Navigation Links
Co-management holds promise of sustainable fisheries worldwide
Date:1/5/2011

Encouraging new evidence suggests that the bulk of the world's fisheries including small-scale, often non-industrialized fisheries on which millions of people depend for food could be sustained using community-based co-management.

"The majority of the world's fisheries are not and never will be managed by strong centralized governments with top-down rules and the means to enforce them," according to Nicolas Gutirrez, a University of Washington doctoral student in aquatic and fishery sciences who is lead author of a paper that goes online Jan. 5 in the journal Nature. "Our findings show that many community-based co-managed fisheries around the world are well managed under limited central government structure, provided communities of fishers are proactively engaged.

"Community-based co-management is the only realistic solution for the majority of the world's fisheries and is an effective way to sustain aquatic resources and the livelihoods of communities depending on them."

Under such a management system, responsibility for resources is shared between the government and users. On the smallest scale, this might involve mayors and fishers from different villages agreeing to avoid fishing in each other's waters. Examples on a larger scale include Chile's most valuable fishery the snail called "loco," also known as Chilean abalone that started in 1988 with local fishers in a single community cooperating along a 2-mile (4-km) stretch of the coastline and today involves 700 co-managed areas with 20,000 artisanal fishers along 2,500 miles (4,000 km) of coastline.

While case studies of individual co-managed fisheries exist, this new work used data on 130 fisheries in 44 developed and developing nations and included such things as marine and freshwater ecosystems as well as diverse fishing gears and targeted species.

Statistical analysis shows co-management typically fails without such keys things as:

  • Prominent community leadership and social cohesion
  • Clear incentives that, for example, give fishers security over the amount they can catch or the area in which they can fish
  • Protected areas, especially when combined with regulated harvest inside or outside the area, and when the protected area is proposed and monitored by local communities

"Our results show that additional resources should be spent on efforts to identify community leaders and build social capital rather than only imposing management tactics without user involvement," says Gutirrez.

The new study further confirms the theories of Elinor Ostrom, who won a Nobel Prize in economics in 2009 for challenging the conventional wisdom that common property is always poorly managed and should be either regulated by central authorities or privatized. Resource users frequently develop sophisticated mechanisms for decision-making and rule enforcement, she said, to handle conflicts of interest.

"Elinor Ostrom was right," says Omar Defeo, University of Uruguay professor, scientific coordinator of Uruguay's national fishery management program and co-author on the paper. "With community-based co-management, fishers are capable of self organizing, maintaining their resources and achieving sustainable fisheries."

After reading the paper in advance of publication, Ostrom called the work "fabulous" and said, "It was very exciting to see the findings about community cohesion founded on norms, trust, communication, commitment and respect for leaders being the most important attributes leading to successful fisheries co-management."

For the Nature paper, Gutirrez assembled data from scientific literature, government and non-government reports and personal interviews for 130 co-managed fisheries looking to score them on eight outcomes ranging from community empowerment to sustainable catches to increases in abundance of fish and prices of what was caught.

With 40 percent of the fisheries scoring positively on 6, 7 or all 8 outcomes, and another 25 percent scoring positively on 4 or 5 of the outcomes, the co-authors write that community-based co-management "holds great promise for successful and sustainable fisheries worldwide."

Ray Hilborn, UW professor of aquatic and fishery sciences and a co-author on the Nature paper, was also co-author of a paper in Science in 2009 that found that many of the major industrial fisheries and fishery ecosystems were becoming more sustainable.

"This new paper further illustrates the world's growing ability to manage fisheries sustainably and that the tools appropriate for industrial fisheries in countries with strong central governments are quite different from those in small-scale fisheries or countries without strong central governments," he says.

The work was supported by the National Science Foundation, the Fulbright-Organization of American States Ecology Program and Pew Charitable Trusts.


'/>"/>

Contact: Sandra Hines
shines@uw.edu
206-543-2580
University of Washington
Source:Eurekalert  

Related biology news :

1. Globally sustainable fisheries possible with co-management
2. Research identifies type of vaccine that holds promise in protecting against TB
3. Oral rinses used for tracking HPV-positive head and neck cancers holds promise for cancer screening
4. High blood sugars impact on immune system holds clues to improving islet cell transplants
5. New drug holds out promise of normal diet for sufferers of devastating PKU genetic disease
6. Nanotechnology holds promise for STD drug delivery
7. Canadian research breakthrough holds promise for development of effective cancer therapies
8. Energy experts helping Australian households reduce carbon emissions
9. New map of variation in maize genetics holds promise for developing new varieties
10. Orange corn holds promise for reducing blindness, child death
11. New ORNL carbon composite holds promise for bionics
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Co-management holds promise of sustainable fisheries worldwide
(Date:1/6/2017)... Jan. 5, 2017  Delta ID Inc., a leader ... technology for automotive at CES® 2017. Delta ID has ... to demonstrate the use of iris scanning as a ... the driver in a car, and as a way ... experience. Delta ID and Gentex will demonstrate ...
(Date:12/22/2016)... -- As part of its longstanding mission to improve genetic literacy ... released its latest children,s book, titled The One ... topics of inheritance and variation of traits that are part ... school classrooms in the US. The book ... Killoran , whose previous book with 23andMe, You ...
(Date:12/19/2016)... , España y TORONTO , 19 de diciembre ... Northern Biologics Inc. que permitirá el desarrollo acelerado de MSC-1, un ... en varios tipos de tumor en 2017, con múltiples sitios previstos ... ... clase con objetivo en el factor inhibidor de leucemia (LIF), una ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:1/21/2017)... , Jan. 20, 2017 Aratana Therapeutics, ... company focused on the licensing, development and commercialization of ... Pharm,s Best Company in North America ... the award based on the FDA approval ... (grapiprant tablets), ENTYCE ® (capromorelin oral solution) and ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... ... The two newest companies to join the University City Science Center’s Port ... The Wistar Institute, and Sanguis, launched by a trio of students from the University ... is developing a treatment for a chronic viral infection and its associated diseases, with ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... , Jan. 20, 2017 Ginkgo ... of Gen9, a pioneer in the synthesis and ... unique expertise in assembling pathway-length synthetic DNA into ... and capacity in the construction of new organism ... industries. "Gen9 was founded to significantly ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... MA (PRWEB) , ... January ... ... leader in Less Exposure Surgery (LES®) Technologies, announced today the next evolution ... PedFuse Pedicle Screw System platform). In contrast to the competition, SpineFrontier is ...
Breaking Biology Technology: