Navigation Links
Comments by the International Scientific Forum on Alcohol Research
Date:2/17/2012

Summary: In 2008, the NHMRC commissioned the Dieticians Association of Australia to undertake systematic literature reviews to support the revision of the Dietary Guidelines for Australians. The primary aim was to undertake a series of systematic reviews of the national and international literature from the year 2002 on the food-diet-health-disease inter-relationship for different population subgroups. One of the 29 sections in the report (pp 613-678) covered the evidence for the risks and benefits of alcohol drinking. This critique is only of the alcohol section.

Forum Comments:

On balance the authors should be commended on their work. Our criticisms are primarily about the restriction in the time frame of the review, and minimal consideration of key nuances, such as quantity of alcohol consumed and its relation to risk or benefit, patterns of drinking, the balance between risks and benefits, and making statements at all when the evidence is too weak. More details (e.g. considering cardiovascular mechanisms to widen the search) would have added weight to the conclusions.

Specific comments:

1.The search methodology used to create this review is well done and fits with best practice.

2.The authors need to be commended on adopting a balanced view toward alcohol by considering both positive and negative health effects of alcohol.

3.This lack of overt bias may have been due to the fact that all reviewers appear to have been dieticians. That may of course have introduced an inherent unknown bias from the fact that no other health disciplines had input into the process.

4.An unintended bias may have been introduced by the reliance on the 2007 WCRF/ACIR study. Although the methodology and process may have appeared the same, without the reviewers of this study's direct involvement there is always a risk that that assumption is incorrect.

5.The review only considered literature from 2002 to 2009. Although thi
'/>"/>

Contact: R. Curtis Ellison
ellison@bu.edu
617-638-8080
Boston University Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. Director of Berman Institute comments on FDA Approval of first human embryonic stem cell trial
2. AMP submits comments on SACGHS report
3. AMP comments at FDA meeting on array-based tests
4. AMP comments at FDA meeting on next-generation sequencing
5. BIO-key(R) International To Exhibit at Oracle OpenWorld
6. Sentara begins international trial -- open at only 24 US locations
7. Perinatal Days and International Stillbirth Conference -- Nov.5-7
8. AVS 55th International Symposium & Exhibition, Oct. 19-24
9. Minnesota ecology professor wins international award for biodiversity and biofuels research
10. International Council for Science launches major research program on natural disasters
11. Innovations in Pediatric Medicine International Conference brings together pediatrics experts
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/17/2014)... Informatics at IMIM (Hospital del Mar Medical Research Institute) ... recently published a study in eLife showing ... in the evolution of new proteins, some of which ... Ribosomes produce proteins from the instructions found in an ... is RNA containing information for the synthesis of proteins, ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... Mich. Mutations in the human retinoblastoma protein gene ... State University scientists have turned to fruit fly eyes ... , In a paper featured on the cover ... Biological Chemistry , Michigan State University researchers provide the ... to those present in the human cancer gene, said ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... decades of decline, grasses have returned to some once-denuded ... marsh in those places seems healthy again, but a ... the marsh coastal protection remains diminished. , ... hasn,t come back," said ecologist Mark Bertness, professor of ... in the journal Biological Conservation . "The metric ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Parts of genome without a known function may play a key role in the birth of new proteins 2Abnormal properties of cancer protein revealed in fly eyes 2Cape Cod saltmarsh recovery looks good, falls short 2Cape Cod saltmarsh recovery looks good, falls short 3
... In order for a gene to create a protein, ... as messenger RNA. These RNA molecules are the instruction manuals ... how to build a protein. A few years ago, scientists ... metabolic products (metabolites) can bind to. In doing so, they ...
... New drugs that are helping fight a multi-front war on ... of Georgia researchers said. Cancer and cardiovascular disease, both ... shock protein 90 inhibitors as a treatment could become additional ... Biology Center. "I think hsp90 inhibitors may be some ...
... David L. Rimoin, MD, PhD, FACMG of Cedars-Sinai ... College of Medical Genetics Foundation (ACMGF) second annual Lifetime ... Dr. Rimoin was recognized for his decades of contributions ... and heritable disorders of connective tissue, and for helping ...
Cached Biology News:Genes under control 2New cancer therapy may fight cardiovascular disease 2Leader in genetics, Dr. David L. Rimoin, receives ACMG Foundation Lifetime Achievement Award 2Leader in genetics, Dr. David L. Rimoin, receives ACMG Foundation Lifetime Achievement Award 3
(Date:9/18/2014)... Scientists at USC have developed a new microscopy ... in living animals at higher-than-ever resolution. , Dubbed ... allows imaging resolutions that are an order of ... insights into the behavior of biomolecules at the ... Sept. 18 by Nature Communications , the ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... Silicon-valley Electronic Data Capture (EDC) provider ... , the latest addition to Clinovo’s CRO Partnership Program. ... (CRO) Program, Clinovo further expands its global reach to ... training, we are now able to build studies on ... can also rely on Clinovo to fully support the ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... New York, NY (PRWEB) September 18, 2014 ... has completed negotiations with Salem Realty Group and has ... and development space within the Salem Executive Complex adjacent ... cutting ceremony was held on Friday September 5th. Whitehouse ... to refit the entire space specifically for package testing. ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... Sept. 17, 2014 The global consumption of squalene ... Squalene is a natural skin-identical chemical that finds applications in ... food supplements, pharmaceuticals, and in other applications like high grade ... has a few major players and is regionally segregated. Sophim ... Liver Oil Co. Ltd. ( Japan ), SeaDragon ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Scientists pioneer microscopy technique that yields fresh data on muscular dystrophy 2Digitaliza TXT Joins Clinovo’s CRO Partnership Program, Bringing Its Open Source EDC System, ClinCapture to Latin America 2Digitaliza TXT Joins Clinovo’s CRO Partnership Program, Bringing Its Open Source EDC System, ClinCapture to Latin America 3Whitehouse Labs Announces Package Testing Laboratory Expansion 2Whitehouse Labs Announces Package Testing Laboratory Expansion 3Whitehouse Labs Announces Package Testing Laboratory Expansion 4Squalene Market by Source (Animal & Vegetable) & by End-user Industry (Cosmetics, Pharmaceuticals & Food Industry) - Global Trends & Forecasts to 2019 2Squalene Market by Source (Animal & Vegetable) & by End-user Industry (Cosmetics, Pharmaceuticals & Food Industry) - Global Trends & Forecasts to 2019 3
... Third Quarter Highlights Recognized ... from Department of Defense (DoD) for nerve agent medical countermeasure ... profit split on worldwide sales of ST-246 and related products ... Completed 1500L commercial scale-up and first cGMP manufacturing run ...
... 8, 2011 Orexigen® Therapeutics, Inc. (Nasdaq: OREX ... today announced financial results for the third quarter of 2011. ... a net loss of $4.6 million, or $0.10 per share, ... $0.31 per share, for the third quarter of 2010. As ...
... for data-intensive biomedical and genetic research -- is ... team of researchers including Anton Nekrutenko, an associate ... State University; Kateryna Makova, an associate professor of ... Emory University, developed the new technology, which will ...
Cached Biology Technology:PharmAthene Reports Third Quarter 2011 Financial and Operating Results 2PharmAthene Reports Third Quarter 2011 Financial and Operating Results 3PharmAthene Reports Third Quarter 2011 Financial and Operating Results 4PharmAthene Reports Third Quarter 2011 Financial and Operating Results 5PharmAthene Reports Third Quarter 2011 Financial and Operating Results 6PharmAthene Reports Third Quarter 2011 Financial and Operating Results 7PharmAthene Reports Third Quarter 2011 Financial and Operating Results 8Orexigen® Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter Financial Results 2Orexigen® Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter Financial Results 3Orexigen® Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter Financial Results 4Orexigen® Therapeutics Reports Third Quarter Financial Results 5Galaxy DNA-analysis software is now available 'in the cloud' 2Galaxy DNA-analysis software is now available 'in the cloud' 3
... The TUNEL-based assay kit provides complete ... cells for convenient detection of DNA ... sections. The incorporation of BrdU in ... biotinylated or digoxigenylated methods. Results can ...
... ergonomic microscopes are now available in digital ... DM-BA200 comes packed with Motic's patented Colour ... plug and play digital image capture head. ... a reversed quadruple nosepiece, deliver high quality ...
... The Fujifilm Life Science LAS-3000 ... technology with a simplified user interface, ... a wide range of modularities. The ... applications, and the perfect standard system ...
This kit is designed to select cells labeled with biotinylated antibodies. Kit includes reagents for labeling 3 x 10 9 cells and EasySep magnet....
Biology Products: