Navigation Links
Columbia researchers: Growth of CT scan use may lead to significant public health problem

NEW YORK Computed Tomography (CT) scans are an increasingly used X-ray-based tool for providing a three-dimensional view of a particular organ or tissue. The value of CT scanning to diagnose injury, cancer and other health problems is undisputed. But are these scans being used too frequently, in some cases unnecessarily" What are the health consequences of having too many CT scans over the course of a persons life"

In a Nov. 29, 2007 article in The New England Journal of Medicine, David J. Brenner, Ph.D., and Eric J. Hall, Ph.D., from the Center for Radiological Research at Columbia University Medical Center, argue that the potential carcinogenic effects from using CT scans may be underestimated or overlooked. This is of particular concern, because perhaps one-third of all CT scans performed in the United States may not be medically necessary, the radiation researchers say.

It is estimated that more than 62 million CT scans per year are currently given in the United States, compared to three million 1980. Because CT scans result in a far larger radiation exposure compared with conventional plain-film X-ray, this has resulted in a marked increase in the average personal radiation exposure in the United States, which has about doubled since 1980, largely because of the increased CT usage.

It used to be widely believed that all radiological examinations were essentially harmless, because of the small amounts of radiation involved, but Drs. Brenner and Hall show that this is unlikely to be true for CT scans. In particular, Japanese atomic bomb survivors who were about two miles away from the explosions, actually received radiation doses quite similar to those from a CT scan. Sixty years of study of these survivors have provided direct evidence that there will be an increased individual cancer risk, though small, for those who have this same dose of radiation from CT scans. Although the individual risk is small, the large number of CT scans currently being given may result in a future public health problem. In particular, Drs. Brenner and Hall suggest that, in a few decades, about 1 to 2 percent of all cancers in the United States may be due to the radiation from CT scans being done now.

Defensive Medicine Leads to Overuse

Drs. Brenner and Hall suggest that the rapid increase in CT usage represents a potential public health problem in the United States that should be proactively addressed. This is particularly important for children, who are more sensitive than adults to radiation exposure. The issue arises, for example, when CT scans are requested in the context of so-called defensive medicine, or when scans are repeated as a patient passes through different parts of the medical system. Compounding the issue, surveys suggest that the majority of radiologists and emergency-room physicians may not appreciate that CT scans are likely to increase the lifetime risk of cancer. Ultimately, the health care system, the doctor, and the patient (who can perhaps best track of the number of CT scans performed when dealing with multiple doctors) may have to share the burden of monitoring the appropriate dosage and number of scans.

Drs. Brenner and Hall suggest three strategies for proactively addressing the potential increased radiation risks associated with CT scans:

1. Reduce the CT-related radiation dose in individual patients.

2. Replace CT use, when appropriate, with other options that have no radiation risk, such as ultrasound or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

3. Decrease the total number of CT scans prescribed.

Drs. Brenner and Hall suggest in their papers conclusion that these strategies could potentially keep 20 million adults and, crucially, more than one million children annually in the United States from being irradiated unnecessarily. They stress, however, that in the majority of individual cases, the benefits associated with a correct diagnosis through CT will far outweigh the individual risk.


Contact: Alex Lyda
Columbia University Medical Center

Related biology news :

1. Columbia to award 2007 Horwitz Prize to three generations of teacher-student scientists
2. 3 Columbia University Medical Center faculty elected to Institute of Medicine
3. Researchers: No faking it, crocodile tears are real
4. Circadian clock controls plant growth hormone
5. Population movements and money remittances spur forest regrowth
6. Paracetamol, one of most used analgesics, could slow down bone growth
7. Targeting nerve growth factor may cure liver cancer
8. Study shows vitamin C is essential for plant growth
9. Study reveals a key to blood vessel growth and possible drug target
10. Brain cell growth diminishes long before old age strikes, animal study shows
11. Sea cucumbers fast track organ regrowth by healing their wounds
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/30/2015)... Fla. , Nov. 30, 2015  BIOCLAIM ... a finalist in this year,s Fierce Innovation Awards:  Healthcare ... FierceHealthIT , FierceHealthcare ... recognized as a finalist in the category of ... --> --> ...
(Date:11/19/2015)...  Based on its in-depth analysis of the biometric ... the 2015 Global Frost & Sullivan Award for Product ... this award to the company that has developed the ... the market it serves. The award recognizes the extent ... customer base demands, the overall impact it has in ...
(Date:11/18/2015)... 2015 --> ... market report titled  Gesture Recognition Market - Global Industry ... 2021. According to the report, the global gesture recognition market was valued ... reach US$29.1 bn by 2021, at a CAGR of ... America dominated the global gesture recognition market ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:12/1/2015)... ... 01, 2015 , ... Matthew “Tex” VerMilyea, PhD, HCLD, has joined Texas Fertility ... all IVF lab procedures as well as continue his research efforts into the emerging ... to Auckland, New Zealand to bring home a High Complexity Clinical Laboratory Director named ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... , ... November 30, 2015 , ... ... will join physicians, aesthetic practitioners and aesthetics professionals from Central America and abroad ... be held in Panama City, Panama Feb. 17-19, 2016. Testart will present and ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Global ... Practice (GMP) 10000 in the Santiago Marriott. The Global Stem Cells Group GMP ... a world-class team of qualified medical researchers and practitioners, experienced in administering stem ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... interventional radiology technique shows promise for helping morbidly obese patients ... being presented today at the annual meeting of the Radiological ... --> --> Gastric artery ... a way to stop bleeding in emergency situations, but the ... obesity is new. Mubin Syed , M.D., interventional ...
Breaking Biology Technology: