Navigation Links
Credit allocation among researchers determined by new algorithm
Date:8/15/2014

A new algorithm developed at Northeastern'sCenter for Complex Network Researchhelps sheds light on how to properly allocatecredit.

The research was published this month inProceedings of the National Academy of Sciencesin a paper co-​​authored by Hua-​​Wei Shen, a visiting scholar at Northeastern and associate professor at the Institute of Computing Technology at the Chinese Academy of Sciences, and Albert-​​Lszl Barabsi, the Robert Gray Dodge Professor of Network Science and a Distinguished University Professor at Northeastern.

Using the algorithm, which Shen developed, the team revealed a new credit allocation system based on how often the paper is co-​​cited with the other papers published by the paper's co-​​authors, capturing the authors' additional contributions to thefield.

"The idea behind this is that based on an author's previous line of work, people have a perception of where the credit lies," explained Barabsi, the director of theCenter for Complex Network Research. "And the algorithm's goal is simply to extract that perception."

To test its hypothesis, the team looked at Nobel prize-​​winning papers in which the Nobel committee and the science community decided to whom the primary credit for a discovery should go. In 81 percent of the papers related to physics, chemistry, and medicine that they looked at, the credit allocation algorithm found that the authors deserving of the most credit corresponded to the Nobel laureate.

In all, the team looked at 63 prize-​​winning papers using the algorithm. In another finding, the algorithm showed physicist Tom Kibble, who in 1964 wrote a research paper on the Higgs boson theory, should receive the same amount of credit as Nobel prize winners Peter Higgs and Franois Englert.

A world-​​​​renowned network scientist, Barabsi has joint appointments in theCollege of Scienceand theCollege of Computer and Information Scienceat Northeastern. The paper builds upon his research in the science of success, which uses a mathematical model for quantifying the long-​​term success of individual researchers.

Barabsi explained that the traditional system of credit allocation varies depending on the field of research, and being the first author listed on a paper does not mean that person would receive the most credit. In biology, for example, the authors listed first and last on a paper are generally the one's who receive credit while in physics the author list is often alphabetical.

"If you are not an insider in the field, you have absolutely no idea who should get the credit for the paper," Barabsi said.

While the science community is usually correct when allocating credit to authors, sometimes credit can go to the wrong person. In their paper, the researchers wrote that "the ability to accurately measure the relative credit of researchers could potentially impact hiring, funding, and promotions."

Barabsi also noted this new algorithm could help professors from different disciplines who collaborate on a research paper determine to whom the community would credit thepaper.


'/>"/>

Contact: Emily Bhatti
e.bhatti@neu.edu
617-373-3287
Northeastern University
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Press accreditation opens for World Series of Science
2. Service Credit Union Selects DigitalPersona to Secure Access to Network and Applications
3. Press accreditation for World Series of Science
4. Flashback Data Remains Only Non-Governmental Digital Forensics Lab with ASCLD/LAB International Accreditation
5. Advantages for Digital Wallets Eliminate Need to Carry Credit Cards - Large Scale CNBC Ad Campaign for Latest Smart Wallet to Commence July 7th
6. Consumer Needs for Identity Theft Security Grows with Popularity of Latest Smart Technology Products - Biometrically Secure Digital Wallet to Replace Credit Card Dependency
7. Scientists identify prostate cancer stem cells among low-PSA cells
8. New study published on fertility awareness among American university students
9. Considerable prevalence of both malaria, STIs exist among pregnant women in sub-Saharan Africa
10. Levels of hepatitis C virus higher among African-Americans and males
11. RedBrick Health Launches Open Integration and Partner Certification Program, Selects Fitbit, RunKeeper Among First to be "RedBrick Ready"
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/6/2017)... 6, 2017 According to Acuity Market ... border authorities to continue to embrace biometric and ... 2143 Automated Border Control (ABC) eGates and 1436 ... more than 163 ports of entry across the ... achieving a combined CAGR of 37%. APC Kiosks ...
(Date:2/2/2017)... 2017  Central to its deep commitment to ... The Japan Prize Foundation today announced the laureates ... the envelope in their respective fields of Life ... are being recognized with the 2017 Japan Prize ... contribute to the advancement of science and technology, ...
(Date:1/26/2017)... -- Acuity Market Intelligence today released the 2017 "Ten ... characterizes 2017 as a "breakout" year for biometrics ... new understanding of the potential benefits these technologies ... are often perceived as threats to privacy and ... Acuity Market intelligence. "However, taken together these technologies ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:2/24/2017)... ... February 24, 2017 , ... FireflySci, Inc is an explosive small business ... had the goal of bringing their powerful cuvette and spectrophotometer calibration to ... that FireflySci is going on as they add yet another mark on the global ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... RAFAEL, Calif., Feb. 23, 2017 ... U.S. dollars, except per share data, unaudited)Three Months Ended ... ChangeTotal BioMarin Revenue $   ...   22832%$ 1,117$   89026%Aldurazyme Net Product Revenue ... 906538%34823946%Naglazyme Net Product Revenue  ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... Feb. 23, 2017  Seattle,s upscale Capitol Hill neighborhood, with its ... place for a head lice treatment salon to set up ... Tuscan restaurant and a French bistro on E Madison Ave, ... aren,t just any old lice clinic, we pride ourselves on ... and release some of the stigma associated with lice. Everyone ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... February 23, 2017 , ... ... insulin, cortisol, CRP, adiponectin, uric acid, and/or other biomarkers or SNPs of interest) ... from Salimetrics’ SalivaLab , the relationship between insulin and other relevant biomarkers ...
Breaking Biology Technology: