Navigation Links
Communication trumps penalties in new study of social-ecological systems

TEMPE, Ariz. Research conducted in a computerized microworld by scientists at Arizona State University and Indiana University, including Nobel laureate Elinor Ostrom, show how common-pool resources such as fisheries, forests, water systems or even bandwidth can be managed effectively by self-organized user groups under certain conditions.

The findings are published April 30 in the journal Science.

"We use different experiments with specially designed computer simulation games that include costly fines, communication, a combination of both and a period where neither punishment nor communication is allowed. These experiments help us identify which variables increase the level of cooperation," says Marco Janssen, social science modeler at the School of Human Evolution and Social Change in ASU's College of Liberal Arts and Sciences and the study's lead author.

The experiments involve a timed computer game played simultaneously by college students in a lab. The students sit in individual cubicles and have their own avatars in the game. They go about individually "harvesting" a resource in this case, colored dots in an experimental environment, along with the other players. If they harvest them too fast, the resource runs out and the game ends. If they manage them sustainably, the dots regenerate, allowing them to harvest more and earn more points. The more points the students have, the more they are paid real dollars at the end, creating an incentive for them to take the game seriously, explains Janssen.

To do well requires the participants to monitor their own behavior, but also to be mindful of what the others are doing, Janssen notes. In some cases, the players are allowed a brief opportunity to communicate via chat rooms to strategize and make decisions regarding where and when to harvest resources, or collect tokens. They also determine whether or not to impose costly fines for overuse of resources by a member of the group, and when to sanction a player.

"Spatial and temporal resource dynamics were included in our laboratory experiments in order to capture these two critical variables," adds Janssen. He explains that adding the space and time complexity component to their experiments illustrated that stronger governance of common-pool resources does not always result in better harvesting.

This finding is contrary to the classic view of options regarding how to manage common resources, such as those based on Garrett Hardin's famed example of the "tragedy of the commons" the basis for much of the world's policies for managing resources.

When participants make decisions without communicating, they overharvest, notes co-author Ostrom, founding director of ASU's Center for the Study of Institutional Diversity and a professor of political science in Indiana University's College of Arts and Sciences.

When given a chance to communicate, however, participants improve their joint outcomes greatly and the effect is lasting even when communication is no longer possible, she says, adding, that being able to use costly fines against each other did not improve harvest output.

"This study presents results from a more complex experimental setting than previous laboratory experiments on public goods or common-pool resources. Since we conduct field research as well as experimental research we wanted to develop a more realistic setting than has been feasible in the past to assess how individuals cope with both the complexity and the temptations to overuse," says Ostrom, recipient of the 2009 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.

Other co-authors of the study "Lab Experiments for the Study of Social-Ecological Systems" are Allen Lee, a research at ASU, and IU doctoral student Robert Holahan.

According to Lee, more than 400 students at both universities participated in the experiments.

"With the ability to communicate, the students almost invariably cooperate with each other and improve their earnings by coming up with their own rules to govern how they harvest from the resource. The only time it breaks down is when there are one or two members in the group that disregard the rules they came up with," says Lee.

A next step is to take the sophisticated simulation games used in the experiments and convert them into educational games for youth.

"My hope is the games will get the next generation to think more deeply about the pressing social-ecological problems we are facing, and what it takes to manage resources sustainably," Lee adds. "Rather than just be entertained, it would be fantastic if the experience from the games ultimately led them to take action."


Contact: Carol Hughes
Arizona State University

Related biology news :

1. Eating disorders, obesity and communications experts tackle weighty matters
2. BIO-key(R) International Taps JMR Worldwide for PR, IR and Strategic Communications
3. Study suggests environment may impact apes ability to understand declarative communication
4. Leading entomologist to give talk at UCR on communication and cooperation in ant societies
5. Communication breakdown: what happens to nerve cells in Parkinsons disease
6. Communication problems in the brain
7. Media source impacts ag biotech communication
8. Academies announce winners of 2009 Communication Awards
9. New book teaches core skills needed to create professional scientific communications
10. Science communication to take the stage at annual AAAS meeting in San Francisco
11. Animal and plant communication at the ESA Annual Meeting
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Communication trumps penalties in new study of social-ecological systems
(Date:10/13/2015)... Research and Markets ( ) has announced the ... Market - Estimation & Forecast (2015-2020)" report to ... --> The biometric market value is anticipated to ... in 2020 at an estimated CAGR of 16.47% from ... . Growing digitization in the government sector is expected ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... -- NXTD ) ("NXT-ID" or the "Company"), a ... reports on the recent SNS Future in Review Conference in ... NXTD ) ("NXT-ID" or the "Company"), a biometric authentication company ... recent SNS Future in Review Conference in Park ... NXTD ) ("NXT-ID" or the "Company"), a biometric authentication ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... October 8, 2015 NXT-ID, ... "Company"), a biometric authentication company focused on the ... Wocket® smart wallet announces that revenues for the ... $410,000 compared with $113,00 for the three months ... months ended September 30, 2015 were approximately $520,000. ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... ... Proove Biosciences, a commercial and research leader ... Medicine of the University of Southern California (USC) Pain Center to study ... Clinical Objectives Linking Genotypic and Phenotypic Association with Pain Outcomes) is one of ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... Calif. and BRUSSELS , Oct. ... (Euronext Brussels: UCB) today presented additional findings from an exploratory ... The findings were presented today in an oral plenary ... (ASBMR) 2015 Annual Meeting in Seattle . ... --> The small exploratory sub-study data showed ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... , Oct. 12, 2015 This report covers ... include cell type, products, applications, end-user markets and geographic ... HIGHLIGHTS The global cell expansion market generated revenue ... to reach revenues of $9.7 billion in 2015 and ... rate (CAGR) of 17.8% from 2015 to 2020. ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... octubre de 2015 El 8 de octubre, ... récord en el congreso con su declaración acerca del ... Plasma Awareness Week (IPAW), que se celebrará del 11 ... la Plasma Protein Therapeutics Association (PPTA) y ... , Aumentar la concienciación mundial acerca de la donación ...
Breaking Biology Technology: