, decision-makers can fully examine the local, regional and global benefits of natural forests versus their economic priorities.

"We need to demand clarity about what's meant by 'forest' and what the full range of costs are of different interventions," Putz said. "Then we need to figure out the mechanism to get decision-makers to employ the interventions that are least damaging to naturalness but that still satisfy their other desires."


'/>"/>

Contact: Francis E. Putz
fep@ufl.edu
352-392-1486
University of Florida
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Incentives as effective as penalties for slowing Amazon deforestation
2. Study: Deforestation could intensify climate change in Congo Basin by half
3. Deforestation of sandy soils a greater climate threat
4. More logging, deforestation may better serve climate in some areas
5. Amazon deforestation brings loss of microbial communities
6. Deforestation in the Amazon equals net losses of diversity for microbial communities
7. Time, place and how wood is used are factors in carbon emissions from deforestation
8. First tests of old patent medicine remedies from a museum collection
9. Stanford professor maps by-catch as unintended consequence of global fisheries
10. Using geometry, researchers coax human embryonic stem cells to organize themselves
11. NIH-funded researchers extend liver preservation for transplantation
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:4/13/2016)... 2016  IMPOWER physicians supporting Medicaid patients in ... clinical standard in telehealth thanks to a new partnership ... platform, IMPOWER patients can routinely track key health measurements, ... index, and, when they opt in, share them with ... a local retail location at no cost. By leveraging ...
(Date:3/22/2016)... , March 22, 2016 ... report "Electronic Sensors Market for Consumer Industry by Type ... Others), Application (Communication & IT, Entertainment, Home ... Global Forecast to 2022", published by MarketsandMarkets, ... expected to reach USD 26.76 Billion by ...
(Date:3/15/2016)... , March 15, 2016 ... report published by Transparency Market Research "Digital Door Lock Systems ... Forecast 2015 - 2023," the global digital door lock systems ... Mn in 2014 and is forecast to grow at a ... of micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) across the world ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:5/25/2016)... (PRWEB) , ... May 25, 2016 , ... Lady had ... she tore her cruciate ligament in her left knee. Lady’s owner Hannah sought the ... central Florida board-certified veterinary surgeon, to repair her cruciate ligament and help with the ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... ... May 24, 2016 , ... Media ... The new Media Cybernetics corporate branding reflects a results-driven revitalization for a company ... analysis. The re-branding components include a crisp, refreshed logo and a new web ...
(Date:5/23/2016)... and LONDON , May 23, 2016 ... Could See Frontage Boost Efficiency by 40% - Frontage ... - Frontage Enforce Quality, Compliance and Traceability Within the Bioanalytical ... with labs in the United States and ... to be deployed across its laboratory facilities. In addition to ...
(Date:5/20/2016)... ... May 20, 2016 , ... Kablooe Design, a leading provider of product ... official 25th anniversary of the business. “We have worked hard to build long-term relationships,” ... for the privilege and honor of serving their product design and development needs through ...
Breaking Biology Technology: