Navigation Links
Controversial dam removals founded on value conflicts

Researchers at Ume University in Sweden conclude that public opposition to dam removal is not based on knowledge deficiency, as is sometimes argued in dam removal science. It is instead a case of different understandings and valuation of the environment and the functions it provides. The findings are now published in the journal Ecology and Society.

Dam removal is an increasingly common practice as old splash dams and small hydropower dams have become obsolete. Although the removal of these dams has ecological benefits by restoring rivers to their former courses, local residents sometimes contest dam removals.

"We wanted to understand how the proponents and opponents of dam removal think about the function of two contrasting ecosystems an existing dam with a pond and a potential running stream without the pond. The local people who fight to have a dam remain in place have often been dismissed as unknowledgeable," says Dolly Jrgensen, environmental historian at the Department of Ecology and Environmental Science.

Together with ecologist Birgitta Malm-Renflt, she investigated the types of arguments made for and against dam removal in newspaper articles about dams in the Swedish towns Alby, Hallstahammar, Orsa, and Tallsen.

They found that those who want to remove the dam place a high value on the return of game fish to the ecosystem, recreational fishing, and restoration in general. Opponents want the dam to remain because of recreational opportunities for bathing and beaches, the aesthetics of the pond's still water, and the cultural heritage of the pond and the historic dam.

"The public opposition is not based on knowledge deficiency, where more information would lead to better ecological decision-making. The locals simply value different aspects of the environment than scientists or environmentalists that want the dam removed, " says Dolly Jrgensen.

As the number of dam removal projects continues to grow in Sweden and other places in the world, controversies are likely to become more common. Because a decision to remove or keep the dam will result in one side losing the ecosystem services they value, compromise solutions may be difficult to reach.


Contact: Dolly Jrgensen
Umea University

Related biology news :

1. Sickle cell trait can cause sudden cardiac death in black athletes: Why is this controversial?
2. Study confirms prognostic value of new IASLC/ATS/ERS adenocarcinoma sub-classification
3. Is the detection of early markers of Epstein Barr virus of diagnostic value?
4. Cross Match Technologies Undoubtedly Offers the Highest Value to Customers in the North American Biometrics Market, Says Frost & Sullivan
5. Reproducibility Initiative to increase the value of biomedical research
6. Family values
7. Boston Healthcare Associates Roundtable Explores Challenges and Opportunities Surrounding the Value of Big Data within the Life Sciences
8. Womens scientific achievements often overlooked and undervalued
9. Medical device, health professionals attend first national conference on value-driven engineering
10. New research predicts rising trend in Indias Violent Land Conflicts; 130 districts struggle
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Controversial dam removals founded on value conflicts
(Date:9/24/2015)... Publiceringsförbud fram till: ... Kerv ( ), det Londonbaserade ... första kontaktlösa betalningsring på i ett ... för massproduktion via crowdfunding.       ... Kerv-bärare kan göra direkta kontaktlösa betalningar ...
(Date:9/10/2015)... Report Details The global wearable technology market ... of revenues, consumer adoption and even technological advances. However, ... begin to achieve that mass market acceptance that has ... the entrance of Apple to the SmartWatches market, which ... overall size of the wearable technology market. Visiongain ...
(Date:9/9/2015)... , Sept. 9, 2015  NuData Security ... and solution-based milestones, furthering the company,s commitment to ... online fraud. NuData Security,s online fraud ... the company,s growth cycle. The product combines continual ... determine good user behavior from fraudulent behavior, allowing ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:10/12/2015)... , Oct. 12, 2015  Rebiotix Inc. ... (FDA) has designated its lead Microbiota Restoration Therapy ... treatment of recurrent Clostridium difficile (C ... infection that causes 29,000 deaths in the U.S. ... biotechnology company that was founded to revolutionize the ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... octubre de 2015 El 8 de octubre, ... récord en el congreso con su declaración acerca del ... Plasma Awareness Week (IPAW), que se celebrará del 11 ... la Plasma Protein Therapeutics Association (PPTA) y ... , Aumentar la concienciación mundial acerca de la donación ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... Oct. 12, 2015  Patara Pharma, a clinical-stage ... inflammatory diseases and conditions, today announced the closing ... financing. Concurrent with the close of its sale ... Loan and Security Agreement with Silicon Valley Bank ... million. Patara will use the funds from the ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... October 12, 2015 ... version for enriched online experience --> ... to print version for enriched online experience ... media alternative to print version for enriched online ... of scientific, technical and medical information products and services, ...
Breaking Biology Technology: