Navigation Links
California's draft Bay Delta conservation plan incomplete; needs better integration to be more scientifically credible
Date:5/5/2011

WASHINGTON A draft plan to conserve habitat for endangered and threatened fishes in the California Bay-Delta while continuing to divert water for agricultural and personal use in central and southern California has critical missing components, including clearly defined goals and a scientific analysis of the proposed project's potential impacts on delta species, says a new report from the National Research Council. In addition, the scientific information in the plan is fragmented and presented in an unconnected manner, making its meaning difficult to understand.

The delta region receives fresh water from the Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers and their tributaries, and water from the delta ultimately flows into the San Francisco Bay and the Pacific Ocean. Pumping stations divert water from the delta, primarily to supply Central Valley agriculture and southern California metropolitan areas. The effects of an increasing population and the operation of the engineered water-control system have substantially altered the delta ecosystem, including its fish species.

The November 2010 draft of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) aims to gain authorization under the federal Endangered Species Act and companion California legislation for a proposed water diversion project, such as a canal or tunnel that would take water from the northern part of the delta directly to the south while protecting the region's ecosystems. To date approximately $150 million has been spent in developing the BDCP, which is being prepared by a steering committee of federal, state, and local agencies, environmental organizations, and other interest groups. The plan is slated for completion by 2013 and would be implemented over the next 50 years.

The draft BDCP states that the principal component of a habitat conservation plan is an "effects analysis," which the plan defines as "a systematic, scientific look at the potential impacts of a proposed project on those species and how those species would benefit from conservation actions." However, the effects analysis is still being prepared and was not included in the BDCP, resulting in a critical gap in the science. Without this analysis, it is hard to evaluate alternative mitigation and conservation actions.

The BDCP lacks clarity in its purpose, which makes it difficult to properly understand, interpret, and review the science that underlies the plan, stated the panel that wrote the report. Specifically, it is unclear whether the BDCP is exclusively a habitat conservation plan to be used as an application to "take" -- meaning to injure, harass, or kill -- listed species incidentally or whether it is intended to be a plan that achieves the co-equal goals of providing reliable water supply and protecting and enhancing the delta ecosystem. If it is the latter, a more logical sequence would be to select alternative projects or operation regimes only after the effects analysis is completed.

Furthermore, the draft BDCP combines a catalog of overwhelming detail with qualitative analyses of many separate actions that often appear disconnected and poorly integrated, the panel said. There are many scientific elements, but the science is not drawn together in an integrated fashion to support the restoration activities. The panel noted that a systematic and comprehensive restoration plan needs a clearly stated strategic view of what each scientific component is intended to accomplish and how this will be done.

"There is a strong body of solid science to support some of the actions discussed in the BDCP, but because the science is not well-integrated, we are getting less from the science than we could," said panel chair Henry Vaux, professor emeritus of resource economics at the University of California in Berkeley and Riverside. "As our report concludes, a stronger and more complete BDCP -- and the panel identified several areas for improvement -- could contribute importantly to solving the problems that beset the delta."


'/>"/>

Contact: Jennifer Walsh
news@nas.edu
202-334-2138
National Academy of Sciences
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. Draft potato genome based on unique potato variety
2. First draft of the pig: Researchers sequence swine genome
3. Researchers complete draft genome sequence for cassava
4. APA announces draft diagnostic criteria for DSM-5
5. UK researchers release draft sequence coverage of wheat genome
6. Draft sequence of Neandertal genome wins the 2010 AAAS Newcomb Cleveland Prize, supported by Affymetrix
7. EPAs draft health assessment for formaldehyde needs improvement
8. Time (and PPAR-beta/delta) heals all wounds
9. River delta areas can provide clue to environmental changes, Texas A&M prof says
10. River delta areas can provide clue to environmental changes, Texas A&M prof says
11. Dolphins get a lift from delta wing technology
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:3/20/2017)... Germany , March 20, 2017 At this ... Hamburg -based biometrics manufacturer DERMALOG. The Chancellor came to the DERMALOG ... is this year,s CeBIT partner country. At the largest German ... biometrics in use: fingerprint, face and iris recognition as well as DERMALOG´s ... ...
(Date:3/9/2017)... and MOUNTAIN VIEW, Calif. , March ... Made Simple," and 23andMe , the leading personal ... food choices.  Zipongo can now provide customers with personalized ... health goals and biometrics, but also genetic markers impacting ... Zipongo,s personalized food decision support platform uses ...
(Date:3/2/2017)... Summary This report provides all ... and its partnering interests and activities since 2010. ... The Partnering Deals and Alliance since 2010 report provides ... of the world,s leading life sciences companies. ... ensure inclusion of the most up to date deal ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:3/28/2017)... Research Triangle Park, NC (PRWEB) , ... March ... ... drug development company engaged in the development of a new orally administered treatment ... Company’s Advisory Board. , CEO John Didsbury states, “As we seek to uniquely ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... 2017 Roka Bioscience, Inc. (NASDAQ: ROKA), a molecular ... detection of foodborne pathogens,  today announced that Mary Duseau ... 2017 Convention on March 29 at 9:50am ET. The conference ... About Roka Bioscience ... Roka Bioscience is a molecular ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... March 27, 2017 Cousins Properties (NYSE: ... leading biotechnology companies, has signed a 10-year, approximately 125,000 square-foot ... office asset located in the Westshore submarket of ... that Amgen has chosen Corporate Center for their new location ... , president and chief executive officer of Cousins Properties. "Amgen ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... MOSCOW , March 27, 2017 Infectex Ltd., a Russian ... Phase 2b-3 clinical study of SQ109 added to the standard drug therapy regimen in ... by scientists at Sequella, Inc. ( USA ) and the US National ... ... Maxwell Biotech Venture Fund Logo ...
Breaking Biology Technology: